[00:00:03]
ALL GOOD.[1. CALL TO ORDER, PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE, ROLL CALL]
IT IS, THIS IS THE SEDONA CITY COUNCIL MEETING ON TUESDAY, OCTOBER 27TH, 2026.I'M CALLING THE MEETING TO ORDER.
PLEASE JOIN ME IN THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE.
I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO, TO THE FLAGS OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS, ONE NATION UNDER GOD, INDIVISIBLE, WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL.
MADAM CLERK, CAN YOU CALL THE ROLE PLEASE? MAYOR PLU.
[3. CONSENT ITEMS - APPROVE]
A REQUEST TO PULL ITEM THREE H OFF OF THE CONSENT AGENDA.SO I WILL TAKE A MOTION FOR THE REMAINING ITEMS. I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE CONSENT ITEMS THREE A THROUGH G.
[4.a. AB 3408 Discussion/possible action for approval of appointment of Steve Henry as an Associate Magistrate for the Sedona Magistrate Court.]
OKAY.WE HAVE ONE APPOINTMENT, AB 34 0 8.
DISCUSSION, POSSIBLE ACTION FOR APPROVAL OF APPOINTMENT OF STEVE HENRY AS AN ASSOCIATE MAGISTRATE FOR THE SEDONA MAGISTRATE COURT.
IS HE STILL HERE? THERE HE IS.
DO YOU WANNA COME UP AND TALK ABOUT THIS APPOINTMENT? APPRECIATE IT.
HOW ARE YOU THIS EVENING? GOOD AFTERNOON, MAYOR AND COUNCIL.
THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO BE HERE.
UM, I'M ASKING THAT WE APPOINT STEVE HENRY AS AN ASSOCIATE MAGISTRATE.
UM, STEVE HENRY IS A LONG TERM LAW ENFORCEMENT CAREER, SPENT OVER 30 YEARS IN LAW ENFORCEMENT.
PRIOR TO THAT, HE RECEIVED HIS DEGREE, HIS INITIAL BACHELOR'S DEGREE FROM ARIZONA STATE UNIVERSITY, RECEIVED HIS MASTER'S IN PUBLIC LEADERSHIP, OR IN, UM, EDUCATIONAL LEADERSHIP FROM NORTHERN ARIZONA UNIVERSITY.
WAS A COMMISSIONED OFFICER IN THE UNITED STATES ARMY FOR A NUMBER OF YEARS.
SPENT OVER 30 YEARS AS A POLICE LIEUTENANT IN CHANDLER.
ALSO SPENT TIME AS A CHIEF DEPUTY IN PINAL COUNTY.
SERVED FIVE YEARS AS A DEPUTY WARDEN IN THE ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS, WHERE HE HANDLED A NUMBER OF ISSUES, UM, SUPERVISED HUNDREDS OF EMPLOYEES, MILLIONS OF DOLLARS IN BUDGETS, HANDLED THINGS THAT WERE, YOU KNOW, GRIEVANCES, POTENTIAL LAWSUITS.
HE, ON HIS OWN TIME, USING HIS OWN MONEY, UH, VOLUNTEERED TO GO TO THE NEW JUDGE ORIENTATION THAT HE ATTENDED IN JANUARY.
ATTENDED EVERY CLASS, GRADUATED WITH NO PROBLEMS, UM, IS UNDERTAKING WHERE HE IS VOLUNTEERING AS A HEARING OFFICER WHERE YOU HEAR CIVIL TRAFFIC, UM, MATTERS IN MARICOPA COUNTY, UH, JUSTICE COURTS.
AND AGAIN, I, I CAN ATTEST AT LEAST TO HIS CHARACTER, I'VE KNOWN HIM FOR OVER 30 YEARS.
HE'S NOT AN ATTORNEY, BUT HE HAS A BACKGROUND THAT WOULD MAKE HIM A VERY BIG ASSET TO US.
A LOT OF WHAT WE DO AND A LOT OF THE TIMES THAT WE NEED, WE NEED A JUDICIAL OFFICER THAT CAN HANDLE DOING ARRAIGNMENTS, DOING IN CUSTODY MATTERS, AND HANDLING CIVIL MATTERS FOR THE CITIZENS AND THE VISITORS IN SEDONA.
AND I THINK HE, I BELIEVE HE, I KNOW HE WOULD BE VERY IMPARTIAL.
HE'D EXERCISE GREAT JUDICIAL, UH, TEMPERAMENT AND, AND CONDUCT.
I THINK HE, I'M GONNA ASK THAT YOU WOULD APPOINT HIM AS THE ASSOCIATE MAGISTRATE BE ON A PART-TIME BASIS, BUT ON A NEEDED ON-CALL.
UM, VERY LIMITED IN THE NEARLY 10, OVER 10 MONTHS THAT I'VE BEEN HERE.
I THINK I'VE USED MAYBE FOUR HOURS OF ANOTHER ASSOCIATE MAGISTRATE.
SO IT'S NOT SOMETHING THAT GETS USED A LOT.
THE MONEY WAS ALREADY BUDGETED AS FAR AS UNDER OTHER CONTRACTS FOR TEMPORARY EMPLOYEES.
ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS FROM COUNSEL? THANK YOU FOR GIVING THIS THE INFORMATION.
SO I ENTERTAIN A MOTION MAYOR, I MOVE TO APPROVE THE APPOINTMENT OF STEVE HENRY AS AN ASSOCIATE JUDGE MAGISTRATE IN THE SEDONA MAGISTRATE COURT FOR A TWO YEAR TERM EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY.
[00:05:01]
UM, ARE THERE ANY CARDS FOR PUBLIC FORM? JOE, YOU HAVE SUMMARY FOR US? YEAH.UH, SUMMARY OF CURRENT EVENTS BY MAYOR COUNCILORS, CITY MANAGER, AND COUNCIL ASSIGNMENTS.
ANYBODY HAVE ANYTHING TO REPORT? OKAY.
[6. EXECUTIVE SESSION REPORT]
THEN WE'LL GO TO EXECUTIVE SESSION REPORT.MONIQUE, AFTER THE EXECUTIVE SESSION EARLIER THIS MORNING, UH, COUNSEL, UH, APPOINTED JONATHAN KIRCHNER TO THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION AS AN OFFICIAL ACTION.
DID EVERYBODY HEAR THAT? GOOD.
[7. PUBLIC FORUM]
FORUM.TIM PERRY, FOLLOWED BY CARL JACKSON AND THEN JOHN THOMPSON.
MY NAME IS TIM PERRY AND I LIVE IN SEDONA IN TONIGHT'S INSTALLMENT OF THE LIES TOLD AND PROPAGATED BY THE CITY OF SEDONA.
WE'LL REVIEW A COUPLE OF THE PIECES OF MISINFORMATION THAT CAME OUT OF TODAY'S PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION APPOINTMENT.
WE SAT HERE AND HEARD MULTIPLE APPLICANTS TALK AT THE PROMPTING OF THE CITY COUNCIL ABOUT ACHIEVING SOME KIND OF BALANCE BETWEEN PROPERTY RIGHTS AND NEIGHBOR CONCERNS, BUT NO SUCH BALANCE AS POSSIBLE.
PROPERTY RIGHTS ARE NOT UP FOR DISCUSSION.
THEY'RE AN ABSOLUTE, AT LEAST AN OUR SYSTEM.
AND WELL, IF YOU GUYS WOULD LIKE TO REVISIT THAT, THEN I HAVE MY EYE ON, UH, MELISSA DUNN'S 5,000 SQUARE FOOT MANSION THAT SHE AND HER HUSBAND OCCUPY WHILE WORKING FAMILIES LIVE IN THEIR CARS.
I'M SURE THE PEOPLE'S COMS SARS WOULD HAVE SOMETHING TO SAY ABOUT THAT UNDER A DIFFERENT SYSTEM.
YOU ARE NOT TO ADDRESS COUNCIL MEMBERS OR MEMBERS OF STAFF SPECIFICALLY BY NAME, HOLLY.
YOU ARE WELL AWARE THAT IS PERMITTED UNDER OPEN MEETING LAW AND THE PERMISSIBLE REGULATIONS MOVING ON.
PROPERTY RIGHTS ARE NOT UP FOR NEGOTIATION.
THEY CANNOT BE BALANCED WITH ZONING AND USE RESTRICTIONS BECAUSE ZONING AND USE RESTRICTIONS ARE NOTHING BUT AN ATTEMPT TO SUBVERT PROPERTY RIGHTS.
IN FACT, I'M STILL WAITING TO SEE IF SOMEBODY'S GONNA SUE YOU GUYS OVER UNDER PROP 2 0 7 OVER THE PICKLEBALL COURT BAN, WHICH IS STILL OUT THERE.
ANOTHER PIECE OF MISINFORMATION THAT WE HEARD FROM MULTIPLE APPLICANTS TODAY WAS THE STATEMENT THAT, UH, WHILE THERE'S SO LITTLE LAND TO BUILD ON IN SEDONA, AS WE ALL KNOW, STAFF INCLUDED, WE HAVE OVER A THOUSAND VACANT LOTS LEFT IN THIS TOWN, UH, ON WHICH YOU COULD BUILD PROBABLY 2000 HOUSES.
AND THAT'S NOT INCLUDING CITY OWNED LAND, EXCLUDING THE CULTURAL PARK ON THE DELLS ON WHICH YOU COULD BUILD ANOTHER THOUSAND HOUSES.
THE MYTH THAT WE HAVE NO LAND LEFT FOR HOUSING, AND THAT'S A CAUSE OF THE HOUSING SHORTAGE OF THE PIECE OF STAFF DERIVED MISINFORMATION THAT NEEDS TO STOP BEING DISSEMINATED.
IT WAS ALSO RATHER RIDICULOUS TO SEE COUNSEL ADVANCING TO THE FINAL ROUND AND APPLICANT WHO EXPRESSED HER, DISCUSSED BY THE PEOPLE'S TWO TO ONE DECISION TO REJECT THE COUNCIL'S CONCENTRATION CAMP PROPOSAL DURING A DISCUSSION OF UNDERSTANDING COMMUNITY VALUES IN A FIRST, THE COUNCIL DESERVES A VERY SMALL PAT ON THE HEAD FOR MAKING A GOOD APPOINTMENT TO THE PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION, A WORKING PERSON WITH EXPERIENCE IN CONSTRUCTION AND KIDS IN THE COMMUNITY RATHER THAN ANOTHER RETIRED LEFT COAST LIBERAL.
LET'S MAKE THIS A TREND, SHALL WE? OKAY.
CARL JACKSON, NICE TO SEE YOU.
THANK YOU MAYOR AND COUNCIL FOR HEARING ME.
UH, THE REASON I'M HERE TODAY, I JUST WANNA GO ON IN AN OPEN MEETING ON A PUBLIC FORUM, ON A PROPOSAL TO MODERNIZE, UH, SEDONAS DEFINITION OF FAMILY IN THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE AND SPECIFICALLY, UH, MODERNIZE IT BY ALIGNING IT WITH THE SCOTTSDALE DEFINITION.
SO NOTHING NEW, SOMETHING THAT SCOTTSDALE'S DOING.
AND AS AN OVERVIEW, THE CURRENT DEFINITION OF FAMILY IN THE SEDONA CODE IS BROKEN UP INTO HIGH LEVEL TWO UNEQUAL PARTS.
ONE IS A TRADITIONAL FAMILY, WHICH IS PEOPLE WHO ARE RELATED BY BLOOD MARRIAGE OR ADOPTION, AND IT'S VERY OPEN-ENDED.
AND THEN ANOTHER CLASS OF FAMILY, WHICH I GUESS TYPICALLY WOULD BE CALLED FUNCTIONAL FAMILIES, WHICH IS A STRICT CAP OF NO MORE THAN FOUR UNRELATED ADULTS.
SO WHAT, UM, SCOTTSDALE DOES IS THEY GET RID OF ALL THAT DISTINCTION BETWEEN WHAT IS A FAMILY, WHAT IS NOT A FAMILY, AND JUST SAYS
[00:10:01]
A FAMILY IS NO MORE THAN SIX ADULTS, UH, WITH DEPENDENT CHILDREN.AND SO THE QUESTION IS, WHAT PUBLIC BENEFIT WOULD IT BE TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF FAMILY IN THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE? AND THERE'S THREE BASIC, UH, PUBLIC BENEFITS I SEE.
ONE IS, IS THAT WE BRING BACK FAIRNESS, OBJECTIVITY, AND INCLUSION TO THE DEFINITION OF FAMILY.
WE NO LONGER SINGLE OUT TRADITIONAL FAMILIES AS BEING SOME PINNACLE WE ALL WANNA ATTAIN.
THERE'S A LOT OF DIFFERENT TYPES OF STRUCTURES OF FAMILIES IN SEDONA, AND I THINK WE WANNA INCLUDE EVERYBODY IN THE, IN THE COMMUNITY.
UH, THE SECOND REASON TO DO IT, TO MAKE SIX AS YOUR ADULT, UH, FOR A FAMILY IS TO EXPAND THE WORKFORCE.
SO RIGHT NOW, THE DEFINITION OF FAMILY IN THE SEDONA CODE SAYS IT'S NO MORE THAN FOUR UNRELATED ADULTS.
SO BY MAKING IT SIX AND ALIGNING TO SCOTTSDALE, IT CREATES MORE WORKFORCE AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES IN THE COMMUNITY.
AND THE LAST ONE WOULD BE PROTECTING THE INFRASTRUCTURE AND FIRE EGRESS.
SO BY CAPPING FAMILY AND MAKING FAMILY SIX ADULTS, IT WOULD TAKE PRESSURE OFF INFRASTRUCTURE LIKE SEPTIC SYSTEMS, WHICH WE KNOW IN SMALL NEIGHBORHOODS ARE CAN GET OVERRUN AS WELL AS FIRE EGRESS.
UH, SO BASICALLY LESS CONGESTION IF THERE'S A FIRE IN SEDONA.
AND SO IT'S VERY EASY TO CHANGE THIS DEFINITION.
WE'D RUN THROUGH THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, APPLY TO ALL SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL ZONING AND BE EQUAL FOR OWNER OCCUPIED LONG-TERM LEASE OR TRANSIENT.
IT WOULD BE VERY FAIR, VERY BALANCED, AND VERY OBJECTIVE.
CARL, CAN YOU GIVE THAT, UH, INFORMATION TO THE JOANNE CITY CLERK? YES.
YEAH, I, I'D LIKE US TO DIRECT STAFF TO, UM, STUDY THAT MATTER, PLEASE.
MAYOR PLU AND COUNCILOR KINSELLA.
UM, THE, UH, PROJECT THAT TONY ALLEN, OUR COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR'S WORKING ON, IS CURRENTLY UNDERWAY ALREADY FOR THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE UPDATES.
WE'LL PROVIDE THIS FEEDBACK TO THANK YOU.
SO CAN WE HAVE SEATS OVER HERE? I WOULD LIKE TO SEE PEOPLE STANDING UNLESS THEY CHOOSE TO WHEN WE HAVE SEATS AVAILABLE.
SO IF SERVICE AVAILABLE, I'LL BE LEAVING.
ANYBODY WANTS TO COME OVER AND SIT IN THESE SEATS, YOU'RE WELCOME TO DO THAT.
AND, UH, GOOD E UH, GOOD AFTERNOON EVERYONE.
I'M JOHN THOMPSON, RESIDENT OF SEDONA.
OUR LAST MOMENT OF MOO ENDED WITH A CHART SHOWING THAT BEEF CONTRIBUTED FAR MORE GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS THAN ANY OTHER FOOD.
IN FACT, JUST THE METHANE FROM CATTLE ACCOUNTS FOR 5% OF THE ENTIRE WORLD'S GREENHOUSE GASES.
BUT BEEF CONSUMPTION CONTRIBUTES TO THE ABUSE OF THE PLANET IN OTHER WAYS AS WELL.
CONSIDER THE USE OF WORLDWIDE CROP LAND.
ALL THE WORLD'S LAND CURRENTLY BEING USED TO GROW CROPS COULD PROVIDE ENOUGH CALORIES TO FEED 14 AND A HALF BILLION PEOPLE, WHICH HAS NEARLY DOUBLE OUR CURRENT POPULATION.
YET ONLY 45% OF THE CALORIES PRODUCED ON THAT LAND ARE FOR HUMAN CONSUMPTION, WHILE ANOTHER 40% OF THOSE CALORIES FEED ONLY CATTLE, BIG PIGS, CHICKENS, AND OTHER LIVESTOCK.
AND THE LARGEST SHARE OF THAT LIVESTOCK FEED OVER 41% OF IT IS JUST FOR BEEF AND DAIRY CATTLE.
SO TO SIMPLIFY THE MATH HERE, LESS THAN HALF OF THE CALORIES PRODUCED BY THE WORLD'S CROP LAND GOES DIRECTLY TO FEEDING PEOPLE, AND 30% OF THE REST OF IT FEEDS BEEF AND DAIRY CATTLE.
SO HOW CAN SHE PULL AN ITEM THAT DISPROPORTION IS EASIER TO BELIEVE WHEN YOU CONSIDER THAT THERE ARE OVER ONE AND A HALF BILLION BEEF AND DAIRY CATTLE BEING RAISED WORLDWIDE AT ANY GIVEN POINT IN TIME.
BUT OF COURSE, ALL THE BEEF AND MILK PRODUCTS DERIVED FROM THOSE CATTLE IS FOOD FOR PEOPLE AND IS, IN FAIRNESS, WE NEED TO CONSIDER THAT TOO.
UNFORTUNATELY, ALL ANIMAL FOODS COMBINED ADD LESS THAN 5% CALORIES TO THE 45% OF PLANT CROPS GROWN ON THE WORLD'S CROPLANDS, INCLUDING JUST 1.8% FOR DAIRY PRODUCTS, AND LESS THAN A HALF OF 1% COMING FROM BEEF CATTLE.
SO A LOT OF CALORIES ARE BEING LOST IN THE PROCESS.
IT'S BAD ENOUGH THAT IT TAKES TWO AND A HALF CALORIES OF ANIMAL FEED TO PRODUCE ONE CALORIE OF MILK AND 10 CALORIES OF FEED TO PRODUCE JUST ONE CALORIE OF CHICKEN OR PORK.
BUT BEEF, ONCE AGAIN, IS THE WORST BARGAIN BY FAR, WITH ONLY ONE CALORIE PRODUCED FOR EVERY 33 CALORIES OF
[00:15:01]
FEED.SO IT'S ONLY FAIR TO ASK WHY DO WE HAVE CATTLE CHEW OUR FOOD FOR US WHEN ALL WE ARE LEFT WITH IS 3% OF THE CALORIES, NOT TO MENTION A LOT OF DEAD ANIMALS.
I WELCOME ANY FEEDBACK OR QUESTIONS ON SEDONA AT SEDONA, JOHN@ME.COM.
ROBERT KOSTER, FOLLOWED BY JIM MURPHY AND HENRY SILBERG AND SANDRA OF ROBERT KOSTER.
I'M A RESIDENT OF SEDONA AND HOLLY, I JUST WANT TO THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR COMING UP BEFORE THIS MEETING AND RECOGNIZING THAT THE CULTURAL PARK IS NOW ON THE CITY WEBSITE AS A, UH, PARK.
I JUST SAY THANK YOU FOR THAT.
I AM A RESIDENT OF SEDONA, AND I'M FOLLOWING UP ON A CONVERSATION I HAD DURING A BREAK, UH, WITH THE CITY, UH, COUNCIL MEETING REGARDING POTENTIAL CONCRETE COURT TESTING FAILURES AT THE UPTOWN GARAGE AND THAT I BROUGHT UP DURING THE BREAK, UH, WITH BOTH HOLLY YU AND, AND BRIAN, UH, ASKING TO HAVE IT AS AGENDA ITEM FOR THE CITY COUNCIL MEETING.
OUR INTENT IN JUST OUR INTENT TODAY IS IN, IN DOING IT AS PURELY SAFETY AND IS TO HIGHLIGHT POTENTIAL FAILURES AND TESTING, OBTAIN FROM A DATA REQUEST OF CONCRETE CYLINDER REPORTS AND REQUEST CITY COUNCIL AND QUALIFIED STAFF AND ENGINEERING TO INVESTIGATE FAILED AN INCOMPLETE TEST AND REPORT ON REMEDIATION TAKEN.
AND WE ARE NOT IN ENGINEERS EITHER, UM, UH, FAR FROM IT IN MY CASE.
UM, UH, BUT, BUT WE HOLD THE CITY COUNCIL AND STAFF ACCOUNTABLE TO ADDRESS POTENTIAL FAILURES AND TO BE TRANSPARENT AND FULLY DISCLOSING THE RESULTS.
AND REMEDIATIONS OUR PURPOSE FOR STANDING UP TODAY IS TO ENSURE THAT THESE POTENTIAL SAFETY CONCERNS FOR THE UPTOWN GARAGE ARE EACH ADDRESSED AND THE REMEDIATIONS SHARED WITH FULL TRANSPARENCY.
UM, WE, WE ELECTED NOT TO BRING THIS BACK TO STAFF AS SUGGESTED DURING THE OCTOBER 13TH CONVERSATION AS IF THERE ARE ISSUES WITH THE TESTING.
WE'RE NOT SURE WHERE THE POTENTIAL ACCOUNTABLE ACCOUNTABILITY MAY LAY.
THIS IS POTENTIALLY JUST THE, YOU KNOW, ONE OF ANOTHER CHAPTER I KNOW FOR THE UPTOWN GARAGE.
I KNOW IT'S A PAINFUL TOPIC, YOU KNOW, FROM THE, UH, ESCALATING COST FROM 17 AND A HALF TO APPROACHING 40 MILLION AND THE OVERALL IMPACT ON RESIDENTS AND BUSINESSES, THE ENGINEERING FACADE, AND MOST RECENTLY LACK OF WATER PRESSURE TO SATISFY THE EXISTING FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEM NEEDS.
NOW WE HAVE A POTENTIAL PUBLIC SAFETY CONCERN AND THAT COULD EXPOSE THE CITY'S SIGNIFICANT LIABILITY AND THE PARKING PUBLIC TO DANGEROUS POTENTIAL FLAWS IN CONSTRUCTION.
IF THERE ARE NONE, YOU KNOW, AS WE HOPE.
UM, THEN DISCLOSE, UM, AN UPDATED TESTING AND A REMEDIATION MADE PUBLIC WILL BE GREETED WITH A COLLECTIVE SIGH OF RELIEF BY ALL.
THE CONCERN WAS CONVEYED TO US FROM A CITY EMPLOYEE AS PRESIDENT OF A CITY STAFF MEETING WHEN THE ISSUE WAS FIRST RAISED.
AND WE EXPECT A TIMELY RESPONSE JUST SO THAT WE CAN PUT THIS ONE TO BED.
SEDONA, I ALSO WANNA THANK YOU FOR, UH, FOLLOWING THROUGH ON YOUR COMMITMENT TO ADD THE CULTURAL PARK TO THE PARK WEBSITE, THOUGH.
UH, I WANTED TO FOLLOW UP ON ROBERT'S CONVERSATION.
THIS ALL IS RELATED TO PUBLIC SAFETY AS IT RELATES TO OUR UPTOWN GARAGE.
AFTER HEARING THAT ONE OF YOUR CITY EMPLOYEES WAS PRESENT AT A STAFF MEETING WHERE CONCRETE TESTING FAILURES WERE QUICKLY DISMISSED, I DECIDED TO SUBMIT A PUBLIC RECORDS REQUEST AND ASSESS THE COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH TESTS FOR THE CONCRETE THAT WAS POURED IN THE UPTOWN GARAGE.
AND TONIGHT I BROUGHT THE RECEIPTS.
I REVIEWED OVER A HUNDRED TESTS FROM DIFFERENT CONCRETE PORES DURING THE CONSTRUCTION OF THE STRUCTURE, AND FOUND THAT 24 EITHER HAVE FAILURES OR INCOMPLETE TESTING THAT WOULD LEAD ME TO BELIEVE THAT THAT TESTING WAS STOPPED WHEN CONCRETE WAS DEEMED TO NEVER MEET THE STRENGTHS, UH, THAT WERE SPECIFIED BY THE ENGINEER.
LET ME QUALIFY THOSE SPECIFIC FAILURES TONIGHT AND NOTE THAT IT DOES SAY ON THESE SHEETS THAT IT IS A FAILURE.
THIS IS NOT MY INTERPRETATION.
UH, YOUR THIRD PARTY FACILITY IN GILBERT WAS THE ONE THAT PROVIDED THE ANALYSIS.
AND SO IT SHOULD BE NOTED THAT THESE FAILURES WERE NOT JUST ONE PART OF THE PARKING STRUCTURE.
THERE WERE FAILURES IN THE COLUMNS, THE DECKS, THE PARKING RAMPS, AND
[00:20:01]
THE WALLS.ALL ASPECTS OF THE GARAGE HAD FAILURES.
AND TONIGHT, I'M GONNA HIGHLIGHT THREE OF THOSE.
ON TWO OCCASIONS, STRENGTHS AND SLUMP TESTS BOTH FAILED.
UH, THEY WERE MUCH LOWER THAN THE ENGINEER'S SPECIFICATIONS DECKS ON TWO OCCASIONS FAILED MISERABLY AGAINST 5,000 PSI AND BAD SLUMP FAILURES.
AND LASTLY, WHICH WAS MOST, UH, MOST SERIOUS WERE MULTIPLE WALL FAILURES.
UH, AGAIN, I THINK YOU'D ALL AGREE THAT COLUMNS, WALLS, AND, UH, DECKS ARE IMPORTANT FOR THESE, FOR THIS STRUCTURE TO STAND LONG TERM.
YOU MIGHT BE ASKING YOURSELF, WHAT DOES A RESIDENT KNOW ABOUT FAILING CONCRETE TESTS AND HOW LEGIT ARE MY CONCERNS? SO LET ME TELL YOU FIRST, I HAVE LIMITED CONSTRUCTION TIME AROUND CONCRETE, ABOUT EIGHT YEARS.
BUT MORE IMPRESSIVE WAS THE COUNCIL THAT I GOT FROM EXPERTS IN THE FIELD.
I SPOKE TO TWO BUILDING INSPECTORS, NOT SEDONAS, A DEPUTY INSPECTOR WHO SPECIALIZED IN CONCRETE, TWO CONCRETE CONTRACTORS AND A CIVIL ENGINEER.
ALL OF THESE PEOPLE CONFIRMED THAT THESE TEST ANALYSIS HIGHLIGHT MULTIPLE PUBLIC SAFETY ISSUES THAT SHOULD HAVE BEEN EXPOSED DURING CONSTRUCTION AND SUBSEQUENT INSPECTION.
SO I CAN CONFIDENTLY STAND BEFORE YOU TODAY AND SAY THAT IF THESE HAVE NOT BEEN RESOLVED, THERE ARE SERIOUS SAFETY CONCERNS WITH OUR PARKING GARAGE.
AFTER WATCHING MR. DICKEY AT LAST MONTH'S MEETING EXPLAINED WHAT HAPPENED WITH FIRE SUPPRESSION FAILURE, IT LEAVES ME LITTLE CONFIDENCE THAT THESE WERE ADDRESSED WHEN THEY WERE DIS UH, DISCOVERED THE NUMBER ONE JOB OF CITY MANAGEMENT.
AND YOU MAY NOT HAVE HEARD ABOUT THIS THESE PROBLEMS BEFORE TONIGHT, BUT YOU CERTAINLY ARE AWARE OF NOW.
SO I APPRECIATE YOUR TIME TONIGHT.
I LIVE IN SEDONA, THE SEDONA PARKING GARAGE.
AND YOU'RE GONNA HAVE TO GIMME A SECOND.
THE SEDONA PARKING GARAGE PROJECT HAS BEEN A BEEN PLAGUED BY CONCERNS FROM BEGINNING.
IT WAS PUSHED THROUGH DURING EMERGENCY SESSION, DESPITE RESIDENT OBJECTIONS, THE COST IS NOW APPROACHING EIGHT 40 MILLION.
AND AFTER REPORTS OF FACADE FAILURE, A HISTORY OF WATER ISSUES AND LAWSUITS, WE ARE NOW FACING CONCERNS ABOUT CONCRETE FAILURES.
THESE DEVELOPERS RAISED SERIOUS QUESTIONS THAT DESERVE CLEAR AND PUBLIC ANSWERS.
I AM ASKING THE COUNCIL TO ADDRESS THE FOLLOWING.
WERE THE COUNCIL AND CITY STAFF AWARE OF REPORTS DOCUMENTING CONCRETE FAILURES? WHICH SPECIFIC MEMBERS OF STAFF ATTENDED THE MEETINGS WHERE THESE FAILURES WERE DISCUSSED? THREE.
WHAT ACTIONS WERE TAKEN WHEN THESE ISSUES WERE RAISED? AND WHAT WAS THE TIMELINE? FOUR.
IF THE COUNCIL WAS NOT INFORMED, WHY WAS THIS CRITICAL SAFETY INFORMATION WITHHELD? FIVE.
IF YOU WERE INFORMED WHAT TECHNICAL ASSESSMENTS ESTABLISHED THAT THESE ISSUES WERE ADEQUATELY ADDRESSED, THESE ARE NOT MINOR CONSTRUCTION'S CONCERNS.
IF THE FAILURES POSE A RISK TO THE PUBLIC, RESIDENTS DESERVE TO KNOW THE EXTENT OF THAT RISK.
AND WHETHER CORRECTIVE MEASURES HAVE BEEN INDEPENDENTLY VERIFIED UNTIL THE SAFETY OF THE STRUCTURES ESTABLISHED BY QUALIFIED PROFESSIONALS.
I WOULD BE RELUCTANT TO RECOMMEND THAT ANYONE USE THE GARAGE.
I AM FORMALLY REQUESTING THAT THE FOLLOW UP ON THE CONCRETE FAILURE REPORTS BE ADDED AS AN AGENDA ITEM FOR THE NOVEMBER CITY COUNCIL MEETING.
THE PUBLIC DESERVES THE TRANSPARENT ACCOUNT OF WHAT HAPPENED AND WHEN IT HAPPENED.
AND WHO KNEW? I REMIND YOU OF JULY 25 WHEN THE COUNCIL ASKED FOR PROOF OF THE PROJECT'S FINANCIAL VIABILITY.
THOSE QUESTIONS WERE LARGELY DEFERRED, YET THE PROJECT WAS SEATED.
WE CANNOT ALLOW CONCERNS TO BE DISMISSED AGAIN THIS TIME.
IT'S NOT JUST ABOUT FINANCIAL ACCOUNTABILITY, BUT PUBLIC SAFETY.
WE EXPECT YOU TO PURSUE ACCOUNTABILITY FOR ANYONE WHOSE ACTIONS OR MISSIONS MAY HAVE COMPRISED SAFETY.
WHETHER THROUGH A FAILURE TO ACT OR A FAILURE TO DISCLOSE MATERIAL INFORMATION, IMAGINE THE CONSEQUENCES OF A STRUCTURE FAILURE BEYOND THE HUMAN TRAGEDY.
THE CITY WOULD FACE DEVASTATING LEGAL AND FINANCIAL FALLOUT.
ESTABLISH THE FACTS, DISCLOSE WHAT IS KNOWN, AND ENSURE ALL CORRECTIVE MEASURES ARE VERIFIED.
LASTLY, LET'S NOT USE THE EXISTING MANAGER'S SCAPEGOAT FOR COLLECTIVE LACK OF KNOWLEDGE.
THE RESIDENTS OF SEDONA DESERVE TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY.
GOOD EVENING, MAYOR, MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL.
I'M A REGISTERED NURSE AND A RESIDENT OF SEDONA.
EARLIER THIS EVENING, I HEARD COMMENTS FROM RESIDENTS ABOUT POTENTIAL
[00:25:01]
SAFETY CONCERNS WITH THE UPTOWN GARAGE.I AGREE 100% THAT THE CITY NEEDS TO FULLY INVESTIGATE THOSE ISSUES AND PUBLICLY DISCLOSE ALL FINDINGS TO THE COMMUNITY.
TRANSPARENCY HAS BEEN MENTIONED SEVERAL TIMES TONIGHT.
THIS COUNCIL HAS NOT ALWAYS BEEN OPEN WITH RESIDENTS ABOUT COST AND PROBLEMS. AS THEY DEVELOP, WE ELECT YOU TO OVERSEE THESE PROJECTS WHEN CAUSED SPIRAL OUT OF CONTROL.
WHEN WATER SUPPRESSION ISSUES ARISE THAT COST THE COMMUNITY MONEY THAT COULD HAVE BEEN BETTER USED ELSEWHERE WITH ADEQUATE PLANNING OR WHEN LIMITS ON PARKING AND POSSIBLE FUTURE CHARGES ARE ONLY DISCLOSED LATE IN THE PROCESS.
THE IMPACT IS GREATER IN TRUST ROADS QUICKLY.
RESIDENTS DESERVE TO KNOW THESE THINGS WHILE DECISIONS ARE STILL BEING MADE, NOT AFTER THE FACT.
I'VE HEARD SOME OF YOU SAY, I'M NOT AN ENGINEER.
WE ELECTED YOU TO PROVIDE OVERSIGHT.
ASK THE HARD QUESTIONS AND HOLD THE PROFESSIONALS ACCOUNTABLE.
WHEN PROBLEMS SURFACE, THE RESPONSIBILITY DOES NOT STOP WITH THE CONSULTANTS OR THE CONTRACTORS.
IT STOPS WITH THE COUNCIL THAT APPROVED AND CONTINUES TO OVERSEE THE PROJECT.
IF A PATIENT DEVELOPS A FEVER THAT PROGRESSES TO SEPSIS AND DEATH, I CANNOT SAY MY ASSISTANT DIDN'T NOTIFY ME.
I AM THE ULTIMATE RESPONSIBLE PERSON.
THE SAME PRINCIPLE APPLIES HERE.
YOU CANNOT PASS RESPONSIBILITY DOWN THE LINE WHEN THINGS GO WRONG.
PRESIDENT TRUMAN MADE THIS PRINCIPLE FAMOUS WITH THE SIGN ON HIS DESK, SAID, THE BUCK STOPS HERE LATER, PRESIDENTS ECHOED IT.
PRESIDENT OBAMA SAID, ULTIMATELY THE BUCK STOPS WITH ME.
AND PRESIDENT BIDEN HAS USED THE SAME WORDS.
THAT IS THE STANDARD PRESIDENTS EXPECT FROM THIS COUNCIL AS WELL.
THE CITY IS ACCOUNTABLE TO US FOR THE DECISIONS YOU MAKE, AND YOU IN TURN MUST HOLD OTHERS ACCOUNTABLE WHEN THERE IS FAULT.
NO SWEET PROBLEMS UNDER THE RUG.
I URGE YOU TO INVESTIGATE THE SAFETY CONCERNS RAISED TONIGHT, RAISE THE FULL FINDINGS AND COMMIT TO GREATER OPENNESS GOING FORWARD ON THIS AND FUTURE PROJECTS.
OKAY, THAT'S ALL THE CARDS I HAVE.
UH, KEVIN, AS OUR INTERIM CITY MANAGER, CAN YOU ADDRESS THIS ISSUE AND BRING IT BACK TO COUNCIL IN A WAY THAT YOU FEEL WOULD BENEFIT US AND THE PUBLIC? THANK YOU.
UH, NOW WE'RE ON REGULAR BUSINESS.
I'M GOING TO, UH, TO DEAL WITH THE ITEM THAT WAS TAKEN OFF OF CONSENT, BUT AFTER THAT I'M GONNA SWITCH THE AGENDA ITEMS SO THAT THE PRESENTATION DISCUSSION FROM THE UNITED STATES FOREST SERVICE ET ALL WILL BE THE FIRST ITEM ON THE AGENDA SINCE YOU ARE ALL HERE FOR THAT DISCUSSION.
[9.a. Discussion/possible action regarding items pulled off “3. Consent Items”.]
FIRST, WE'RE GOING TO DO THE ITEM THAT WAS REMOVED FROM CONSENT.SO, JEN, DO YOU WANNA COME UP TO THE PODIUM? THANK YOU MAYOR.
CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS AND CITY STAFF.
MY NAME IS JEN FARNSWORTH AND I'M A RESIDENT OF UPTOWN SEDONA.
BEFORE SIGNING THE MOU WITH ARIZONA WATER, I ASK THAT YOU GET ADDITIONAL ANSWERS TO THE QUESTIONS THAT CONFIRM THE FIRE FLOW NEEDS FOR THE GARAGE ARE IN FACT 1500 GALLONS PER MINUTE FOR TWO HOURS BY SPECIFICALLY DOCUMENTING WHAT THAT ALLOCATION WILL MEET AND HOW IT WILL MEET.
CRITICAL FIRE SUPPRESSION NEEDS ANY REFERENCE TO GARAGE FIRE.
HAZARD CODE PRIOR TO 2022 IS OUTDATED.
THE CITY IS CLAIMING A 25% FIRE FLOW CREDIT, WHICH MEANS THE CITY IS SAYING THE GARAGE WILL NEED LESS WATER USING OLDER CODE EXEMPTIONS.
THIS SEEMS CONTRARY TO THE CONTRACT REQUIREMENTS FOR THE GARAGE.
AND THE EXEMPTION ALLOWS THE CITY TO CALL THE BUILDING FULLY SPRINKLERED.
IT IS NOT, NOT ONLY DOES THE TOP DECK WITH A POTENTIAL OCCUPANCY OF 460 LIVES HAVE NO SPRINKLERS, IT HAS NO AUTOMATIC FIRE SUPPRESSION AT ALL THIS IMPACTS.
JEN, YOU HAVE TO STICK TO THE MOU.
UM, UM, THE SPRINKLERS ARE NOT CONTAINED IN THE MOU AND YOU CAN'T BE DISCUSSING ANYTHING OTHER THAN WHAT'S IN THE MOU.
WE, YOU AND I HAD THIS CONVERSATION EARLIER TODAY.
I GUESS WHAT I'M, THE POINT I'M TRYING TO MAKE IS THAT IT RELATES TO HOW MUCH WATER THE GARAGE NEEDS.
AND THAT'S A COMPONENT OF THE MOU.
IS THAT TOO VAGUE? I MEAN, DURING PUBLIC FORUM, MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC ARE ENTITLED TO SPEAK ON WHATEVER ITEMS THEY WANT.
WHEN YOU PULL AN ITEM FROM THE AGENDA, YOU NEED TO STICK WITH WHAT'S IN THE AGENDA BILL AND WHAT'S IN THE AGENDA.
AND IN THIS PARTICULAR INSTANCE, IT'S JUST THE AGREEMENT WITH ARIZONA WATER COMPANY THAT WAS ON THE CONSENT AGREEMENT.
THERE'S NOTHING ABOUT, UM, THE SPRINKLERS OR ENGINEERING.
IT'S, IT'S JUST THE AGREEMENT.
[00:30:01]
NEEDS ARE DIRECTLY CONNECTED TO THE, THE SPRINKLERS ON THE TOP DECK.AND THAT WAS THE POINT I WAS TRYING TO MAKE.
BUT IT, BUT THAT'S NOT INCLUDED IN THE AGREEMENT.
UM, I GUESS I CAN'T KEEP SPEAKING THEN.
I OFFERED YOU AN OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK TO ALL OF THIS ON THE PUBLIC FORUM AND YOU CHOSE TO DO IT UNDER THIS ITEM.
AND I THOUGHT IT WAS CONNECTED, SO I APOLOGIZE.
I THOUGHT IT'S ALL RELATED TO HOW MUCH WATER NEEDS TO BE A PART OF THE MOU.
SO I TAKE A MOTION ON THIS ITEM.
MAYOR, I MOVE TO APPROVE AB 33 70, UH, WHICH IS ITEM THREE H FROM THE CONSENT AGENDA.
SECOND, ARE THERE ANY COMMENT YOU WANTED TO MAKE A COMMENT ON THE CONSENT AGENDA? NOT THIS ITEM.
WE'VE GOT A RULING ABOUT WHAT WE CAN DO ON CONSENT ITEMS. OKAY.
DO YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS? I HAVE NOTHING.
ANYBODY HAVE ANY QUESTIONS? ALRIGHT, ALL THOSE IN FAVOR? A AYE.
[9.c. AB 3339 Presentation/discussion by United States Forest Service Red Rock Ranger District, Red Rock Trail Fund, Verde Valley Cyclist Coalition and Friends of the Forest regarding Sedona area trail system projects and partnerships.]
PERFECT.CAN Y'ALL HEAR ME OKAY? PERFECT.
AND I, BEFORE YOU START, I REPEAT THAT THERE ARE SEATS OVER HERE.
IF PEOPLE ARE STANDING, FEEL FREE TO COME AND SIT.
THERE'S ALSO A SEAT RIGHT UP FRONT.
AND MAY I, A PERSONAL POINT OF PRIVILEGE.
I WANNA READ A LETTER WHICH IS RELEVANT TO THIS DISCUSSION THAT I RECEIVED FROM THOMAS TORRES, WHO IS THE STATE FORESTER AND DIRECTOR OF THE ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF FORESTRY AND FIRE MANAGEMENT.
HE, UH, AND HE WROTE, DEAR MAYOR PLU, THANK YOU FOR YOUR SEPTEMBER 14TH LETTER, RECOGNIZING THE EFFORTS OF THE ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF FORESTRY AND FIRE MANAGEMENT DURING THE POCKET FIRE.
ON BEHALF OF OUR ENTIRE TEAM, I SINCERELY APPRECIATE YOUR THOUGHTFUL WORDS AND THE GRATITUDE EXPRESSED BY THE SEDONA COMMUNITY.
I AM PROUD OF THE PROFESSIONALISM, DEDICATION, AND RESOLVE OUR EMPLOYEES BRING TO PROTECTING ARIZONA'S COMMUNITIES.
YOUR RECOGNITION MEANS A GREAT DEAL TO ALL OF THE EMPLOYEES OF DFFM, WHOSE COLLECTIVE EFFORTS MAKE OUR RESPONSE POSSIBLE.
KNOWING THEIR WORK IS VALUED BY THE PEOPLE THEY SERVE IS ESPECIALLY MEANINGFUL.
THANK YOU ALSO FOR THE COMMEMORATIVE BANNERS BEARING THE SIGNATURES OF SEDONA COMMUNITY MEMBERS.
AND I HOPE SOME OF YOU, ALL OF YOU SIGN THEM.
THIS PERSONAL EXPRESSION OF APPRECIATION AND THEIR CONNECTION TO AMERICA'S 250TH CELEBRATION MAKES THEM A SPECIAL TRIBUTE TO PUBLIC SERVICE AND THE RELATIONSHIPS THAT UNITE OUR COMMUNITIES.
THE POCKET FIRE RESPONSE REFLECTS THE IMPORTANCE OF STRONG PARTNERSHIPS AMONG LOCAL, STATE, AND FEDERAL RESPONDERS AND THE COMMUNITIES WE SERVE.
WE VALUE OUR RELATIONSHIP WITH SEDONA AND REMAIN COMMITTED TO WORKING TOGETHER TO STRENGTHEN WILDFIRE PREPAREDNESS AND COMMUNITY RESILIENCE.
PLEASE EXTEND MY THANKS TO THE CITY COUNCIL AND THE RESIDENTS OF SEDONA FOR THEIR GENEROSITY AND SUPPORT.
I WILL TOUCH A LITTLE BIT ON THE POCKET FIRE AND APPRECIATE YOUR FLEXIBILITY.
I WAS PLANNING TO GIVE A PRESENTATION SIMILAR TO WHAT I'LL TALK ABOUT TONIGHT, EARLIER THIS SUMMER, AND WE INSTEAD TALKED ABOUT THE POCKET FIRE.
SO, UM, THINGS CHANGE QUICKLY AROUND HERE SOMETIMES, AND I APPRECIATE YOUR FLEXIBILITY.
ALSO, START WITH A COUPLE THANK YOUS.
THANK YOU FOR THE OUTGOING COUNSELORS.
UH, YOUR SERVICE IS REALLY FOR THIS COMMUNITY AND, AND FOR US.
RELATIONSHIPS WE HAVE ARE REALLY POSITIVE.
THAT'S A SOMETHING I DON'T TAKE FOR GRANTED, AND I APPRECIATE THE TIME YOU SPENT IN THIS ROLE.
UH, I I HOPE THAT THE NEW COUNSELORS, WE HAVE SIMILAR POSITIVE RELATIONSHIP.
AND I ALSO WANTED TO POINT OUT ANNETTE, OUR, OUR CITY MANAGER HERE.
UM, I FOUND YOU TO BE NOTHING BUT THOUGHTFUL, APPROACHABLE, AND COMPETENT.
AND I REALLY, REALLY APPRECIATE THE LAST COUPLE YEARS AND THE PARTNERSHIP THAT OUR AGENT, OUR ORGANIZATIONS HAVE.
AND I HOPE TO CONTINUE THE SAME WITH MR. PHELPS.
SO WITH THAT, UH, I'M GONNA TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT SOME
[00:35:01]
NATIONAL LEVEL, UH, CHANGES IN THE AGENCY THAT WE HAVE GOING ON.AND THEN I'LL ZOOM IN HERE LOCALLY AND TALK, UH, LOTS ABOUT DIFFERENT RESOURCES THAT WE HAVE.
DIFFERENT PROJECTS ARE PLANNED IN THE NEXT YEAR, AND IF YOU HAVE QUESTIONS, FEEL FREE TO, TO ASK THEM MID PRESENTATION OR, OR HOLD 'EM TO THE END.
WHATEVER, WHATEVER MAKES SENSE FOR YOU ALL.
SO, MOVING ON TO THE THE NEXT SLIDE.
I ALWAYS TRY TO START THIS WITH PUBLIC PRESENTATIONS AND REMIND FOLKS THAT THE FOREST SERVICE DOES MORE THAN JUST MANAGE OUTDOOR RECREATION.
IT IS INCREDIBLY PREVALENT HERE ON THE RED ROCK, RIGHT? LIKE THAT IS WHAT YOU SEE.
YOU SEE THESE BEAUTIFUL TRAIL HEADS, YOU SEE THE TRAILS, YOU SEE JUST GORGEOUS SCENERY.
AT THE SAME TIME, THE FOREST SERVICE IS REQUIRED TO BALANCE THAT MANAGEMENT OF RECREATION WITH RANGE TIMBER, WATERSHED, WILDLIFE AND FISH AND WILDERNESS.
AND ESPECIALLY HERE, I WOULD ADD CULTURAL RESOURCES AND FIRE THERE.
THOSE ARE BOTH PREVALENT RESOURCES HERE THAT WE HAVE CERTAIN LAWS, REGULATIONS, POLICIES THAT WE ALWAYS HAVE TO FOLLOW.
AND RELATED TO THAT, OUR CURRENT STAFFING HAS CHANGED A LOT IN THE LAST COUPLE YEARS.
SO OUR FIRE PROGRAM HAS STAYED THE SAME IN THE LAST COUPLE YEARS.
WE'VE CONTINUED TO FEEL BEHIND FIREFIGHTERS AS THEY GET PROMOTED, THEY MOVE ON, THAT KIND OF THING.
SO WE HAVE 13 FIREFIGHTERS IN THE DISTRICT.
WE SHARE A PROGRAM WITH THE VERDE RANGER DISTRICT AND A ZONE PROGRAM WHERE THEY RESPOND ANYWHERE IN THE VERDE VALLEY REALLY TO, TO ANY WILDLAND FIRE AND ASSIST OTHER AGENCIES AS NECESSARY OUTSIDE OF FIRE.
WE'VE GONE THE LAST COUPLE YEARS FROM 35 EMPLOYEES TO 21.
IT MAKES IT REALLY CHALLENGING RIGHT NOW.
UM, AS WE THINK ABOUT OUR PRIORITIES AND HOW WE'RE GONNA GET THEM ACCOMPLISHED.
AND I'LL TELL YOU SOME OF THESE RESOURCES THAT WE HAVE, HAVE LEGAL REQUIREMENTS THAT EVERY PROJECT WE HAVE TO GO THROUGH.
WE HAVE TO ANALYZE THE EFFECTS TO THESE RESOURCES.
AND THERE ARE MULTIPLE RESOURCES.
WE HAVE ONE EMPLOYEE, SO WE HAVE AN AMAZINGLY SUPPORTIVE COMMUNITY.
BUT YOU'LL NOTICE AS I GO THROUGH PROJECTS, THERE'S, THERE'S SOME THINGS MISSING THAT WE WANNA DO IN THE FUTURE, BUT WE HAVE TO PRIORITIZE.
AND, AND THIS IS A LARGE PART OF IT, IT'S KNOWING THAT, THAT THERE'S ONLY SO MANY THINGS NO MATTER WHAT OUR PARTNERS COME TO THE TABLE WITH.
SO MANY THINGS THAT WE HAVE TO DO THAT ARE INHERENTLY GOVERNMENTAL FUNCTIONS THAT, THAT WE CAN'T PASS OFF AND CAN'T ASK A PARTNER TO DO.
SO I JUST WANTED TO HIGHLIGHT THAT.
UM, AS WE MOVE INTO THIS NATIONWIDE, THE AGENCY HAS, UH, DECREASED ABOUT SIX TO 7,000 EMPLOYEES THE LAST COUPLE YEARS.
UM, SO IT'S A, IT'S A BIG CHANGE THAT'S HAPPENING RIGHT NOW IN OUR AGENCY.
SO AT THAT NATIONAL LEVEL, SOME OF THE OTHER CHANGES, OUR REORGANIZATION, THAT'S THAT WE'RE KIND OF IN THE MIDDLE RIGHT NOW.
WE'RE MOVING THE HEADQUARTERS OF THE FOREST SERVICE FROM WASHINGTON DC TO SALT LAKE CITY, THE REGIONAL OFFICES, THE, UM, THE FORMAT THAT THE FOREST SERVICE HAS OPERATED UNDER SINCE ITS INCEPTION FOR OVER A HUNDRED YEARS, THOSE ARE GOING AWAY.
THAT LEVEL OF THE AGENCY, FOR THOSE OF YOU NOT FAMILIAR, I WORK ON THE SMALLEST LEVEL, THE DISTRICT, WHICH MULTIPLE DISTRICTS COMPOSE THE FOREST.
THEN WE HAVE OUR REGIONAL OFFICE THAT COVERS NEW MEXICO AND ARIZONA.
AND THEN WE HAVE OUR NATIONAL OFFICE.
IT'S CHANGING TO A STATE-BASED SYSTEM.
WE WILL HAVE AN ARIZONA STATE DIRECTOR THAT OVERSEES THE ENTIRETY OF ALL OF THE NATIONAL FORESTS IN ARIZONA ITSELF.
SOME OF THOSE STATE DIRECTORS NATIONWIDE HAVE ALREADY BEEN NAMED.
SO DON'T KNOW WHO THAT PERSON IS YET.
BUT MY BOSS'S BOSS WILL BE SOMEBODY NEW SOON.
ALSO RELATED TO THIS, UM, OPERATIONS, SERVICE CENTERS, THOSE REGIONAL OFFICES, BESIDES PROVIDING SOME DIRECTION AND, AND POLITICAL INTERFACE, THEY ALSO, UH, HOUSE A LOT OF EXPERTISE.
SO IF WE DON'T HAVE ANSWERS TO A CERTAIN THING OR DON'T KNOW HOW TO IMPLEMENT A CERTAIN POLICY, RIGHT NOW WE ASK OUR REGIONAL OFFICES FOR ADVICE.
A LOT OF TIMES THERE'S A REGIONAL PROGRAM MANAGER WITH THAT EXPERTISE.
NOW THAT'S MOVING TO OPERATION SERVICE CENTERS THAT WILL HAVE, WELL, I'LL BE HONEST, I DON'T KNOW EXACTLY WHAT THEY'LL LOOK LIKE, BUT THEY WILL SERVE THAT FUNCTION.
SO WE'RE IN THE MIDDLE OF THAT.
IT'S SORT OF PAUSED RIGHT NOW.
THERE'S SOME LITIGATION GOING ON, I'LL LEAVE IT THERE.
A COUPLE OTHER, UH, NATION NATIONWIDE CHANGES THAT ARE UNDER THAT WERE GOING ON UNDERGOING.
UM, THE FIRST ONE IS THE ROADLESS RULE.
SO A COUPLE POINTS I WANNA MAKE HERE.
THIS HAS BEEN ESTABLISHED SINCE 2001.
IT'S AN AGENCY PROCESS WHERE THE AGENCY DESIGNATED CERTAIN AREAS THAT IT WANTED TO BE VERY THOUGHTFUL ABOUT CONSIDERING AND APPROVING NEW ROADS.
THERE ARE HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF MILES OF ROADS NATIONWIDE THAT THE FOREST SERVICE MANAGES.
AND THERE WAS A REALIZATION AROUND THAT TIME THAT WE DON'T HAVE THE RESOURCES TO MANAGE THAT MANY.
WE SHOULD BE THOUGHTFUL ABOUT NEW ROADS.
SO IT DESIGNATED CERTAIN AREAS THAT, THAT WE HAVE TO GO THROUGH A SOMEWHAT ARDUOUS ANALYSIS BEFORE APPROVING SOME A NEW ROAD.
YOU CAN SEE ON OUR DISTRICT, THERE ARE FOUR OF THEM.
THEY'RE ALL EAST OF CAMP VERDE.
SO IT DOESN'T REALLY AFFECT THE SEDONA AREA A WHOLE LOT.
BUT I GET A LOT OF QUESTIONS ABOUT IT AND THERE'S A LOT OF CONFUSION ABOUT WHAT'S WILDERNESS AND WHAT'S ROADLESS.
THOSE ARE TWO VERY SEPARATE THINGS.
WILDERNESS IS DESIGNATED BY CONGRESS NOT AFFECTED BY THIS CHANGE, THIS PROPOSAL TO REMOVE THE ROADLESS RULE.
ONLY THESE ROADLESS AREAS WOULD BE
[00:40:01]
EVEN WITHOUT THE ROADLESS RULE, I DON'T ANTICIPATE LOCALLY THAT TO HAVE A MAJOR EFFECT.I WOULD THINK THAT THE MOST COMMON REQUEST WE WOULD GET FOR NEW ROADS WOULD BE TO ACCESS GRAZING INFRASTRUCTURE, TANKS, TROUGHS, THAT KIND OF THING.
I DON'T ANTICIPATE A LOT OF NEW ROAD BUILDING, EVEN IF THIS RULE IS RESCINDED, THAT'S GONNA TAKE, UH, A LITTLE BIT.
IT GOT INTRODUCED LAST YEAR AND A FINAL RULING NATIONWIDE WILL COME NEXT YEAR.
ANOTHER RULE, WHICH IT'S HARD TO KEEP THESE STRAIGHT TRAVEL MANAGEMENT 'CAUSE IT HAS TO DO WITH ROADS AND THE ROAD, THIS RULE, BUT TRAVEL MANAGEMENT, I WOULD SAY IS A LITTLE BIT MORE RELEVANT LOCALLY.
SO THIS PROPOSAL, AGAIN, IS NATIONWIDE TO CHANGE HOW WE MANAGE ACCESS AND IT WILL BE CALLED THE ACCESS RULE MOVING FORWARD ON EVERY NATIONAL FOREST RIGHT NOW, THERE'S A MOTOR VEHICLE USE MAP THAT SHOWS ALL OF THE PUBLICLY OPEN ROADS ON ANY GIVEN FOREST.
THIS WOULD CHANGE TO POTENTIALLY STILL HAVE A MAP LIKE THAT, BUT A PRESUMPTION THAT ANY ROAD ON THE GROUND THAT YOU ENCOUNTER, IF IT'S NOT SIGNED, IF IT'S NOT SPECIFICALLY CLOSED, IS OPEN TO ACCESS.
WHAT THAT ACTUALLY MEANS, WHETHER THAT MEANS THE ONES THAT ARE ON OUR MAP THAT WE KNOW ABOUT, WHETHER THAT MEANS ONE THAT WAS ILLEGALLY BUILT, I DON'T HAVE AN ANSWER FOR THAT.
UM, A LOT OF THE DETAILS ON THIS, A LOT OF THOSE DETAILS WILL BE RELEASED IN THE DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT THAT WILL COME NEXT YEAR.
SO THIS IS SOMETHING TO BE AWARE OF.
MAYBE TO KEEP TRACK, MAYBE TO KEEP TRACK OF.
ANOTHER REALLY RELEVANT LOCAL TOPIC IS THAT CLASS ONE E-BIKES UNDER THIS NEW RULE WOULD BE EXEMPTED FROM THE MOTORIZED TREATMENT THAT THEY CURRENTLY HAVE.
THEY'RE CURRENTLY AUTHORIZED ON MOTORIZED ROWS AND TRAILS NOT AUTHORIZED ON NON-MOTORIZED.
THIS WOULD TREAT THEM JUST LIKE A NORMAL MOUNTAIN BIKE.
UM, AND THEY WOULD BE ALLOWED ON NON-MOTORIZED TRAILS.
SO THAT WOULD BE, LIKE I SAID, A WOULD HAVE A VERY LARGE IMPACT LOCALLY.
BEFORE I GET TO LOCAL CHANGES, THERE'S ONE MORE THAT I DIDN'T ADD A SLIDE ON, AND THAT IS THE PEN POTENTIAL SHIFT OF OUR FIREFIGHTING RESOURCES WITHIN, WITHIN THE FOREST SERVICE TO DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR.
SO THERE WAS AN EXECUTIVE ORDER THAT ASKED THE AGENCIES TO LOOK AT AND POTENTIALLY MOVE ALL WILD LAND FIREFIGHTING RESOURCES UNDER ONE ORGANIZATION WITHIN THE DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR.
THEY ALREADY HAVE MOVED FROM THE FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE, PARK SERVICE, BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT AND OTHER AGENCIES, ANY WILDLAND FIREFIGHTERS TO A NEW NATIONAL WILDLAND FIREFIGHTING SERVICE WITHIN THE FOREST SERVICE.
WE'VE DONE SOME CONSOLIDATING A LITTLE BIT INTERNALLY, BUT RIGHT NOW THERE'S A STUDY THAT WAS RECENTLY CONTRACTED.
I BELIEVE THE RESULTS WILL BE OUT EARLY, EARLY NEXT YEAR LOOKING AT DOES IT MAKE SENSE TO MOVE THE FOREST SERVICE, THE DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE FIREFIGHTING FORCE INTO THE DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR UNDER THAT NEW WILD LAND FIREFIGHTING AGENCY.
THERE IS A LOT OF RAMIFICATIONS TO THAT POTENTIALLY, BUT AGAIN, I DON'T HAVE A LOT OF DETAIL ON WHAT THAT WOULD EVEN LOOK LIKE, SO I DON'T REALLY WANNA SPECULATE ANOTHER TYPE ITEM TO POTENTIALLY TRACK AND BE AWARE OF.
SO LOCALLY, WHAT YOU SEE HERE ARE THE PRIORITIES THAT WE'VE OUTLINED FOR FISCAL YEAR 27.
SO EVERY YEAR, THE FOREST SUPERVISOR, MY MY BOSS WHO SITS UP IN FLAGSTAFF, SENDS A LETTER TO THE STAFF AS WE'RE DOING OUR BUDGETING, AS WE'RE DOING OUR PLANNING, THAT SAYS IN ADDITION OR BUILDING ON IS PROBABLY MORE ACCURATE, ALL OF THE PRIORITIES FOR THE CHIEF NATIONALLY OF THE FOREST SERVICE.
HERE'S WHAT WE WANNA FOCUS ON, ON THE COCONINO NATIONAL FOREST.
SO THIS FIRST BULLET IS FOCUSED ON ACTIVE MANAGEMENT AND I WOULD CALL ACTIVE MANAGEMENT AS ANYTHING THAT WE DELIBERATELY CHANGE THE LAND.
SO THE FOREST SERVICE, THAT KIND OF TAKES THE FORM MOST FREQUENTLY OF TIMBER HARVEST, PLANTING, PRESCRIBED BURNING AND GRAZING.
SO RANGE MANAGEMENT, THOSE ARE REALLY THE OVERRIDING PRIORITY OF THE AGENCY RIGHT NOW IS TO MAKE SURE THAT WE ARE PRODUCING IN THOSE DIFFERENT AREAS.
SECONDARY SECOND TO THAT, UM, IS ANOTHER RESOURCE RECREATION.
THAT'S OUR SECOND BULLET IS TO CONTINUE PROVIDING WORLD CLASS RECREATION HERE.
I DON'T THINK MANY PEOPLE WOULD ARGUE WITH THAT, THAT MONIKER WORLD CLASS.
I HAVE VISITED OTHER COUNTRIES AND RAN INTO PEOPLE WHEN I SAY I'M FROM SEDONA, THEY KNOW WHERE I'M FROM AND IT'S BECAUSE OF THE ROCKS, IT'S BECAUSE OF THE TRAILS, IT'S BECAUSE OF THE RECREATION THAT'S HERE.
AND THEN THE THIRD AND FOURTH BULLETS, I'M NOT GONNA TALK A WHOLE LOT ABOUT THOSE.
SOME THINGS WE'RE TRYING TO DO TO IMPROVE EFFICIENCY, HAVE A LITTLE BIT MORE OF WHAT WE CALL BUSINESS ACUMEN.
UM, SOME POSITIVE CHANGES, I THINK.
ALRIGHT, ACTIVE MANAGEMENT, I MENTIONED THE POCKET FIRE OR, OR YOU MENTIONED THE POCKET FIRE.
AND I SAID I WOULD ELABORATE A LITTLE BIT.
WHAT A GREAT EXAMPLE OF, OF WHAT WE DO HERE.
SO POCKET FIRE WAS A HUGE, HUGE INCIDENT AND I HAVE A FEW MORE THANK YOUS JUST TO THE PARTNERS THAT HELPED WITH THAT.
SEDONA FIRE DISTRICT, THE CITY OF SEDONA CHANCE AND THE EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT.
UH, YOU ANDY, SO MANY PEOPLE INVOLVED IN NOT ONLY, UM, SETTING UP THE EMERGENCY SIDE, BUT ALL THE LOGISTICAL SIDE.
WE HAD A SPIKE CAMP OUT AT THE HIGH SCHOOL.
SO MUCH SUPPORT FROM OUR PARTNERS,
[00:45:01]
SOME OTHERS, THE DEPARTMENT OF FIRE AND FORESTRY MANAGEMENT THAT WAS MENTIONED, SEVEN CANYON RESORT, YAVAPAI AND COO, COUNTY SHERIFF AND EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT.I REALLY CAN'T NAME 'EM ALL, BUT IT TAKES A TON OF RESOURCES, A BUNCH OF DIFFERENT ORGANIZATIONS TO MAKE IT WORK.
AND A 27,000 ACRE FIRE THAT HAD NO STRUCTURES LOST AND NO, UH, FOLKS HURT.
I MEAN THAT'S, THAT'S QUITE AN ACCOMPLISHMENT THAT I, I THINK WE ALL CAN BE PROUD OF.
THIS IS A RENTAL CABIN AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC THAT THE FOREST SERVICE RUNS ON THE FLAGSTAFF RANGER DISTRICT.
IT'S NEAR EDGE OF THE WORLD FOR ANYBODY FAMILIAR WITH THE RIM COUNTRY UP THERE.
SO BEFORE THE FIRE WAS ABOUT TO GET TO THAT AREA, IT WAS WRAPPED TO MAKE SURE THAT NO EMBERS COULD GET ON IT AND BURN THAT STRUCTURE.
AND THEN DURING THE NIGHTTIME WHEN IT WAS COOLER, HIGHER RELATIVE HUMIDITY, OUR FIREFIGHTERS LIT OFF PURPOSEFULLY IN FRONT OF THE, THE MAIN FIRE, FIRE TO BURN AND REDUCE FUELS AROUND IT TO MAKE SURE WHEN THAT MAIN FIRE GOT THERE, IT DIDN'T HAVE ENOUGH LEFT TO BURN AND SPREAD IN THAT AREA AND POTENTIALLY BURN THIS STRUCTURE DOWN.
SO THIS IS SOME GOOD PHOTOS OF, OF WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE WHEN WE HAVE TIME TO PREPARE AND HAVE A GOOD TEAM THAT HAS A GOOD PLAN.
AND THEN I ALSO WANTED TO THANK JUST THE RESIDENTS AND EVERYBODY HERE THAT WAS IMPACTED.
I THINK THIS IS A GREAT PHOTO TO SHOW ALL THE SMOKE IMPACTS AND, AND ALSO THE SUPPORT THERE FROM SEVEN CANYONS.
THEY BASICALLY LET THE FIREFIGHTERS USE, UH, THROUGH A LAND USE AGREEMENT, THE DRIVING RANGE TO USE THOSE HELICOPTERS TO DUMP HUNDREDS AND HUNDREDS OF BUCKETS ON THE HELICOPTER OR ON THE FIRE IN TARGETED PLACES MADE A HUGE DIFFERENCE.
YOU ALSO SEE SMOKE IN THE AIR TODAY, RIGHT? UM, I'LL GET A LITTLE BIT LATER INTO PRESCRIBED BURNING.
AND ACTUALLY I THINK THAT'S MY NEXT NEXT SLIDE.
PRESCRIBED BURNING IS A REALLY IMPORTANT TASK THAT WE DO.
UM, PART OF IT IS RESTORATION ORIENTED IN A LOT OF PLACES.
WE HAVE MUCH MORE JUNIPER THAN WE WOULD PREFER THAN WAS HISTORICALLY THERE.
SO WE'RE GOING THROUGH AND WORKING WITH DEPARTMENT, THE STATE DEPARTMENT OF FIRE, FORESTRY AND FIRE MANAGEMENT TO DO THINNING TREATMENTS.
AND THEN WE'RE COMING BACK A COUPLE YEARS LATER AFTER IT DRIES AND BURNING AND TRYING TO MAINTAIN MORE GRASSLAND AND LESS FUEL FOR THOSE FIRES.
UM, WHY I BRING THAT UP IS THIS MORNING, AND PART OF WHY I BRING THAT UP IS THIS MORNING THERE WAS A LOT OF SMOKE.
THAT'S GONNA CONTINUE PROBABLY THE NEXT COUPLE DAYS.
FLAGSTAFF RANGER DISTRICT IS BURNING PILES RIGHT NOW, AND SO IS SMOKING ON RIM RANGER DISTRICT.
SO WELL, IT'S NOT OUR DISTRICT.
GRAVITY DOES ITS THING AND BRINGS THE SMOKE DOWN HERE.
THIS IS A LITTLE TINY WINDOW THAT HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO DO THAT.
THERE WERE SOME PRETTY BIG PLANS THIS FALL FOR BURNING A LOT MORE ACREAGE.
ALL OF OUR WET WEATHER, WHICH I'M THANKFUL FOR, DON'T GET ME WRONG, WE NEED IT, UH, HAS DEFINITELY SUPPRESSED BURNING OPPORTUNITIES.
SO THOSE LITTLE WINDOWS REALLY HAVEN'T SHOWN UP, I IMAGINE NEXT SPRING, IF IT'S A LITTLE BIT DRIER, WE'LL WE'LL BE OUT THERE BURN A LOT MORE.
SO SPECIFICALLY ON THIS DISTRICT, WHERE WE'LL BE BURNING IS OUT NEAR APACHE MAID, NOT REAL CLOSE TO SEDONA, STONEMAN LAKE CEDAR FLAT, IF YOU'RE ALL FAMILIAR WITH THOSE AREAS.
THEY'RE EAST OF I 17, BUT THE SMOKE IMPACTS POTENTIALLY COULD BE FELT HERE.
SMOKE IMPACTS FROM THE KAIBAB NATIONAL FOREST, FROM FLAGSTAFF RANGER DISTRICT.
AGAIN, THEY ALL FUNNEL INTO THE VERDE VALLEY.
SO I TRY TO DO MY BEST, KEEP AN EYE OUT ON NEWS RELEASE, BUT I TRY NEWS RELEASES, BUT I TRY TO DO MY BEST TO GIVE Y'ALL A HEADS UP, UM, WHEN THOSE POTENTIAL IMPACTS WILL BE HERE ALSO THIS YEAR.
SO THOSE ARE, I WOULD SAY, MORE RESTORATION ORIENTED BURNS THAN THEY ARE.
WHILE THERE ARE BENEFITS TO COMMUNITY PROTECTION, WE'RE REALLY RESTORING GRASSLAND.
WHAT IS LESS RESTORATION ORIENTED IS WHAT WE'RE PROPOSING AND WILL COME NEXT YEAR, IS A FUELS TREATMENT NEAR THE VILLAGE OF OAK CREEK.
DURING THE POCKET FIRE, YOU ALL SAW THAT THE FIRE STARTED JUST NORTH OF SEDONA.
AND EVERY DAY THAT WIND WHEN IT WAS THERE BLEW FROM THE SOUTHWEST TO THE NORTHEAST.
AND WHILE WE HAVE ALL THESE COMMUNITIES THAT ARE AT RISK TO FIRE THE ONES THAT ARE RIGHT IN THE PATH OF WHERE THE PREDOMINANT WIND PUSHES ARE THE ONES TO THE SOUTH OF HERE, THE VILLAGE OF OAK CREEK.
SO THAT'S WHERE WE'RE STARTING.
THERE WILL BE PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD TO GIVE SOME FEEDBACK ONCE WE GET THAT OUT THERE AS TO WHAT FOLKS WANNA SEE WHAT THEIR THOUGHTS ARE.
UH, BUT WE'RE WORKING WITH PARTNERS AGAIN, DFFM AGAIN, SEDONA FIRE DISTRICT.
UM, BUT THAT WILL COME NEXT YEAR.
SO, SO JUST BE ON THE LOOKOUT.
AND THEN THE LAST BULLET I HAVE HERE IS WORKING WITH SEDONA FIRE DISTRICT TO FIND A NEW STATION LOCATION IN OAK CREEK CANYON.
CLEARLY MUTUALLY BENEFICIAL FOR THE FOREST SERVICE AND THE SEDONA FIRE DISTRICT TO HAVE A LONG-TERM SOLUTION FOR THEIR, THEIR FIRE STATION LOCATION.
SO THAT'S EARLY IN THE PROCESS, BUT WE'RE LOOKING AT A SITE NEAR SLIDE ROCK STATE PARK.
AND THEN THE LAST SLIDE I HAVE HERE ON ACTIVE MANAGEMENT IS FOCUSED ON THAT GRAZING IN THAT RANGE MANAGEMENT.
SO AT THE DEPARTMENTAL LEVEL, TALKING ABOUT THE USDA, THE SECRETARY OF AGRICULTURE, THE SECRETARY OF INTERIOR, THERE'S BEEN A MEMO SIGNED BY BOTH TO SUPPORT A NATIONAL BEEF PLAN AND A GRAZING ACTION PLAN TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF COWS AND CATTLE ON LANDSCAPE.
SO WHILE THIS DOESN'T NECESSARILY AFFECT
[00:50:01]
SEDONA THAT CLOSELY, THERE'S ONE RANGE ALLOTMENT IN WEST SEDONA, THE WINDMILL WEST ALLOTMENT THAT RUNS BASICALLY FROM COTTONWOOD ALL THE WAY UP ALMOST TO FLAGSTAFF.UM, IT DOES TAKE A LOT OF OUR, POTENTIALLY A LOT OF OUR CAPACITY TO DO THIS.
UM, BY THE WAY, THESE TWO HORSES, THE THE DISTRICT HAS TWO HORSES, STANLEY AND TRICKS ON THE LEFT AND RIGHT.
UH, THEY'RE PRETTY, PRETTY GOOD BOYS.
SO, AND THEN LET'S MOVE ON TO RECREATION.
SO WE GOT A LOT FOR RECREATION AS YOU MIGHT EXPECT.
A BIG NOTABLE CHANGE IS OUR RECREATION FEE PROPOSAL.
YOU ALL MIGHT REMEMBER TWO YEARS AGO ALMOST WE PROPOSED THIS.
THERE'S A LONG PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD.
WE GOT MANY, MANY COMMENTS TO CONSIDER.
BUT THE RED ROCK PASS WAS STARTED IN 2001, I THINK, OR MAYBE EVEN NO, 2000.
IT WAS LAUNCHED AND THE PRICE HAS NEVER CHANGED.
SO WE PROPOSED THIS IN 2025 OR 24, 24.
AND FINALLY IT HAS SAT SINCE THEN UNTIL WE HAVE A RECREATION ADVISORY COMMITTEE, THERE'S A LONG REQUIRED PROCESS WE HAVE TO GO THROUGH.
AND FINALLY THERE'S A RECREATION ADVISORY COMMITTEE THAT EXISTS THAT IS WILLING TO HEAR US PROPOSE THIS AND GO OVER ALL THE COMMENTS AND THEN MAKE RECOMMENDATION TO OUR REGIONAL FORESTER TO MAKE A FINAL DECISION.
BUT THAT STEP HAS BEEN IN A HOLDING PATTERN FOR OVER A YEAR BECAUSE NO COMMITTEE EXISTED FOR US TO GO TO.
SO FINALLY THAT'S HAPPENING NEXT MONTH AND WE HOPE TO PROPOSE THESE FEES, UM, AND HOPEFULLY BRING IN MORE REVENUE THAT WILL GO RIGHT BACK INTO MANAGING THE LOCAL AREA.
ANY QUESTIONS ON THOSE FEES? OKAY, WANNA MAKE SURE RELATED TO THE POCKET FIRE, THERE ARE SOME RECREATION IMPACTS OR POTENTIAL IMPACTS THAT COULD FURTHER, UH, IMPACT RECREATION MOVING FORWARD.
SO SOME SPECIFIC PROJECTS WE'RE DOING IN ADVANCE OF, OF POTENTIAL FLOODING OR TRYING TO CLEAN UP AFTER FLOODING OUR ROAD ROAD DRAINAGE PROTECTION.
THERE IS A PROJECT THAT WAS, UH, PRESCRIBED BY THE BURNED AREA EMERGENCY RELIEF TEAM THAT CAME IN, CONSIDERS ALL THE IMPACTS, THE BURN SEVERITY, THAT KIND OF THING, WHAT POTENTIALLY FLOODING COULD, COULD, UM, WHAT IT COULD LEAD TO.
AND THERE'S A GIAN STRUCTURE THAT WILL PROTECT THE VOLTI ARCH ROAD.
THE DIRT ROAD THAT GOES ALL THE WAY TO VOLTI ARCH, PAST DEVIL'S TRAILHEAD GETS REALLY CLOSE TO DRY CREEK AND WITH THE EXPECTED INCREASED FLOWS AFTER THE FIRE THAT WILL HELP PROTECT THAT ROAD AND HOPEFULLY LONG AFTERWARD WILL HELP.
THERE'S ALSO SOME GATES TO, TO INSTALL TO POTENTIALLY IF THERE'S FLOODING IMPACTS, WE CAN CLOSE OFF AREAS MORE EASILY FOR PUBLIC SAFETY, UH, AS WELL AS SOME TRAIL REMEDIATION RELATED TO THAT.
THE WEST FORK TRAIL IS A, IS A BIG PROJECT THAT HAS HAD SOME FLOOD IMPACTS ALREADY.
WE HAD THE CLOSURE TO THE AREA GOING THROUGH THE END OF OCTOBER.
WE JUST PUT OUT A NEWS RELEASE TODAY THAT WILL BE CLOSED AT LEAST FOR THE END OF FEBRUARY.
SO THE WEST FORK TRAIL IS, WILL BE CLOSED.
WELL, THE WEST FORK DAY USE AREA, THE ENTRANCE OF FOLKS WANT TO JUST PICNIC THERE.
AND THE REASON IS THAT THERE'S BEEN A LOT OF FLOODING AND DEBRIS DAMAGE IN THERE.
THERE'S A COUPLE PHOTOS THAT SHOW A TRAIL SIGN WHERE THE SIGN IS PROBABLY FOUR FEET OFF THE GROUND AND THE DEBRIS IS PROBABLY THREE FEET OFF THE GROUND.
SO WE HAVE TO EITHER CLEAR THAT DEBRIS OR REROUTE THE TRAIL AT THE SAME TIME.
GOING BACK TO THOSE DIFFERENT RESOURCES, IT'S ENDANGERED SPECIES HABITAT.
WE HAVE MULTIPLE ENDANGERED SPECIES IN THAT AREA AND WE NEED TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO BOTH FIX THE TRAIL, DO THE ANALYSIS, GET IT AUTHORIZED, MITIGATE THE IMPACTS ON THOSE SPECIES, AND THEN GET IT DONE.
SO THE GOAL IS BY THE END OF FEBRUARY, I CAN'T GUARANTEE THAT'S GONNA HAPPEN.
IT MAY THIS WINTER HAVE MORE IMPACTS THAT HAVEN'T HAPPENED YET, BUT THAT'S, THAT'S WHAT WE'RE SHOOTING FOR.
LASTLY ON THIS SLIDE IS WORKING WITH THE COUNTY TO CONSIDER A PARKING PROHIBITION AROUND THE BOYNTON CANYON ROAD AREA.
IF YOU'VE SEEN, UH, SOME OF THE VIDEOS, THEY'RE ON YOUTUBE OF THE PARKING ISSUES OUT THERE, THERE'S A LOT OF SAFETY CONCERNS.
FOLKS WILL PARK UP AND DOWN THE ROAD, WALK THE ROAD.
WELL THERE'S A HIGH VOLUME OF TRAFFIC THERE.
WE WANT TO GET THOSE FOLKS OFF THE ROAD, GET THEM EITHER TO A DIFFERENT EXPERIENCE WHERE THEY CAN PARK SAFELY OR TO A TRAIL WHERE THEY CAN WALK OR BOTH, AS YOU ALL KNOW, OFF HIGHWAY VEHICLES ARE CONTINUING TO BE A MANAGEMENT CHALLENGE.
SO THE GREATER STUDENT RECREATION COLLABORATIVE, WE'VE GOT SOME SUCCESSES TO POINT TO THIS.
LAST YEAR, FOREST ROAD 1 52 C WAS SUCCESSFULLY REROUTED A PORTION OF IT AWAY FROM THE NEIGHBORHOOD BRANCH FROM THE STATE.
THAT'S HAD A BIG IMPACT IN A POSITIVE WAY TO THOSE LOCAL RESIDENTS.
WE WANT TO CONTINUE ACTIONS LIKE THAT.
SO FOREST ROAD 1 52 C, THAT SAME ROAD WE'RE LOOKING THIS FALL, THEN THIS WINTER AT PILOTING A SPEED LIMIT OF 25 MILES AN HOUR
[00:55:01]
TO SEE BOTH IF IT'S EFFECTIVE AT SLOWING DOWN PEOPLE AND SEE IF THAT SLOWING DOWN OF OF VEHICLES ACTUALLY HAS A POSITIVE IMPACT TO THE RESIDENTS AND TO THEIR USERS.OR DOES IT POTENTIALLY HAVE A NEGATIVE IMPACT TO USERS? WE'RE NOT EXACTLY SURE WHAT TO EXPECT.
WE'RE GONNA BE LOOKING AT THAT, MONITORING THAT AND MAKE A DECISION AT SOME POINT NEXT YEAR AS TO WHETHER THAT WILL BECOME PERMANENT OR NOT.
UM, YOU'VE TAKEN, YOU HAVE AN AVERAGE OF WHAT THE SPEEDS ARE NOW GOING THROUGH THERE.
SO WE ARE INSTALLING MONITORS.
SO TO EXPLAIN WHAT THOSE ARE, THEY COLLECT THREE PIECES OF INFORMATION THEY COLLECT WHENEVER A VEHICLE GOES BY THE DATE, THE TIME, AND THE SPEED.
THEY DON'T VIDEO RECORD, THEY DON'T TAKE A PHOTO, THEY DON'T EVEN DIFFERENTIATE BETWEEN TYPES OF VEHICLES.
SO BEFORE WE PUT THE SPEED LIMIT SIGN IN, WE'RE COLLECTING THAT DATA TO MAKE SURE WE HAVE A SOLID BASELINE OF BEFORE AVERAGE MEDIAN SPEED.
AND THEN ONCE WE PUT THOSE SIGNS IN, WE'LL BE DOING A COUPLE DIFFERENT THINGS TO, TO SEE HOW IT AFFECTS THAT.
BUT YOU'RE ESTIMATING THAT THE SPEEDS ARE CURRENTLY OVER 25 MILES AN HOUR? SLIGHTLY.
WE HAVE AN ENGINEERING STUDY FROM 2021 THAT THERE, THERE ARE SOME FLAWS IN IT THAT HAVE BEEN POINTED OUT.
IT WAS NOT AS ROBUST AS SOME FOLKS WOULD'VE LIKED, BUT THE AVERAGE SPEED, IF I RECALL, AND I CAN SEND YOU THAT STUDY, I THINK IT WAS SOMEWHERE AROUND 27 OR 28 MILES PER HOUR.
SO IT WASN'T A LOT OVER 25 MILES PER HOUR, BUT IT DID EXCEED IT.
BUT FOR SERVICE SPECIFIC, OUR CAPACITY ANALYSIS.
SO WE HAVE A TEAM WITHIN THE AGENCY CALLED THE ENTERPRISE PROGRAM.
THEY'RE HELPING US WITH THEIR RECREATION EXPERTISE TO COME UP WITH A WAY TO ESTIMATE HOW MANY VEHICLES CERTAIN ROADS CAN HANDLE.
IT'S JUST THAT IT'S AN ESTIMATE WE'RE GONNA HAVE.
THE REASON WE HAVE TO DO THAT IS THIS IS A CONTROVERSIAL ISSUE.
THERE'S LOTS OF FOLKS WHO WANT MORE VEHICLES.
THERE'S LOTS OF FOLKS WHO WANT LESS VEHICLES.
SO IF WE MAKE A DECISION, IT HAS TO BE DEFENSIBLE, IT HAS TO BE BASED IN THE DATA THAT WE HAVE AND AND REALLY CONSIDER A WHOLE LOT OF FACTORS.
AND SO WE'RE TRYING TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO INCORPORATE THOSE FACTORS IN A WAY THAT IS LOGICAL THAT WE CAN EXPLAIN.
THAT'S TAKEN SOME TIME I'LL SAY.
AND THERE'S HAD A LOT OF DEEP CONVERSATIONS ABOUT WHAT NEED TO BE INCLUDED, BUT WE'RE MAKING PROGRESS ON THAT AND I THINK WE'LL HAVE THAT NEXT YEAR.
IF IT SHOWS THAT THAT ESTIMATE THAT CURRENT TRAFFIC IS EXCEEDING THOSE ESTIMATES, IT DOESN'T MEAN THAT WE'RE IMMEDIATELY GONNA TAKE ACTION ON THAT.
THERE'S A LOT OF THINGS THAT HAVE TO HAPPEN.
AGAIN, TO REVERT BACK TO WHAT I STARTED WITH PLANNING PROCESS WISE, IMPLEMENTATION CAPACITY WISE FOR US TO GET THINGS DOWN THE GROUND.
BUT IT GIVES US A SIGN THAT WE SHOULD BE CONSIDERING IT AND WE SHOULD BE COMING UP WITH PLANS, WHETHER SHORT TERM OR LONG TERM, TO ADDRESS THOSE, THOSE CAPACITIES.
SO THAT'S WHAT WE'RE WORKING TOWARD AND MY HOPE IS AT THE END OF NEXT CALENDAR YEAR, WE'LL HAVE A MUCH CLEARER IDEA OF THE PROJECTS THAT MANY HAVE BEEN SUGGESTED.
MANY WORKED ON LOTS OF GOOD IDEAS, BUT THE ONES THAT WE PLAN TO, AGAIN, IN SHORT, LONG, MEDIUM, LONG TERM PURSUE IN THE SHORTER TERM TRAIL PARTNERS OF ARIZONA, THIS IS A GROUP THAT'S, UH, COME TOGETHER TO FORM A 5 0 1 C3 ORGANIZATION.
IT REALLY STARTED WITH OUR LOCAL RENTAL COMMUNITY AND THOSE BUSINESSES, THEY'VE GOTTEN A GRANT FROM THE STATE FOR $750,000 TO FUND MULTIPLE DIFFERENT THINGS.
ARCHEOLOGY SURVEYS ARE ONE OF THEM.
WE REALLY WANT TO GET TO A POINT WHERE WE CAN AUTHORIZE WHAT WE CALL RAPID RESPONSE.
WHAT THAT MEANS IS THAT WHEN SOMEBODY GOES OFF A ROAD AND CAUSES SOME DAMAGE, WE CAN GET IN THERE, PUT IN BOULDERS, REMEDIATE PLANT, PUT IN A FENCE, ANYTHING TO PREVENT THAT FROM GETTING WORSE AND REMEDIATE IT IMMEDIATELY RATHER THAN RIGHT NOW GETTING A ONE-OFF.
SO WE'RE DOING THE SURVEYS TO AUTHORIZE THAT IN THE ENTIRE CORRIDOR RATHER THAN RIGHT NOW DOING A ONE-OFF PROJECT HERE AND THERE, GOING AND DOING THAT ANALYSIS PLUS FOR THAT PROJECT AND HAVING TO HAVE THAT DELAY.
SO THAT WILL BE A HUGE BENEFIT TO THE DISTRICT AND A HUGE GAIN IN EFFICIENCY.
THE OTHER THINGS THAT, THAT FUNDS ARE AN OHV CREW THAT WILL WORK ON MAINTENANCE AND THAT RAPID RESPONSE, SOME MAINTENANCE OF THE DIAMONDBACK GULCH OHV TRAIL, UH, AS WELL AS FACILITATION OF THE GREATER SEDONA RECREATION COLLABORATIVE GROUP TO CONTINUE THESE, THESE EFFORTS.
SO A LOT OF REALLY HELPFUL EFFORTS THAT ARE FUNDED BY OUR PARTNERS HERE LOCALLY THROUGH A GRANT FROM THE STATE.
LOTS OF DIFFERENT PLAYERS PLAYING THESE ROLES TO GET TO A GOOD RESULT THAT WILL HOPEFULLY BALANCE EVERYBODY'S NEEDS.
THE SECOND BULLET HERE, THE MAIN BULLET IS CASE SPRINGS CAMPGROUND REDESIGN.
SO CASE SPRINGS IS OUR MOST POPULAR CAMPGROUND IN NUMBER OF VISITORS.
WE ONLY HAVE A FEW RIGHT IN OAK CREEK.
IT, IT REALLY ISN'T THE BEST FOR THE LARGER MODERN DAY TRAILERS AND CAMPERS THAT A LOT OF PEOPLE WANT TO BRING IN.
IT'S A NARROW ROAD IN WE REALLY WANT TO MAKE SOME CHANGES TO MODERNIZE IT, MODERNIZE THE SHOWERS,
[01:00:01]
THE, THE ENTRANCE AND THE SITES THEMSELVES.THE TUNE OF OVER A MILLION DOLLARS FROM GREAT AMERICAN OUTDOORS ACT THAT WE'VE BEEN TRYING TO, TRYING TO GET TO A DESIGN.
SO IN THIS NEXT YEAR WE'RE HOPING TO WORK ON THAT DESIGN AND GET A FINAL ENGINEER DESIGN AND THEN FILL IN THE REST OF THE FUNDING THROUGH THE AGENCY OR POTENTIALLY GRANTS AND THEN IN THE NEXT COUPLE YEARS GET THAT IMPLEMENTED AND HAVE FOLKS HAVE A BETTER EXPERIENCE OF THAT CAMPGROUND.
AND THEN THE SHUTTLE, THIS IS SUCH A GOOD EXAMPLE OF THE PARTNERSHIP BETWEEN THE CITY AND THE FOREST SERVICE AND THE PARTNERSHIP THAT WE WANT TO EXPAND.
SO KIND OF TWO BUCKETS HERE I'LL TALK ABOUT.
THE FIRST ONE IS CHANGES TO IMPROVE ITS CURRENT DESIGN.
SO A MAJOR ONE IS THE DRY CREEK ROAD SHUTTLE.
THE CITY AND ITS STAFF HAVE BEEN WORKING HARD TO COME UP WITH A DESIGN THAT WOULD WORK FOR US THAT WE CAN GO THROUGH OUR PLANNING PROCESS AND AUTHORIZE RECENTLY GOT A DESIGN, THERE'S A SCREENSHOT THERE.
THE REASON WE WANT TO MOVE THE CURRENT DRY CREEK VISTA TRAILHEAD DROP OFF IS BECAUSE OF THE TRAFFIC ISSUES.
IT'S A ONE WAY IN, ONE WAY OUT.
OFTENTIMES A SHUTTLE GETS IN THERE AND FOLKS WHO ARE VISITING REFUSE TO MOVE AND GET OUTTA THE WAY AND WAIT THERE UNTIL THERE'S A SPOT THAT COMES OPEN.
NOT REALLY THE MOST ETHICAL OR FRIENDLY BEHAVIOR, BUT THE RESULT IS THAT OUR SHUTTLE SITS THERE BEHIND THEM POTENTIALLY FOR 20, 30, 40 MINUTES WHILE A SPOT WAITS TO OPEN BY DROPPING PEOPLE OFF ALONG DRY CREEK ROAD, WE SKIP THAT WEIGHT.
THERE'S NO ONE WAY IN, ONE WAY OUT.
WE DON'T ANTICIPATE, UM, ANY OF THOSE TYPES OF DELAYS.
SO THAT WOULD IMPROVE THE EFFICIENCY AND THE EXPERIENCE FOR FOLKS TREMENDOUSLY.
AT THE SAME TIME, WE WANNA WORK AND EXPLORE THE POTENTIAL FOR PARTNERSHIP WITH THE COUNTY, POTENTIALLY OTHER ORGANIZATIONS TO EXPAND THAT SHUTTLE SYSTEM.
OBVIOUSLY, THE, THE CITY IS CONCERNED MOSTLY WITHIN CITY BOUNDARIES, BUT THE SHUTTLE SYSTEM HAS AN OPPORTUNITY IF WE CAN FIND MORE PARTNERS, MORE LONG-TERM FUNDING FOR OPERATIONS TO EXPAND AND, AND GO TO OTHER TRAILHEADS.
SO I LISTED A FEW HERE THAT FROM A RECREATION STANDPOINT WOULD BE IMPORTANT.
I ALSO DIDN'T LIST, BUT WANT TO MENTION THAT THE CHAPEL IS ALSO A POTENTIAL STOP.
UM, THERE'S SOME, SOME WORKING OUT THERE, WHETHER IT'S THE SHUTTLE, WHETHER IT'S SHUTTLE CONNECT, WHERE THE PARKING WOULD BE.
BUT I THINK THERE'S A PATH FORWARD THAT COULD POTENTIALLY WORK FOR, FOR NOT ONLY THE CITY, THE FOREST SERVICE, BUT ALSO THE CHAPEL ITSELF.
SO THOSE CONVERSATIONS CONTINUE.
I KNOW THE CITY HAS WORKED HARD ON SOME POTENTIAL PLANS FOR SHUTTLE CONNECT DROP OFF, AND I'M LOOKING FORWARD TO CONTINUING THOSE CONVERSATIONS AND, AND HOPEFULLY GET INTO A PROJECT SOON.
LASTLY, TWO THINGS RELATED HERE.
THIS IS WHAT A LOT OF PEOPLE THINK OF WHEN THEY THINK OF THE RED ROCK RANGER DISTRICT.
AND WE CONTINUE TO MAKE REALLY, REALLY GREAT PROGRESS ON, ON PROJECTS THAT ARE FRANKLY IMPRESSIVE COMPARED TO OTHER FOREST SERVICE DISTRICTS.
TURKEY CREEK AREA BOUNCED AROUND HERE.
WE AUTHORIZED A COUPLE YEARS AGO, ROUGHLY 30 MILES OF TRAIL IN THAT AREA OFF VERDE VALLEY SCHOOL ROAD NEAR THE VILLAGE OF OAK CREEK.
WE CONTINUE CONSTRUCTION, I THINK ABOUT SIX AND A HALF MILES, GOT COMPLETED LAST SEASON.
WE'RE SHOOTING FOR AROUND EIGHT THIS YEAR.
WE'RE GETTING TO A POINT WHERE WE REALLY NEED THE TRAILHEAD TO BE BUILT SO THAT WE CAN HAVE THOSE MATCH WHERE WE HAVE THE CAPACITY OF THE TRAILHEAD TO MATCH THE NUMBER OF USERS WE ANTICIPATE TO USE ALL THOSE TRAILS.
'CAUSE RIGHT NOW WE'VE GOT A VERY UNDERSIZED TRAILHEAD IN A NOT NOT IDEAL LOCATION.
SO THIS YEAR WE'RE WORKING WITH NATIONAL FOREST FOUNDATION AND SEDONA RED ROCK TRAIL FUND TO FUND THE DESIGN, THE ENGINEERED DESIGN.
IT'S ALREADY BEEN AUTHORIZED FOR A PLANNING PROCESS, SO LUCKILY THAT'S DONE.
BUT ONCE YOU HAVE THE ENGINEERED DESIGN, WE'LL BE LOOKING FOR IMPLEMENTATION FUNDING.
AND HOPEFULLY IN THE NEXT COUPLE YEARS WE'LL GET THAT BUILT FURTHER ALONG THE, THE TIMELINE IS BROKEN ARROW.
SO, UM, WE'VE BEEN TALKING ABOUT THIS FOR, FOR YEARS, RIGHT? AND FINALLY IT IS COMING TO FRUITION.
THE LAST I SAW WAS A 90% DESIGN DONE BY THE CITY.
UM, THAT IS, IS SO CLOSE TO BEING FINISHED.
AND I BELIEVE THE CONTRACTING PLANS ARE TO GET INTO A CONTRACT THIS YEAR AND BUILT NEXT SPRING OR SUMMER.
SO THE END OF OUR FISCAL YEAR, DEFINITELY THE END OF NEXT CALENDAR YEAR.
MY HOPE IS THAT THAT TRAILHEAD WILL LOOK A LOT DIFFERENT THAN IT DOES NOW, AND TRAFFIC FLOW WILL BE SO MUCH SMOOTHER THAN IT IS NOW.
SO, TO REMIND FOLKS, IT'S ONE WAY IN, ONE WAY OUT.
AGAIN, A THEME HERE AT SOME OF OUR TRAILHEADS, THAT'S A CHALLENGE AND FOLKS GET STUCK THERE.
THEY GET BACKED UP AND THEY HAVE IMPACTS IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD WHERE THEY SIT AND IDLE AND ARE NOISY.
WE'RE TRYING TO CHANGE ALL THAT AND JUST IMPROVE IT FOR BOTH THE USER AND THE LOCAL RESIDENTS.
THAT PROJECT IS FUNDED BY A STATE GRANT, UM, REALLY SUCCESSFUL PARTNERSHIP.
AGAIN, THIRD ONE WESTERN GATEWAY.
SO ALEX, BEFORE YOU MOVE ON, HAS THE COMMUNITY AND BROKEN ARROW SEEN THE DESIGN AS IT'S MATURED OR HAVE THEY'VE BEEN INVOLVED IN IT? MAY HAVE GIVEN ANY FEEDBACK.
SO, NO, THEY HAVE NOT BEEN INVOLVED IN THE DESIGN.
AS WE GOT INTO THE ENGINEER DESIGN, WE HAVE MULTIPLE SITE VISITS ON
[01:05:01]
IN PERSON ON THE GROUND BEFORE WE EVEN GOT TO THE ENGINEER DESIGN AND GOT THROUGH EVERY SINGLE ASPECT OF THAT TRAILHEAD.WHETHER IT'S THE FRONT GATE, WHETHER IT'S WHERE A FUTURE GATE MIGHT BE, THE ROCK BARRIER, THE, THE TURN WHERE IT SHOULD BE PAVED.
I WAS PRETTY CONFIDENT THAT WE, WE DID PRETTY WELL GETTING FEEDBACK THAT GOING TO THE DESIGN, WE HAD THIS LAUNDRY LIST OF THINGS THAT IT NEEDS TO MEET.
I I THINK RESIDENTS WILL BE PRETTY HAPPY THAT WE'VE UPHELD WHAT THEIR DESIRES ARE.
UM, SO AS WE MOVE FORWARD, I, I THINK THEY'LL BE EXCITED TO SEE WHAT WE HAVE.
LOOKING FOR SOMEBODY TO BE SHAKEN HIS HEAD.
THANK YOU CARL
LIKE THE FEEDBACK, THE FEEDBACK WE'VE GOTTEN HAS LED TO A MUCH BETTER PRODUCT.
I'LL JUST JUST PUT IT THAT WAY.
LIKE I'M SO GLAD THAT WE'VE HAD LOCAL COMMUNITY MEMBERS THAT ARE WILLING TO BE INVOLVED AND TAKE THEIR TIME TO GIVE IT.
I THINK IT WAS A GOOD COLLABORATION IN THE END.
SO, WESTERN GATEWAY, THIS IS OUR TRAILHEAD LOCATED ADJACENT TO CULTURAL PARK, THAT PROPERTY, THE CITY, AND AGAIN, PARTNERSHIP THE CITY AND THE FOREST SERVICE, PUT IN A GRANT REQUEST TO THE FEDERAL LANDS ACCESS PROGRAM FOR A ROUGHLY $10 MILLION PROJECT SPANNING BOTH THE FOREST SERVICE PROPERTY AND SOME PROJECTS ON THE CITY PROPERTY THAT WAS SUCCESSFUL.
AND THAT PROJECT DEPENDS ON FUNDING THAT CONGRESS NEEDS TO REAUTHORIZE.
SO THERE'S CERTAINLY SOME, SOME CAVEATS HERE AS TO STEPS THAT NEED TO BE HAD.
BUT THAT IS A REALLY, REALLY AWESOME PROJECT THAT WILL TAKE WHAT IS RIGHT NOW A BOULDER OFF DIRT LOT AND TURN IT INTO OUR LARGEST TRAIL HEAD THAT WE HAVE ON THE ENTIRE DISTRICT, AROUND 65 PARKING SPOTS.
OUR HOPE IS TO JUST DOWN THE ROAD, HAVE AN EQUESTRIAN SPECIFIC PARKING AREA AS WELL, SO THAT WE DON'T HAVE USER CONFLICT AND SAFETY ISSUES BETWEEN PEDESTRIANS AND VEHICLES AND FORCES.
AND ALSO TO REPAVE THE WHAT'S NOW CALLED THE CENTENNIAL TRAIL.
IT'S KIND OF A DEGRADED ASPHALT THAT'S SUPPOSED TO BE A DA ACCESSIBLE, I I WOULD QUESTION ANYBODY WHO'S TRYING TO TAKE A WHEELCHAIR ON THAT AND INCORPORATE IT INTO AN EXTENSION OF THE, UH, SHARED USE PATH THAT THE CITY HAS SO THAT WHEN SOMEBODY'S ON THAT PATH, THEY REALLY DON'T NOTICE A DIFFERENCE AS THEY TRANSITION FROM CULTURAL PARK PROPERTY ONTO NATIONAL FOREST, WHICH SHOULD BE AN AWESOME EXPERIENCE.
I BELIEVE IT'D BE LIKE THE SOUTHERN TERMINUS OF THAT SHARED USE PATH.
AND THEN LASTLY, THE DOE AND BEAR MOUNTAIN EXPANSION OF THAT TRAILHEAD.
FOR ALL OF YOU WHO AREN'T AWARE, DOE MOUNTAIN USED TO JUST HAVE THIS ONE MILE TRAIL, THREE QUARTERS OF MILE TRAIL UP TO THE TOP OF THE MESA.
AND THEN IT WAS LIKE, ONCE YOU'RE UP THERE, YOU'RE ON YOUR OWN
RECENTLY WE BUILT A SORT OF FIGURE EIGHT TRAIL, AND I SHOULDN'T SAY WE, THESE GUYS IN THE BACK OF THE ROOM DID SAM AND KEVIN AND THEIR CREWS BUILT A FIGURE EIGHT TRAIL IN PARTNERSHIP WITH THE TRAIL FUND WITH, WITH A COUPLE OTHER PARTNERS.
AND, UM, IT'S A GREAT EXPERIENCE.
AND AT THE SAME TIME, THE LAST COUPLE YEARS, THEY FINISHED RE REBUILDING THAT THAT ONE MILE TRAILER GETS UP TO THE TOP.
A LOT OF REALLY EXCELLENT ROCK WORK THAT'S GONNA BE THERE FOR DECADES.
IT'S A REALLY GOOD EXPERIENCE THAT TRAILHEAD ONLY HOLDS 15 CARS, PROBABLY THERE'S ROOM TO EXPAND IT AND ROOM FOR THAT TRAIL TO HOLD MORE PEOPLE AND HAVE A GREAT EXPERIENCE FOR MORE FOLKS.
SO AS WE'RE THINKING ABOUT WHERE WE NEED TO REDUCE IMPACTS TO CULTURAL RESOURCES, NATURAL RESOURCES, WHERE CAN WE ACTUALLY SEND PEOPLE THAT WON'T HAVE MORE IMPACTS? THAT ONE'S READY TO, TO TAKE MORE VISITORS, POTENTIALLY A SHUTTLE STOP AS WELL.
I I SHAVED THAT FOR LAST BECAUSE THAT'S GONNA BE SUCH A TOPIC TONIGHT.
UM, WE CONTINUE TO MAKE REALLY GOOD STRIDES.
WE, WE HAVE JUST SO MUCH GOOD SUPPORT THAT YOU'LL SEE DOCUMENTED HERE TODAY.
SO MANY GOOD IDEAS, SO MANY GOOD PROJECTS.
MY CHALLENGES FOR THE FOREST SERVICE TO MEET NOT EVEN 50 50, I'D SAY 90 10 FOR US TO MEET WHERE WE CAN, BUT WE'RE DOING OUR BEST.
OUR ONE TRAILS EMPLOYEE IS IN THE BACK.
OUR ONE PERMANENT EMPLOYEE DEDICATED TO TRAILS.
I HOPE SOMEDAY WE'LL HAVE MORE.
UM, BUT WE'VE GOT A LOT OF SMART CREATIVE PEOPLE IN THIS COMMUNITY THAT NOT ONLY HAVE TALKED THE TALK, BUT THEY WALKED THE WALK.
THEY ARE AMAZING PARTNERS AND, AND THERE'S NOTHING BUT I THINK POSITIVE IN THE FUTURE FOR THIS, THIS OUTDOOR RECREATION INDUSTRY AS WELL AS THE TRAILS THEMSELVES.
SO I'LL LEAVE IT AT THAT AND, UH, TAKE ANY QUESTIONS Y'ALL HAVE.
PETE, ALEX, I WANNA THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE AGAIN TONIGHT.
AND THIS PRESENTATION WAS REALLY, REALLY GREAT.
I GOT JUST A COUPLE OF QUESTIONS OF THINGS YOU SAID, UH, BUT I WILL FIRST WANT TO JUST SAY THANK YOU.
I SEE THE, THE GREEN COLOR IN THE BACK OF THE FOLKS THAT WORK FOR YOU THAT DO THE DOERS THAT ARE OUT THERE AND MANY, MANY PEOPLE IN THE AUDIENCE THAT SUPPORT ALL THE WORK THAT YOU DO.
AND I WANT TO THANK EVERYBODY FOR BEING HERE, ENGAGING IN THIS TOPIC.
IT'S, IT'S BEEN, YEAH, JUST YOUR COMMITMENT TO COMING TO US.
IT'S NOT ALWAYS EASY TO COME BEFORE COUNCIL AND, AND CROWDS OF PEOPLE.
[01:10:01]
IN THAT, UH, ACCESS PLAN THAT YOU TALKED ABOUT, THE NEWLY WORDED, YOU TALKED ABOUT CLASS ONE E-BIKES AND YOU SAID, IF I GOT THE QUOTE RIGHT, POTENTIALLY A LARGE IMPACT IN OUR AREA.CAN YOU HELP ME UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU MEAN BY POTENTIALLY A LARGE IMPACT IN OUR AREA? ARE YOU PRE-JUDGING WHAT CLASS ONE E-BIKES WOULD DO OR, UH, SPECULATING SLIGHTLY.
I THINK, UH, WELL-INFORMED, I THINK SO RIGHT NOW, UM, WE HAVE THE ABILITY TO AUTHORIZE E-BIKES ON NON-MOTORIZED TRAILS.
IT TAKES A PLANNING PROCESS, IT TAKES CAPACITY TO DO THAT.
AND IF YOU DON'T KNOW, THERE'S, THERE'S A LOT OF DIFFERENCES OF OPINION WITHIN THE BIKING COMMUNITY.
THERE'S SOME DIFFERENCE OF OPINION, CERTAINLY WITHIN THE LARGER TRAIL USE OPINION, UH, TRAIL USE COMMUNITY, THERE'S A LOT OF DIFFERENCES OF OPINION.
SO, WHICH TRAILS THEY BELONG ON IS A BIG QUESTION.
IF, UH, IF, IF WE'RE TOLD NATIONALLY THAT ALL NON-MOTORIZED TRAILS SHOULD HAVE E-BIKES, BUT TAKING OFF HIGHWAY VEHICLE MANAGEMENT AS AN EXAMPLE, ONE OF THE CHALLENGES IS THAT THE STATE LAW ALLOWS THEM TO BE STREET LEGAL.
AND SO JUST LIKE WHEN YOU RENT A A VEHICLE AT THE AIRPORT, YOU CAN RENT A OHV IN THE CITY AND TAKE IT ON FOREST SERVICE, UH, PROPERTY.
AND IT, WE ONLY HAVE CERTAIN REGULATORY AUTHORITIES AND, AND WE REALLY ARE A LITTLE BIT LIMITED IN THOSE CHOICES.
SO WE CAN'T, OR IT'S EXTREMELY DIFFICULT POTENTIALLY FOR US TO DESIGNATE OHV ONLY TRAILS IF THIS CHANGE OCCURS.
IT WOULD BE SIMILAR WITH E-BIKES.
AND SO WE ALREADY HAVE SOME CONFLICT BETWEEN USERS AND BIKES THAT ARE NOT ELECTRIFIED AND FOLKS WHO THINK THAT BIKES DON'T BELONG ON TRAILS.
I WOULD IMAGINE THAT WE WOULD HAVE A LOT MORE USERS ON BIKES IF E-BIKES ARE AUTHORIZED, THAT THE INDUSTRY FOR RENTALS WOULD GROW AROUND HERE.
AND WE WOULD SEE WHETHER IT'S ONE YEAR, THREE YEARS, FIVE YEARS, A SIGNIFICANT INCREASE IN THE NUMBER OF BIKES.
AND I ACTUALLY, UM, I BROUGHT IT WITH, I GOT IN THE MAIL TODAY A POSTCARD ANONYMOUSLY THAT I THOUGHT SOMEBODY MIGHT ASK ABOUT E-BIKES.
THIS IS NOT ABOUT E-BIKES, IT'S JUST ABOUT BIKES.
THEY SAID BIKES SHOULD BE BANNED FROM THE BELL ROCK TRAIL BIKERS THINK THEY OWN THE PLACE AND THEY SHOW NO COURTESY TO ANYONE FORCING PEOPLE TO JUMP OUT OF THEIR WAY OR GET HIT.
THEY NEARLY HIT MY KIDS IN ELDERLY.
IT'S A DISGRACE TO THE FOREST SERVICE.
I'M NOT SAYING I AGREE WITH THIS, BUT WHAT I DO WANNA SAY IS THAT IT DEMONSTRATES THAT DIFFERENCE OF OPINION THERE AND WHERE IT'S, IT'S HARD FOR US TO BALANCE BETWEEN RESOURCES, BUT IT'S REALLY HARD IN RECREATION TO BALANCE BETWEEN USER TYPES AND USER GROUPS AS WELL.
SO ANY SORT OF E-BIKE DECISION, WE'RE GONNA WANT A LOT OF COMMENT FROM, FROM THE PUBLIC AND TO FIGURE THAT OUT.
SO, SO WHEN IT COMES TO IMPACTS, I THINK MOSTLY ABOUT THE SOCIAL IMPACTS BECAUSE ON A ONE-TO-ONE BASIS, THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN AN E-BIKE AND, AND A MOUNTAIN BIKE, THERE'S SOME DEBATE, BUT THEY'RE NOT THAT MUCH DIFFERENT.
THEY ARE DIFFERENT IN LENGTH, PEOPLE CAN GO.
SO THEY MIGHT GET DEEPER INTO AN AREA, BUT THEY'RE NOT THAT MUCH DIFFERENT.
I THINK ABOUT THE SOCIAL IMPACTS FIRST.
WHEN YOU SAID LARGE IMPACT, I WAS HOPING THAT YOU MEANT THIS IS A LARGE IMPACT IN TERMS OF IT'S GONNA TAKE A LOT OF ENGAGEMENT AND THOUGHT ABOUT WHAT WE DO IF WE GET A CHOICE OF WHAT TO DO.
SECOND COMMENT YOU MADE WAS, UH, IN THE FUELS TREATMENT AREA NEAR THE VOC, I BELIEVE YOU'VE COME BEFORE US IN THE PAST AND HAVE SPOKEN TO SOME DESIRE TO DO SOME FUEL BREAKS, UH, IN THE SOUTHWEST OF SEDONA AREA.
IS THAT WHAT YOU MEAN? THIS IS THE SAME TOPIC THAT YOU'VE TALKED ABOUT US BEFORE? OR IS THIS SOMETHING DIFFERENT? AND THEN MY QUESTION, IF THAT'S THE CASE, WHAT IS NEAR MEAN? YOU KNOW, HOW FAR, 'CAUSE VOC IS REALLY QUITE SOUTH TO US AND THE SOUTHWESTERLY WIND MIGHT NOT NECESSARILY DICTATE THAT YOU WOULD OPERATE MM-HMM
JUST A QUESTION ABOUT WHAT THAT MEANS.
YEAH, I, SO YES, IT IS AN EXTENSION OF, OF WHAT I'VE TALKED ABOUT IN THE PAST.
AND WHEN I SAY NEAR THE VOCI, I MEAN ADJACENT TO PRIVATE PROPERTY.
SO WE HAVE A LOT OF FOLKS AND EVEN ENTIRE HOAS THAT ARE FIREWISE CERTIFIED.
UM, I BELIEVE IN SEDONA THERE'S A PROGRAM, FIRE SAFE SEDONA, WHERE THEY MAY DO A LOT OF EFFORTS ON THEIR PROPERTY OR WITHIN THEIR COMMUNITY AND THEN THEY GET A RECOMMENDATION THAT SAYS, WELL, YOU SHOULD ALSO EXTEND ONTO THE NATIONAL FOREST.
WE PROBABLY WON'T DO EXACTLY WHAT FIRE SAFE OR, OR WHAT FIREWISE MIGHT ADVISE 'CAUSE IT'S MANAGED DIFFERENTLY AS PUBLIC PROPERTY.
BUT WE'RE TRYING TO DO SOMETHING THAT THAT BALANCES THAT, WHERE, IN THIS CASE, THE BALANCE IS THE POTENTIAL FOR, UM, SCENIC IMPACT ADJACENT TO RESIDENCES, BUT ALSO PROTECTS BETTER THAN CURRENTLY THOSE COMMUNITIES.
SO WHEN I SAY ADJACENT, IT DOESN'T NECESSARILY MEAN, IT DEFINITELY DOESN'T MEAN CLEAR CUTTING OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT.
IT DOESN'T NECESSARILY MEAN RIGHT ON THE BOUNDARY, BUT WITHIN PROBABLY A THOUSAND FEET OF THAT BOUNDARY.
SO I'M NOT TALKING MILES OUT OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT.
[01:15:01]
SO I GUESS MY, MY QUESTION WAS REALLY MEANT TO SAY THAT IF A SOUTHWESTERLY WIND IS PREVALENT, AND I BEL I HAD THOUGHT YOU HAD SAID BEFORE THAT YOU WERE TALKING ABOUT SOME FIREBREAK ACTIVITY THAT WOULD TAKE THE SPEED OUT OF A FIRE COMING FROM THE SOUTHWEST.IS THAT TYPE OF ACTIVITY STILL SOMEWHERE IN YOUR PLANNING? YEAH.
THAT, THAT'S WHAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT.
AND, AND IT'S STARTING AROUND THE VILLAGE OF OAK CREEK.
IF WE'RE SUCCESSFUL THERE, UM, HOPEFULLY LEARN FROM THAT.
IT, WE HAVE THE POTENTIAL IN THE FUTURE TO EXPAND TO OTHER NEIGHBORHOODS AND AREAS WITHIN SEDONA PROPER.
NOW ARE YOU SWAPPING FOR SOMEBODY ELSE? I THINK MULTIPLE PEOPLE.
I HAVE A CARD FROM KURT COMER.
PRESENTATION AND I BROUGHT IT.
MY QUESTION IS, UNDER WHICH OF THESE PRESENTATIONS WOULD YOU LIKE TO COMMENT ARE WHEN IS THAT DICK? IS KURT COMER HERE? YES, SHE'S SPEAKING.
DO YOU WANNA COMMENT NOW? NO, I CAN WAIT.
HOW DO I HIT FORWARD? JUST THAT.
ARE WE READY? DO YOU WANT ME TO PEOPLE FEEL HERE FOR IT? PARDON? STAND UP.
SO WE KNOW YOU AND I KNOW THE AUDIENCE KNOWS YOU, BUT THE PEOPLE AT HOME WATCHING MAY NOT KNOW YOU.
SO WOULD YOU PLEASE INTRODUCE YOURSELVES AND THE ORDER IN WHICH YOU ARE GOING TO SPEAK? EXCUSE ME.
THANK YOU MAYOR VICE MAYOR CITY COUNCIL.
I'M A MEMBER OF FRIENDS OF THE FOREST JOINING ME UP HERE TODAY.
UM, WHO WILL BE SPEAKING? SECOND IS TRACY RANDALL, COMBINATION OF VERDE, VERDE VALLEY CYCLIST COALITION AND SEDONA RED ROCK TRAIL FUND.
AND I ALSO HAVE DICK WILLIAMS FROM SEDONA RED ROCK TRAIL FUND.
OUT IN THE AUDIENCE IS A LOT OF OUR COMMUNITY THAT IS HERE TO SHOW THE SUPPORT.
UM, SO THANK YOU FOR ALL BEING HERE.
AND THERE'S A LOT OF OTHER PEOPLE WHO WERE HERE, UM, THAT WERE PART OF THIS.
SO KEVIN, I KNOW YOU CAME LATER, THERE'S SEATS OVER HERE.
IF YOU GUYS WANNA SIT, PLEASE COME IN.
SO AS YOU CAN SEE ON THE SLIDE THAT IS UP THERE, WE'RE GOING TO SIT HERE AND WE'RE GOING TO DO A LITTLE BIT OF AN CAP ABOUT THE TRAILS AND HOW IMPORTANT THEY ARE.
AND IT COMES FROM A LOT OF DIFFERENT CONVERSATIONS THAT HAPPENED OVER THE SUMMER.
UM, SOME OF IT WAS BY REQUEST AS PEOPLE WERE STARTING TO TALK ABOUT WHAT THE TRAILS NEED, AS YOU JUST HEARD FROM THE FOREST SERVICE, THEY HAVE A LOT GOING ON.
AND SO THEY USE A LOT OF DIFFERENT RESOURCES AND PARTNERS TO GET THINGS ACCOMPLISHED.
AND WE'RE LOOKING AT BEING ABLE TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO DO THAT A LITTLE BIT DIFFERENTLY GOING FORWARD.
WHAT IS UP ON THE SCREEN ARE THE ORGANIZATIONS THAT WE'RE INVOLVED IN THE CONVERSATIONS AROUND THIS.
WE HAD REPRESENTATIONS FROM THE CITY, FOF, FRIENDS OF THE FOREST, SEDONA, RED ROCK TRAIL FUND, THE FOREST SERVICE, AND VVCC.
WE ALSO BENCHMARKED SIX OTHER COMMUNITIES THAT HAVE SIMILAR DEMOGRAPHIC AND OR TRAIL CHALLENGES.
LIKE WE HAVE RESIDENTS, SIGNIFICANT TRAIL USE, SIGNIFICANT VISITORS TO TRY TO GET A BENCHMARK AND TO REALLY REALIZE WE DON'T NEED TO REINVENT THE WHEEL, BUT LET'S SEE WHAT SOME OTHER ORGANIZATIONS HAVE DEALT WITH AND HOW THEY HAVE HANDLED IT.
AND TO GO FROM THERE, YOU ARE GONNA NOTICE A FEW THEMES THROUGH ALL OF THIS ABOUT CONNECTING, PLANNING, FUNDING, AND DELIVERING.
I'M JUST GONNA PUT THAT UP FRONT.
AND REALLY OUR ASK OF THE CITY AT THIS POINT IS TO PARTNER WITH US ON THIS AND LOOKING AT THINGS MAYBE A LITTLE BIT DIFFERENTLY THAT HAVE BEEN LOOKED AT AT THE PAST.
AND THERE WILL BE SOME SPECIFIC ASKS MADE THAT ARE LONG TERM ASKS ALSO.
SO WE HAVE SOME SHORT TERM, SOME LONG TERM
[01:20:01]
NEXT.SO AS I MENTIONED, THE GROUP WAS, HMM, I'LL, I'LL KEEP TALKING.
SO THERE WERE 12 OF US WHO SPENT MANY MEETINGS TOGETHER TALKING ABOUT THE STATE OF THE TRAILS, WHAT WORKS, WHAT DOESN'T WORK, WHAT CAN WORK FOR THE FUTURE.
AND I'M SURE YOU CAN IMAGINE IT WAS A CONSTRUCTIVE CONVERSATION.
WE ALL HAD DIFFERENT OPINIONS, DIFFERENT THOUGHTS.
BUT REALLY AT THE END OF THE DAY, WHAT COMES OUT MORE STRONG THAN ANYTHING IS, BOY, DO WE HAVE A GROUP OF PEOPLE WHO ARE INCREDIBLY COMMITTED THAT LIVE IN THIS COMMUNITY TO MAKE IT BETTER.
WE CAME UP WITH FIVE OVERALL OPPORTUNITIES THAT WE IDENTIFIED THAT WE FINALLY HAD TO CLASSIFY ALL OUR LITTLE STICKY NOTES INTO THAT ARE UP ON THE SCREEN OF WHAT WE WERE TALKING ABOUT.
COLLABORATION WITH FEWER SILOS, THINKING BEYOND, IT SAYS UP THERE CITY LIMITS, BUT I'M GONNA ACTUALLY SAY ANY GEOGRAPHIC BOUNDARY 'CAUSE IT'S ALSO COUNTY LOOKING AT OUR TRIAL MAINTENANCE CAPACITY IN THE FUNDING OF IT.
HAVING CONSISTENT TRAIL CONDITIONS AND MAINTENANCE ACROSS THE DISTRICT AND LOOKING AT ACCESS AS PART OF A USER EXPERIENCE, WHICH WE'RE GONNA TALK A LITTLE BIT MORE ABOUT AGAIN, WITH THAT CAPACITY PLANNING, FUNDING AND DELIVERY WERE A THEME.
AND THAT'S REALLY WHAT WE SPEND A LOT OF TIME WITH WITH OUR BENCHMARK INFORMATION.
THE ASK THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT WITH THE CITY IS TO WORK WITH US IN PLANNING ACROSS MULTIPLE ORGANIZATIONS TO LOOK AT THIS AS ONE TRIAL SYSTEM, INCLUDING ACCESS TO THAT SYSTEM AND NOT HAVING IT DEFINED AND ALSO INCREASING THE INVESTMENT.
A LOT OF THE REST OF WHAT WE'RE GONNA TALK ABOUT IS WHY THIS IS SO IMPORTANT.
SO THIS IS A SNAPSHOT OF WHAT WE HAVE HERE.
AND WHILE THE RED ROCK RANGER DISTRICT ACTUALLY HAS OVER 500 MILES OF NON-MOTORIZED TRAIL, WE LOOKED AT THE SMALLER FOOTPRINT OF, AND I REALLY DON'T WANT TO USE THE GREATER SEDONA RECREATION FOOTPRINT TERM BECAUSE I KNOW WHAT EVERYBODY AUTOMATICALLY THINKS OF THAT, BUT IT KIND OF IS THAT FOOTPRINT.
SO WE'RE TALKING ABOUT OUTSIDE OF SEDONA, INSIDE SEDONA, THE VOC AND WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE IN THAT AREA.
AND IT, YOU KNOW, WE'RE TALKING ABOUT SOME GOOD 400 MILES WORTH OF TRAILS.
WE KNOW WE HAVE OVER 300, 3 MILLION VISITORS THAT COME HERE A YEAR.
I AM THE LAST PERSON WHO WILL EVER SAY THAT EVERYONE WHO COMES HERE IS BASED ON RECREATION.
I'M ALSO THE LAST PERSON WHO SAY IT'S ALL ABOUT ARTS AND CULTURE.
IT'S A COMBINATION OF THE TWO.
PEOPLE COME HERE FOR THE MOUNTAIN BIKE FESTIVAL OR YOGA FESTIVAL.
THEY'RE ALSO GOING INTO OUR STORES AND GOING INTO OUR GALLERIES.
JUST LIKE IF YOU'RE HERE FOR AN ART EXHIBIT OR A WORKSHOP, YOU'RE PROBABLY TAKING ADVANTAGE OF OUR INCREDIBLE TRAILS AND GOING TO USE THEM.
SO THAT BILLION DOLLARS IS AN IMPACT THAT IS SHARED ACROSS MULTIPLE DEMOGRAPHICS.
BUT A LOT OF IT GETS FOCUSED BACK INTO RECREATION.
AND WE KNOW FROM DIFFERENT STUDIES, AND IT'S FOOTNOTED IN THE SOURCES THAT 70 PER OVER 70% OF THE PEOPLE WHO VISIT SOMEHOW TAKE ADVANTAGE OF OUR, OUR NON-MOTORIZED TRIALS.
THE CITY IS INCREDIBLE ABOUT CONTINUING TO HAVE GREAT CONNECTORS WITHIN THE CITY AND HAVING SHARED USE PATHS, LOOKING AT PEDESTRIANS, LOOKING AT ABOUT BIKERS, SHARING ROADS.
WE ACTUALLY WANNA EXPAND ON THAT.
AND I KNOW THE CITY HAS GOT PLANS TO BE DOING THAT AND ADDING ALMOST THREE TIMES THAT AMOUNT INTO THE FUTURE.
AND I THINK THAT IS REALLY KEY.
ONE OF THE THINGS THAT TOUCHES ON GOING BACK TO BUT LOOKING BEYOND CITY LIMITS AND LOOKING BEYOND THE ACTUAL GEOGRAPHIC LINES IS IF YOU'RE VISITING HERE, YOU DON'T THINK ABOUT RECREATING IN THE CITY LIMITS OF SEDONA.
SO WHEN PEOPLE SAY THEY'RE COMING TO SEDONA AND THEY LOVE SEDONA AND PEOPLE, I DON'T KNOW WHO SAID IT EARLIER, UM, PEOPLE EVERYWHERE IN THE WORLD KNOW SEDONA, MAYBE MAYOR IT WAS YOU.
UM, THAT COULD MEAN TO THEM WAY DOWN SOUTH IN THE VOC THAT COULD BE STAYING OUT IN ENCHANTMENT.
WHEN THEY'RE RECREATING, THEY'RE NOT THINKING ABOUT WHERE THEY'RE AT WITHIN THE CITY BOUNDARY.
SO AN EXAMPLE WOULD BE IF YOU WERE TALKING ABOUT SHUTTLE EXPANSION, THEY'RE THINKING ABOUT, WELL WHY CAN'T I TAKE A SHUTTLE FROM AM GONNA GO CATHEDRAL.
I'M GOING MY ROUTE ALL THE WAY DOWN TO THE BELL ROCK TRAILHEAD.
THAT IS NOT ONE OF THEIR OPTIONS, BUT THAT'S HOW THEY RECREATE.
SO ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WE'RE ADVOCATING AND WE'RE LOOKING AT IS LET'S LOOK AT OUR, THE VIEW THAT WE LOOK THROUGH EVERYTHING A LITTLE BIT DIFFERENTLY AND LOOK AT RECREATION AND HOW WE MANAGE OUR TRAIL SYSTEM AS OUR USERS USE IT.
AND NOT JUST THE VISITORS WHO ARE HERE, BUT ALSO OUR RESIDENTS THAT ARE HERE.
ALEX MADE REFERENCE SEVERAL TIMES TO PARTNERS AND HERE'S JUST A FEW OF THEM.
AND IMAGINE THAT IT'S THE THREE OF US WHO ARE SITTING UP HERE.
UM, THE RED ROCK TRAIL FUND IS A HUGE FUNDER.
THE MILLIONS AND MILLIONS OF DOLLARS OVER
[01:25:01]
THE YEARS THAT THEY HAVE GIVEN HAVE THEY HAVE RAISED AND THEY'VE TURNED OVER TO THE FOREST SERVICE TO USE FOR SEASONAL SUPPORT FOR CONTRACTORS, FOR SIGNAGE, YOU NAME IT.THEY ALSO WORK WITH INDIVIDUALS, OTHER NONPROFITS AND BUSINESSES TO BE ABLE TO RAISE THIS MONEY, INCLUDING FROM THE CITY.
THE VBCC IS AN INCREDIBLE GROUP OF PEOPLE WHO ARE OUT ON THESE TRAILS ALL THE TIME AND ADVOCATING FOR MOUNTAIN BIKING, ROADS, ROAD BIKING, SAFETY AND HOW CAN IT BE IMPROVED WHEN IT'S HERE.
AND WITH THEM BEING OUT THERE ON A REGULAR BASIS, I THINK THEY PROBABLY KNOW SOME OF THESE TRIALS BETTER THAN ANYBODY 'CAUSE THEY'RE ON THEM A CRAZY AMOUNT OF TIME, WHICH IS INCREDIBLE.
AND WITH THAT, THEY ARE MAKING RECOMMENDATIONS AND NOT JUST MAKING THE RECOMMENDATION AND SUGGESTIONS, BUT THEY'RE ACTUALLY PITCHING IN FUNDING AND HELPING TO ACTUALLY MAINTAIN AND BUILD TRIALS.
FRIENDS OF THE FOREST DOES A WHOLE LOT OF DIFFERENT THINGS ACROSS THE FOREST.
SOME THINGS HAVE ABSOLUTELY NOTHING TO DO WITH TRAIL, BUT WE DO SPEND A BIG PORTION OF OUR TIME HELPING WITH TRAIL MAINTENANCE ACROSS THE BOARD.
THESE ORGANIZATIONS ARE NOT TAKING OVER ANYTHING FROM THE FOREST SERVICE AND WE'RE NOT ASKING FOREST SERVICE DOESN'T ASK US TO BE RESPONSIBLE, JUST LIKE WE'RE NOT ASKING THE CITY TO BE RESPONSIBLE, BUT THE CAPACITY OF WHAT WE NEED FOR GR GOING FORWARD.
AND IF YOU THINK ABOUT THE TRAILS THAT FOREST SERVICE WOULD LIKE TO BUILD GOING FORWARD, IT'S NOT SUSTAINABLE WITH THE MODEL OF HOW WE'RE LOOKING AT IT AND LITTLE CHUNKS AND PIECES.
SO THAT'S PART OF WHAT THE REST OF THIS PRESENTATION IS ABOUT, IS REALLY LOOKING AT HOW CAN WE GOING FORWARD, TAKE WHAT WE'VE LEARNED, TAKE WHAT WE HAVE, AND CONTINUE, CONTINUE TO BUILD ON IT.
THE LAST POINT I WANT TO POINT I WANNA MAKE BEFORE I HAND IT OVER TO TRACY IS ALL THESE PEOPLE WHO ARE IN THIS ROOM, I'M GONNA SAY MORE THAN HALF OF THEM THAT ARE HERE REPRESENTING THE TRIALS ARE IN AT LEAST TWO, IF NOT THREE OF THOSE ORGANIZATIONS THAT ARE UP ON THAT SCREEN, PLUS OTHERS.
THERE'S PLENTY OF THEM THAT WE DIDN'T INCLUDE JUST 'CAUSE WE COULDN'T INCLUDE ANYONE.
AND I THINK THAT'S A REALLY IMPORTANT THING FOR THE CITY TO RECOGNIZE IS THESE ARE PEOPLE WHO LIVE HERE, WHETHER THEY'RE IN CITY LIMITS OR NOT, THEY GIVE BACK TO OUR TRAILS ALL THE TIME.
OR THEY'RE TRYING TO MAKE THE EXPERIENCE BETTER, NOT ONLY FOR THEMSELVES AS A RESIDENT, BUT ALSO FOR THE VISITORS THAT ARE HERE.
UM, GOOD EVENING COUNCIL MEMBERS.
I ALREADY GOT INTRODUCED BY MELISSA, SO YOU KNOW WHO I AM.
UM, I DO WANNA DO ONE CALL OUT TO ALL THE TRAIL SUPPORTERS THAT CAME OUT AND I THINK IT'S MORE THAN HALF OF THE AUDIENCE, SO PLEASE GIVE A LITTLE CLAP.
SO I'M GONNA SPEND, I'M GONNA COVER THE NEXT FIVE SLIDES, UM, AND REALLY COVER WHERE THE PARTNERSHIP IS STRETCHED.
MELISSA COVERED THE RAH RAH ON WHAT'S WORKING, AND I GOT THE, HEY, THIS IS WHAT WE NEED TO DO BETTER.
UM, AND A LOT OF THAT WAS THROUGH INTERVIEWING OTHER TRAIL COMMUNITIES.
SO I WANNA START BY SAYING CLEARLY THAT THIS PARTNERSHIP IS GETTING A LOT DONE.
LAST SEASON, THE FOREST SERVICE WITH NONPROFITS AND VOLUNTEERS BUILT SIX AND A HALF MILES OF TRAIL AND MAINTAINED 182 MILES ACROSS THE RED ROCK RANGER DISTRICT.
THAT'S A SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF WORK.
AND WHAT DID IT TAKE TO MAKE IT HAPPEN? AS ALEX POINTED OUT, WE HAVE ONE PERMANENT PERMANENT FOREST SERVICE EMPLOYEE.
WE HAVE A SEASONAL TRAIL CREW OF 10 TO 13 FOLKS WITH A CREW BOSS WHO'S HERE AS WELL.
UM, WHO ARE EMPLOYED THROUGH A PARTNERSHIP BETWEEN WHEEL FUND AND THE SEDONA RED ROCK TRAIL FUND.
3,500 VOLUNTEER HOURS AS A COMPED DESK VERSUS OTHERS.
WE WOULD ONLY BE BEHIND PRESCOTT.
WE HAVE MORE VOLUNTEER HOURS THAN ANY OF THOSE OTHER TOWNS THAT YOU SAW.
CONSERVATION CREWS AND CONTRACTORS.
OUR PARTNERSHIP IS CREATIVE IN COMBINING PEOPLE FUNDING AND VOLUNTEER SUPPORT.
WHERE IS IT STRETCHED FIRST ACCESS.
AND A FEW PEOPLE TOUCHED ON THAT.
WE PLAN THE DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE TRAIL USER EXPERIENCE SEPARATELY.
THE FOREST SERVICE MANAGES TRAILS AND TRAIL HEADS WITH NON-PROFIT AND CITY REQUESTS.
THE CITY PLANS SHARED USE PATHWAYS AND OPERATES THE SHUTTLE, SHUTTLE WITH FOREST SERVICE AND CITIZEN INPUT AND MANY TRAILS.
TRAIL HEADS AND TRAIL ACCESS POINTS FALL OUTSIDE CITY LIMITS.
BUT AS MELISSA POINTED OUT, THAT IS NOT HOW THE USER EXPERIENCES THE TRAILS.
PEOPLE EXPERIENCE THE ENTIRE TRIP FROM HOW THEY GET THERE TO THE TRAIL, HEAD TO THE CONDITION OF THE TRAILS.
THEY DON'T KNOW OR CARE WHETHER THEY CROSS FROM CITY TO COUNTY TO FOREST SERVICE PROPERTY.
[01:30:01]
THE SECOND ISSUE IS OUR PIPELINE.WE DON'T HAVE ONE SHARED PRIORITIZED PROJECT LIST FOR THE RED ROCK RANGER DISTRICT.
AND PUTTING THIS PRESENTATION TOGETHER, THAT BECAME VERY CLEAR TO ME.
THE THIRD ISSUE IS CONSISTENCY.
WHILE WE'VE MADE SOME EXCELLENT INVESTMENTS IN FLAGSHIP TRAIL PROJECTS, OTHER TRAILS CONTINUE TO DE DETERIORATE BECAUSE THEY AREN'T RECEIVING ENOUGH MAINTENANCE.
NONE OF THIS IS INTENDED TO CRITICIZE AN INDIVIDUAL PROJECT OR A PARTNER.
IT JUST ILLUSTRATES WHY THE PARTNERS NEED A SHARED PROCESS LOOKING AT THE WHOLE TRAIL AND ACCESS SYSTEM BEFORE INDIVIDUAL PROJECTS MOVE FORWARD.
THE PARTNERSHIP IS DELIVERING, IT'S JUST CARRYING MORE THAN THE CURRENT STRUCTURE WAS BUILT TO CARRY.
AND THE STAFFING NUMBERS ON THE NEXT SLIDE MAKE THAT VERY CLEAR.
I IF YOU REMEMBER ONE NUMBER ON THIS SLIDE, REMEMBER THE NUMBER ONE, HE'S OVER THERE
UM, WE HAVE ONE PERMANENT FOREST SERVICE TRAIL EMPLOYEE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE PLANNING, COORDINATION, SUPERVISION, AND CONTINUITY OF THE TRAIL SYSTEM WITH OVER 400 MILES.
SEDONA NOW HAS A MULTI-MODAL COORDINATOR, WHICH IS A VERY POSITIVE ADDITION, BUT HOW MUCH THAT POSITION WILL FOCUS ON TRAILS AND TRAIL ACCESS IS STILL BEING WORKED THROUGH THE TRAIL FUND HELP FUND THE SEASONAL TRAIL CREW AND TRAIL BOSS.
THAT CREW GIVES US A LOT OF FIELD CAPACITY, BUT THOSE EMPLOYEES HAVE TO BE RECRUITED, HIRED, TRAINED, AND SUPERVISED SEASON AFTER SEASON.
JUST AS THE CREW BECOMES EXPERIENCED AND STARTS WORKING WELL TOGETHER, THE SEASON ENDS.
SEASONAL CREWS AND VOLUNTEERS WORK BEST WHEN THEY'RE ADDING CAPACITY TO A STABLE TEAM.
THAT'S WHAT'S REALLY STOOD OUT.
WHEN WE SPOKE TO OTHER HIGH TOURIST TRAIL TOWNS, BASED ON OUR DISCUSSION, MOAB HAS 13 PERMANENT POSITIONS SUPPORTING 200 MILES.
BREVARD HAS 19 SUPPORTING 490 MILES, AND PARK CITY HAS 28 ACROSS A REGIONAL SYSTEM, ABOUT 400 MILES.
TRACY, CAN I ASK YOU A QUESTION? YEP.
WHO, WHO DO THESE EMPLOYEES REPORT TO OR THAT'S THE NEXT THING?
THOSE PEOPLE DON'T ALL WORK FOR ONE ORGANIZATION.
THEY'RE SPREAD ACROSS FEDERAL AND STATE AGENCIES, LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND NONPROFITS.
AND IF YOU WANT THE DETAILS I HAVE PER AREA WHERE THEY'RE EMPLOYED BY, UM, I COVERED A LITTLE BIT MORE LATER IN THE PRESENTATION.
IT, IT A BIT DEPENDS WHAT THE LAND IS, BUT I WILL TELL YOU ALMOST ALL OF THEM ONLY HAVE ONE OR TWO FOREST SERVICE EMPLOYEES.
THE OTHER STAFF ARE COMING FROM NONPROFITS, THE CITIES AND THE COUNTIES.
THE LESSON IS THAT THE, EXCUSE ME, ANNETTE HAS, OH, I'M SORRY.
UM, I WAS WONDERING IF YOU COULD, UM, I THINK IT MIGHT BE LATER IN THE SLIDE.
BUT CLARIFY THE CITY'S SUPPORT FOR THE SEASONAL CREW BECAUSE I THINK WE CONTRIBUTE UP TO ALMOST 150,000 A YEAR BETWEEN THE FOREST SERVICE AND RED ROCK TRAIL FUND TO HELP PAY FOR CREWS IN ADDITION TO OUR MULTIMODAL COORDINATOR.
WE DID I DO COVER THAT IN HERE.
THE LESSON IS THAT THESE SUCCESSFUL TRAIL REGIONS HAVE BUILT PERMANENT CAPACITY ACROSS SEVERAL ORGANIZATIONS.
THEN THEY USE SEASONAL CREWS, CONTRACTORS, AND VOLUNTEERS TO EXTEND WHAT THE PERMANENT TEAM CAN ACCOMPLISH HERE.
NEARLY ALL THAT RESPONSIBILITY COMES BACK TO ONE PERMANENT FOREST SERVICE POSITION.
THAT'S A MAJOR REASON THE BACKLOG CONTINUES TO GROW EVEN THOUGH THE PARTNERSHIP WORKS EFFICIENTLY.
SO THERE'S A LOT OF NUMBERS ON THIS SLIDE, BUT THE BASIC MESSAGE IS VERY SIMPLE.
WE'RE GETTING A LOT OF WORK DONE FOR THE MONEY WE'RE INVESTING, BUT WE'RE NOT INVESTING ENOUGH TO KEEP UP.
TURKEY CREEK CONSTRUCTION HAS AVERAGED $34,000 PER MILE.
THAT'S BELOW THE AVERAGE OF THE PEERS WE INTERVIEWED AND ABOUT HALF THE BENCHMARK FROM I BETRAYAL SOLUTIONS.
OUR ANNUAL MAINTENANCE INVESTMENT
[01:35:01]
PER MILE IS ALSO BELOW BOTH THE PEER AVERAGE IN THE IBA BENCHMARKS THAT SHOWS HOW EFFECTIVELY THE FOREST SERVICE NONPROFITS, SEASONAL CREWS, CONTRACTORS, AND VOLUNTEERS STRETCH EACH DOLLAR.BUT SPENDING LESS PER MILE IS ONLY A GOOD THING IF THE WORK KEEPS UP WITH WHAT THE TRAILS NEED.
THE GREEN COLUMN SHOWS THAT IT IS NOT THE TRAIL FUND AND THE RED ROCK RANGER DISTRICT HIRED A CONTRACTOR FLAG LINE TRAILS TO ASSESS 201 MILES OR ABOUT HALF THE RED ROCK RANGER DISTRICT TRAIL SYSTEM.
THAT ASSESSMENT IDENTIFIED 46,000 HOURS OF NEEDED MAINTENANCE THAT WORKS OUT TO 227 HOURS PER MILE.
LAST, LAST YEAR, THE PARTNERSHIP COMPLETED 8,000 HOURS OF MAINTENANCE ACROSS THE 182 MILES MAINTAINED.
THAT'S ABOUT 44 HOURS PER MILE.
SO ABOUT 80% OF WHAT WE ASSESSED WE NEEDED TO DO.
SO WE'RE COMPLETING ONLY A PORTION OF THE WORK THAT'S BEEN IDENTIFIED.
I'M GONNA GIVE YOU AN ILLUSTRATION OF ONE OF THE TRAILS.
A TRAIL LIKE TEACUP GIVES YOU A PRACTICAL EXAMPLE OF WHAT THIS LOOKS LIKE IN THE TRAIL.
THE TEAM MIGHT IDENTIFY MORE THAN 20 MAINTENANCE NEEDS ON THE TRAIL.
WE PRIORITIZE 10 OF THEM, BUT THE RESOURCES AVAILABLE ON ANY GIVEN WORKDAY, WE CAN ONLY COMPLETE FOUR OR FIVE OF THEM.
THE REST STAYS ON A LIST AND DEFERRED MAINTENANCE COMPOUNDS.
A DRAINAGE ISSUE BECOMES AN EROSION PROBLEM.
A SMALL TREAD FAILURE BECOMES A MUCH LARGER RECONSTRUCTION PROJECT.
THE LONGER THE WORK WEIGHTS, THE MORE DIFFICULT AND EXPENSIVE IT BECOMES BASED ON THE ASSESSED NEED.
WE ESTIMATE THAT THE RED ROCK RANGER DISTRICT HAS BETWEEN 1.2 AND 2.4 MILLION IN DEFERRED MAINTENANCE.
THAT BACKLOG AFFECTS MORE THAN THE PHYSICAL TRAIL ERODING TREAD POOR DRAINAGE AND DEGRADED CONDITIONS AFFECT THE TRAIL USER EXPERIENCE FOR RESIDENTS AND VISITORS.
SO OUR CONCLUSION IS THAT THE PARTNERSHIP IS EFFICIENT, HOWEVER, IT JUST DOESN'T HAVE THE PERMANENT STAFFING AND FUNDING NEEDED TO KEEP PACE WITH THE SYSTEM.
SO THIS NEXT SLIDE, A LOT OF PEOPLE COVERED ABOUT THIS.
YOU KNOW, THE CITY IS OBVIOUSLY DOING QUITE A LOT AND WE RECOGNIZE THAT YOU'VE MADE MEANINGFUL INVESTMENTS IN THE TRAILS AND ACCESS.
UM, ANNETTE JUST COMMENTED ON SOME OF THE MONEY, UM, THOSE INCLUDE THE TRAILHEAD SHUTTLE SHARED USE PATHWAYS SUPPORT FOR THE FOREST SERVICE AND TRAIL WORK.
THE NEW MULTIMODAL COORDINATOR, OBVIOUSLY WE JUST TALKED ABOUT THE ASSISTANCE WITH BROKEN ARROW TRAIL HEAD AND THE FOREST ROAD 1 52 C.
ALL OF THOSE INVESTMENTS ARE HELPING IMPROVE ACCESS, REDUCING VEHICLE PRESSURE, AND MAKING THE OVERALL, UM, PARTNERSHIP STRONGER.
BUT WHAT WE'RE SUGGESTING IS BUILDING UPON THOSE INVESTMENTS BY LOOKING AT A LARGER FOOTPRINT.
YOU HEARD A FEW PEOPLE BRING THIS UP.
UM, YOU KNOW THE FEW EXAMPLES HERE, STATE ROUTE 1 79, EXTENDING THE SHUTTLE TO YPE VISTA COURTHOUSE, VISTA BELL ROCK COULD SERVE A VERY BUSY CORRIDOR AND MAKE MORE POINT TO POINT RECREATION POSSIBLE.
THE TRAIL FUND MADE A SIGNIFICANT INVESTMENT WITH THE FOREST SERVICE IN THE DO MOUNTAIN.
UM, HAVING A SHUTTLE STOP OUT THERE WITH AN EXPANDED TRAIL HEAD WOULD BE QUITE MEANINGFUL.
THESE ARE JUST EXAMPLES, YOU KNOW, THE LARGER POINT IS THAT TRAILS, TRAILHEAD, SHUTTLES AND PATHWAYS SHOULD BE PLANNED TOGETHER AND PLAN BEYOND CITY LIMITS.
OKAY, MY LAST SLIDE THEN DICK GETS TO TAKE IT OVER.
SO THIS IS A LITTLE BIT MORE INFORMATION AND IT'S GONNA TIE INTO WHAT DICK'S GONNA WALK YOU THROUGH.
SO WHEN WE INTERVIEWED, UM, ALL THE TRAIL COMMUNITIES, ONE WAS ASKING ABOUT SPENDING, RIGHT? SO THAT'S WHERE WE GOT SOME OF THE COMPS ON WHAT THEY WERE SPENDING ON MAINTENANCE, WHAT THEY WERE SPENDING ON BUILDING.
BUT THE OTHER THING WE REALLY WANTED TO UNDERSTAND IS WHO BRINGS EVERYONE TOGETHER? HOW DO THEY PAY FOR THE SYSTEM AND WHO GETS THE WORK DONE? AND THROUGH INTERVIEWING EVERYONE, THERE WERE REALLY TWO CITIES THAT STAND STOOD OUT CONSISTENTLY ACROSS PLANNING, FUNDING, AND DELIVERY.
AND THEN WE THOUGHT THERE WERE A FEW STANDOUT CITIES THAT WERE DOING THINGS THAT WE THOUGHT WOULD BE INTERESTING TO HIGHLIGHT.
SO MOAB PREDOMINANTLY DOES THIS THROUGH A COUNTY EFFORT.
UM, GRAND COUNTY IS THE NAME OF THEIR COUNTY,
[01:40:01]
AND MOAB TRAIL MIX IS AN ADVISORY COMMITTEE THAT BRINGS THE PARTNERS AND USERS TOGETHER.AND GCA PROVIDES THE PROFESSIONAL, UM, STAFF WHO MOVE PRIORITIES ALONG IN PARK CITY.
THE MOUNTAIN TRAILS FOUNDATION, THAT, WHICH I'VE TALKED TO THIS WOMAN SEVERAL TIMES.
UM, THEY PROVIDE MUCH OF THAT CONTINUITY ACROSS THE CITY, BASIN RECREATION, SUMMIT COUNTY, AND THE RESORT RESORTS AND LANDOWNERS.
FLAGSTAFF OFFERS ANOTHER, AT LEAST GOOD PLANNING EXAMPLE.
UM, THEY DID SOMETHING CALLED THE PLA, THE FLAGSTAFF TRAILS INITIATIVE, WHERE THEY BROUGHT PARTNERS TOGETHER FOR TRAILS AND ACCESS AROUND A SHARED REGIONAL STRATEGY.
I'M SORRY, YOU'RE SAYING THE CITY LED THAT EFFORT.
IT WAS ACTUALLY A NONPROFIT THAT THEY FORMED SPECIFICALLY TO PUT THE PLAN TOGETHER.
UM, THERE ISN'T ONE ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE.
WHAT MATTERS IS THAT SOMEONE LEADS THE PROCESS.
THE PARTNERS MEET REGULARLY AND PRIORITIES MOVE FROM PLANNING INTO FUNDING INTO DELIVERY.
SO THEY'RE NOT SEPARATE ACTIVITIES.
THE, THE FUNDING SOURCES ALSO VARY.
UM, AND THE SCALE AND INVERSE DIVERSITY OF THE INVESTMENTS STOOD OUT.
MOAB COMBINES COUNTY AND C CITY FUNDING WITH FEDERAL AND STATE PROGRAMS, GRANTS AND RECREATION FEES.
SAND FLATS ALONE, UM, GENERATES ABOUT 1.24 MILLION IN ANNUAL REVENUES.
AND A SIGNIFICANT PORTION GOES BACK TO THE TRAILS AND PARK CITY.
THEY COMBINE PUBLIC FUNDING, INCLUDING ITS RESORT SALES TAX WITH NONPROFIT SUPPORT.
THE MOUNTAIN TRAILS FOUNDATION REPORTED APPROXIMATELY 2.1 MILLION OF ANNUAL REVENUES.
AND JUST TO PUT INTO PERSPECTIVE, THAT'S ABOUT THREE X WHAT WE'RE DOING RIGHT NOW AT THE TRAIL FUND.
UM, STEAMBOAT PROVIDES A GOOD EXAMPLE AND THAT IT'S A VERY CITY FOCUSED FUNDING MECHANISM.
UM, IT'S VOTERS DEDICATED AND AG ACCOMMODATIONS, TAX REVENUE TO TRAILS BEGINNING AT $300,000 ANNUALLY AND MOVING TO $600,000 ANNUALLY.
THE CITY USES VISITOR GENERATED FUNDING FOR REGIONAL PROJECTS, INCLUDING TRAILS ON FEDERAL LANDS OUTSIDE OF THEIR CITY LIMITS.
AGAIN, THE LESSON IS THERE'S NO SINGLE PERSON THAT'S CARRYING THE MAJORITY OF THE COSTS.
PUBLIC FUNDING IS PROVIDING A FOUNDATION AND NONPROFITS GRANTS AND USER FEES ARE CONTRIBUTING TO THAT.
AND THEN THE SAME PATTERN SHOWS UP IN DELIVERY.
SO SOMEONE ASKED ME ABOUT THAT.
A GOOD PORTION OF MOAB STAFF IS COUNTY.
THERE IS CONTRIBUTION FROM OTHER PUBLIC AGENCIES THAT ARE, ARE CONTRIBUTING TO THAT TRAIL NUMBER.
UM, LET'S SEE, IN PARK CITY, THE MOUNTAIN TRAILS FOUNDATION ACTUALLY EMPLOYS 17 FOLKS.
THE CITY'S FOUR, UH, BASIN RECREATION I THINK HAS SEVEN.
AND SO IT'S SPREAD ACROSS A NUMBER OF ENTITIES.
UM, BREVARD IS AN INTERESTING ONE BECAUSE THEY, THEIR LAND WOULD BE VERY SIMILAR TO SEDONA.
AND THEN IT'S PREDOMINANTLY FOREST SERVICE LAND.
AND I THINK FIVE DIFFERENT NONPROFITS END UP MAKING UP THE BULK OF THAT.
IN ADDITION TO SOME CITY AND STATE STAFF, THE STRUCTURES DIFFER, BUT THE BASIC FORMULA IS THE SAME.
CONNECT, PLANNING, FUNDING, AND DELIVERY.
THESE COMMUNITIES ALSO INVEST BEYOND THEIR JURISDICTIONAL BOUNDARIES BECAUSE RESIDENTS AND VISITORS EXPERIENCE ONE REGIONAL TRAIL SYSTEM, NOT A COLLECTION OF GOVERNMENT BOUNDARIES.
NONE OF THEM BUILT THIS OVERNIGHT.
THEY BEGAN BY BRINGING THE RIGHT PEOPLE TOGETHER, AGREEING ON SHARED PRIORITIES AND DECIDING WHO WOULD MOVE FORWARD THOSE SHARED PRIORITIES.
THAT BRINGS US TO WHERE WE'RE ASKING THE CITY TO HELP US.
AND DICK WILL WALK YOU THROUGH THAT NOW.
CITY AND STAFF AND THE FOLKS HERE.
UM, YOU KNOW, THE ANALOGY OF WHAT'S WHAT'S HAPPENED SO FAR IS, IS LIKE A STAND OF ASPEN TREES.
THEY'RE ALL INDIVIDUAL, BUT THEY HAVE A ROOT SYSTEM IN THERE.
WHAT WE'D LIKE TO PROPOSE IS SOMETHING THAT STRENGTH, STRENGTH STRENGTHENS THAT ROOT SYSTEM BETWEEN ALL OF THEM.
AND THE FIRST THING IS WE'RE GONNA FORM THIS GROUP TRAILS, TRAILS ACCESS WORKING GROUP.
AND WE WOULD LIKE THE CITY TO BE INVOLVED.
WE WOULD LIKE THE CITY TO HAVE A REPRESENTATIVE OR REPRESENTATIVES ON THERE.
[01:45:01]
HAVE THE EAR OF THE CITY, EAR OF THE COUNCIL, EAR OF THE STAFF, AND CAN COME IN TO TO, TO OUR MEETINGS AND, AND WORK TOGETHER.WE THINK THAT'S, THAT'S REALLY IMPORTANT.
ANNETTE TALKED ABOUT THE MONEY, THE SHARED, SHARED USE PASS.
BUT GOING FORWARD WE WOULD LIKE TO PUT THAT TOGETHER.
HOW OFTEN WOULD THAT BE CONVENING? UH, WE THINK QUARTERLY FOR THE MEETING.
AND KATHY, ONE OF OUR, UH, UM, GOALS AND IT'S IN THE, THE, UH, PRESENTATION IS THAT WE WOULD COME BACK AND REPORT TO THE CITY ON A PERIODIC BASIS AND LET Y'ALL KNOW WHAT'S GOING ON.
BUT HOPEFULLY THE PERSON FROM THE CITY ON THE TEAM HAS KEPT Y'ALL INFORMED ALSO.
SO IT'S A, YOU KNOW, IT'S A SYMBIOTIC RELATIONSHIP GOING BACK AND FORTH.
UM, WE WOULD LIKE THE CITY TO, TO, UM, BE IN THE PLANNING PROCESS.
UM, ALEX TALKED ABOUT HIS, HIS THINGS GOING ON.
UH, THEY ALSO HAVE A LONGER TERM PLAN THAT THEY'RE WORKING ON WITH ALL, WITH ALL THE RECREATION.
UM, FROM THE NONPROFIT STANDPOINT, WE LIKE PLANS BECAUSE WE CAN GO FIND SUPPORT AND, AND WHAT HAVE YOU.
AND WITH A PLAN, WE CAN FIGURE OUT HOW MANY PEOPLE WE NEED, HOW MUCH MONEY WE NEED, AND MAYBE THERE IS A DIFFERENT MODEL THAT WE CAN PUT TOGETHER.
IT GOES, UH, ON THE INVESTMENT SIDE, THIS IS THE DOLLAR ASK.
I REALIZE, AND WE REALIZE THAT THE, UH, BUDGET PROCESS IS A, IS A SEPARATE TIMING OF THIS.
BUT, UM, WE WOULD LIKE THE CITY TO CONTINUE THEIR $60,000 SUPPORT TO THE FOREST SERVICE.
UH, WE WOULD LIKE THE CITY TO, UM, UH, UP THEIR, THEIR TRAIL KEEPER SUPPORT TO $87,500.
AND THERE IS SCIENCE BEHIND THAT NUMBER.
WE HAVE ACTUALLY, UM, INCREASED THE NEXT FIVE YEAR CYCLE ON TRAIL KEEPERS TO, UH, $1,250 A YEAR.
WE ARE LOOKING FOR 70, UH, UH, TRAIL KEEPERS.
AND SO, UH, SO IT'S GOING WELL.
AND THEN THE LAST ONE, IT'S CALLED ENABLE, BUT UM, IT'S A PHILOSOPHICAL ONE AND WE'VE TALKED ABOUT THAT.
AND THAT IS GOING PAST THE CITY BOUNDARIES.
AND WE'RE NOT ASKING THAT, THAT Y'ALL DO THIS WILLY-NILLY.
UH, IT, IT WOULD BE SOMETHING THOUGHTFUL THAT WOULD BENEFIT THE RESIDENTS OF SEDONA AS WELL AS THE VISITORS.
AND AT THE END OF THE DAY, WE'RE HOPING WHAT WE COME UP WITH IS LEVERAGING WHAT WE ALL HAVE DONE.
WHEREAS IT'S NOT JUST ONE PLUS ONE PLUS ONE PLUS ONE EQUALS FOUR.
IT'S ONE PLUS ONE PLUS ONE PLUS ONE PLUS ONE EQUALS SEVEN.
I MEAN, UH, WE THINK IT'S THERE.
WE THINK, WE THINK YOU CAN DO IT.
UM, DICK, BEFORE YOU MOVE ON, I'M SORRY.
HAVE YOU TALKED WITH EITHER OR BOTH YAVAPAI, COCONINO COUNTIES TO BE INCLUDED IN THIS? HOLLY? WE UH, WE GOT THAT SUGGESTION LATE.
WELL, AND IT'S A GREAT THOUGHT BECAUSE, BECAUSE, BECAUSE A PERFECT EXAMPLE IS OUT DRY CREEK ROAD INTO DOE, MOUNTAIN AND BEAR AND THAT WHOLE AREA, THAT'S YAVAPI COUNTY.
AND SO TO ME THAT WOULD BE A GREAT PROJECT THAT WE COULD ALL RALLY AROUND AND FIGURE OUT HOW TO WORK ON SOMETHING LIKE THAT.
UM, AND UH, AND WE GOT SOME PRELIMINARY INDICATION THAT YAVAPAI WOULD BE INTERESTED.
WE'VE JUST NOT CONTACTED COCONINO WOULD BE WHAT AVA PIE WOULD BE.
WE JUST HAVEN'T CONTACTED COCONINO.
WE DON'T KNOW WHO TO CONTACT IN COCONINO TO BE HONEST WITH YOU.
SO TAMMY, OUR, OUR SUPERVISOR.
SO, UM, GOING ON, UH, THIS IS A WALK, JOG, RUN MODEL HERE.
UM, UH, WE WANT TO FORM THIS TEAM BY THE END OF THE YEAR.
UH, ONE OF US THREE NON-PROFITS AT THIS TABLE WILL OFFER TO CHAIR IT AND GET IT, GET IT GOING.
WE WOULD JUST LIKE THE CITY TO BE THERE.
UM, THE BIG THINGS WE WOULD DO IS, UH, CONFIRM THAT THE, UH, SCOPE AND MISSION.
WE THINK WE'RE ALREADY PRETTY MUCH THERE.
AND TO BASICALLY, UM, START LOOKING AT ONE PROJECT THAT WE COULD RALLY AROUND AND GO FOR, UH, KNOWING THAT THERE ARE BUDGETING THINGS AND WHAT HAVE YOU GOING ON.
AND THEN, UH, WE WOULD MEET QUARTERLY AS A, AS THE GROUP AND THEN, AND THEN GO ON.
UM, THAT WOULD BE IN THE NEXT YEAR OR SO.
UH, IN 27 AND 28, WE WOULD, WE WOULD TAKE THIS ONE STEP FURTHER AND START DRILLING DOWN INTO,
[01:50:01]
OKAY, HOW DO WE GET THIS SUSTAINED CAPACITY TO WORK ON THE TRAILS? HOW DO WE, UM, SO IT'S NOT THAT CYCLICAL.UH, AND, AND THIS IS ALL OF COURSE WORKING WITH THE FOREST SERVICE 'CAUSE IT'S, IT'S THEIR BUSINESS, BUT HOW DO WE HELP THEM? UM, ALEX IS TIRED OF HEARING ME WALK INTO HIS OFFICE OR CALL HIM AND SAY, ALEX, HOW CAN WE HELP GET MORE WORK DONE? AND SO IT WOULD BE REALLY NICE IF WE COULD FIGURE THAT OUT TOGETHER.
AND A MODEL, JUST LIKE TRACY SHOWED YOU, THEY'RE OUT THERE AND WE HAVE SMART PEOPLE IN THIS ROOM.
WE HAVE VERY GENEROUS PEOPLE IN THIS COMMUNITY.
I THINK WE CAN FIGURE THIS OUT TO BE HONEST WITH YOU.
AND SO THAT, THAT NEXT COUPLE OF YEARS, UM, UH, IT'S, IT'S BASICALLY HOW DO WE TAKE IT FURTHER AND THEN GOING OUT, UM, IT'S CALLED DELIVER REGIONALLY.
WE ALSO KNOW THAT ALEX AND THE OTHER GREEN UNIFORM FOR FOLKS IN THE BACK HAVE HAVE AN ISSUE HERE IN THE VERDE VALLEY IN THAT THERE ARE OTHER PARTS BESIDES SEDONA.
I'M GOING TO SEDONA, BUT IT'S THE VERDE VALLEY, IT'S RIM ROCK, IT'S, IT'S WHAT HAVE YOU.
WE DON'T KNOW WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE IN FOUR OR FIVE YEARS, BUT IF WE CAN BE SUCCESSFUL WITH WHAT WE'RE DOING NOW, I BELIEVE WE CAN TAKE THAT FORWARD AND, AND, UM, LET SOME OTHERS SEE IT.
NOW I, UH, TALK ABOUT THE PROJECTS.
UM, WE HAVE FOUR CATEGORIES AND THE FIRST WOULD BE A BEAR DOUGH TRAILHEAD EXPANSION.
UM, ALEX TALKED A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THIS, BUT WE DID THE WORK ON, ON DOUGH.
AND JUST TO PUT THIS IN PERSPECTIVE, UH, THE DOUGH APPROACH TOOK $200,000 OVER, OVER A COUPLE YEARS AND COUNTLESS HOURS FROM OUR FRIENDS OF FOREST FOLKS UP TOP MAKING THAT FIGURE EIGHT.
SO, UH, IT'S A BIG INVESTMENT.
CATHEDRAL ROCK, WHEN IT WAS REDONE WAS $543,000, GIVE OR TAKE.
THOSE ARE THE CHECKS WE WROTE.
THAT'S NOT WHAT THE FOREST SERVICE DID.
UM, TURKEY CREEK, THE UH, TRAIL FUND WILL END UP RIDING THREE QUARTERS OF A MILLION DOLLARS AND THAT DOESN'T COUNT THE TRAILHEAD, WHICH WILL BE ANOTHER THREE OR $400,000.
AND SO, SO, SO ALL THESE PROJECTS, THEY'RE THINK NOW IN THAT 200,000 THAT WE ASKED THE CITY TO SUPPORT, WE'RE NOT ASKING YOU TO DO THE WHOLE PROJECT OR BE RESPONSIBLE FOR IT.
WE WOULD SHARE THAT WITH YOU SOMEHOW.
WE WOULD FIGURE OUT HOW TO MAKE THIS A COMMUNITY EFFORT AND WHAT HAVE YOU.
SO, UH, THE FIRST WOULD BE AN ACCESS.
TRACY TALKED ABOUT ALL THE BACKLOG.
UM, AND THAT SORT OF COMES IN WITH AND WITH CAPACITY IS HOW DO YOU GET THAT WORK DONE? UM, ALEX TALKED ABOUT THE CENTENNIAL TRAIL.
YOU KNOW, THERE ARE A-D-A-D-A REQUIREMENTS THAT'S AN ACCESS.
HOW DO WE WORK THAT INTO IT AND, AND AND, UH, UH, FIX THAT UP THE, UH, FUNDING, THE ADDITIONAL MAINTENANCE CAPACITY.
UM, ONE THING WE'VE ALSO ASKED IS, OKAY, FOREST SERVICE, IS THERE A POSSIBILITY THAT WE HAVE A SEPARATE TRAIL CREW, JUST LIKE TRACY TALKED ABOUT SOME OF SOME OF THE OTHER CITIES, UM, AND, AND IT'S FUNDED BY US, BUT UNDER THEIR CONTROL, YOU KNOW, HOW DO YOU CHANGE THAT ONE TO A TWO AND HOW DO YOU CHANGE THAT 13 TO A 25 AND OR, OR SOME OTHER NUMBER.
AND, AND INSTEAD OF BEING SEASONAL, IS THERE SOME MODEL THAT YOU COULD DO IT YEAR ROUND WHERE THERE IS WORK DONE IN THE SUMMER ALSO? RIGHT NOW WORK IS ONLY DONE PRETTY MUCH LATE OCTOBER, EARLY NOVEMBER THROUGH APRIL OR THE BEGINNING OF MAY BECAUSE OF A, THE WEATHER AND B, THE TRAILS NEED MOISTURE AND TO MOVE THINGS AROUND AND WHAT HAVE YOU.
SO, SO, UH, UM, THAT AND THEN THE EXPERIENCES IS, UM, BASICALLY IS THERE A TRAIL OR IS THERE A, UH, CONNECTOR WE COULD PUT IN THAT COULD SORT OF HELP TIE THINGS TOGETHER WHERE PEOPLE CAN GO FROM ONE EXPERIENCE TO ANOTHER WITHOUT HAVING TO HOP ON A SHUTTLE OR WALK, WALK AROUND, WALK OR WHAT HAVE YOU.
SO WE WOULD LIKE TO START THIS.
OH, UM, ONE THING BACK ON, UM, UH, THERE WAS ANOTHER INTERESTING PROJECT, AND I KNOW SEVERAL OF THE COUNSELORS WERE INVOLVED.
ANNETTE WAS KIND AND CALLED THE FOLKS IN TAHOE.
BUT, UM, THE FUNDING OF ALL THIS IS INTERESTING.
UH, TAHOE HAS A PROJECT CALLED
[01:55:01]
TAHOE TROUT.AND YOU CAN GO AND BUY A TROUT.
IT'S A METAL TROUT AND YOU CAN HAVE ENGRAVED ON IT.
ANYTHING THAT'S REASONABLE, I THINK, AND THEY HAVE, AND THAT'S BEAUTIES IN THE EYE, THE BEHOLDER I GUESS.
BUT, BUT UM, THEN THAT TROUT, DEPENDING UPON HOW MUCH YOU GAVE THE SIZE OF THAT TROUT CHANGES AND WHERE THAT TROUT GOES AND ALL THAT MONEY GOES INTO A FUND JUST FOR THE MAINTENANCE OF THE TAHOE TRAILS.
AND WE HAVE, UH, UM, UH, ANNETTE WAS KIND AND CALLED THE TAHOE FOLKS, I BELIEVE, AND TALKED TO 'EM, TO 'EM ABOUT IT.
UM, MELISSA AND I HAVE TALKED AND, UH, HER AND I MAY START WORKING ON SOMETHING THAT THERE MAY BE AN ART AND TRAIL TIE IN WHERE WE COULD GET THIS, THIS MELISSA, THIS MELISSA, YES.
SO MAL, SO, SO, UH, UM, UH, UH, THINK ABOUT THAT.
SO WE'D LIKE TO START THIS TRANSITION, THIS, THIS TRAIL SYSTEM, GET IT, GET IT UP AND GOING, UM, START, START THE PLANNING PROCESS AND UM, BASICALLY SUSTAIN WHAT THE CITY IS GIVING US AND THINK ABOUT ANOTHER BIG CHUNK GOING IN WHERE WE CAN, WHERE WE CAN DO SOMETHING.
YOU KNOW? AND AT THE END OF THE DAY, TO ME, THIS IS A COMMUNITY BENEFIT.
IT'S, IT'S, UH, IT'S ONE PLAN.
UH, I THINK THAT THE STABLE, STABLE CAPACITY IS, IS, IS GO AHEAD.
SO, UH, CAN, CAN I INTERRUPT JUST ONE SEC? THAT'S OKAY.
UM, SO ON YOUR SLIDE ABOUT SELECT ONE PROJECT BY SHARED CRITERIA, ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT SELECT ONE PROJECT FROM EACH OF THESE CATEGORIES OR SELECT ONE PROJECT ACROSS THE CATEGORIES, JUST TO BE CLEAR, SELECT ONE ACROSS JUST TO GET THE PROCESS GOING.
AND MY ADVICE WOULD BE TO PICK ONE THAT IS MANAGEABLE THAT WE COULD COMPLETE IN A SEASON AND SEE HOW WE ALL PLAY IN THE SANDBOX TOGETHER AS WE'RE GOING FORWARD.
AND, AND I THINK THAT THAT WOULD GIVE, GIVE PEOPLE SOME CONFIDENCE THAT, HEY, THIS ACCESS GROUP WORKS, THEY CAN WORK TOGETHER, THEY CAN GET SOMETHING CHANGED.
SO YOU TALKED ABOUT TIMING, DICK, AND YOUR TIMING IS REALLY GOOD IN THAT WE'RE GOING INTO OUR RETREAT IN A FEW WEEKS WHERE WE'LL BE DISCUSSING OUR PRIORITIES, BUT YOUR TIMING MIGHT NOT BE SO GOOD WHEN MONEY WOULD BE AVAILABLE, WHICH WOULDN'T BE TILL JULY 1ST.
SO WHEN YOU SAY SEASON, I'M NOT SURE WHAT SEASON YOU'RE REFERRING TO.
UH, UH, WE UNDERSTAND THAT OUR TIMING IS OFF.
WE'VE, WE'VE BEEN BAD ON OUR LICENSE PLATE THING TOO, BUT WE GOT, WE GOT THAT FIXED UP.
BUT, UM, UH, THIS, WE WEREN'T EXPECTING Y'ALL TO GIVE US 200,000 THIS EVENING.
WE WANTED TO PLANT THE SEED THAT GOING FORWARD IN THE NEXT CYCLE.
AND TO BE HONEST WITH YOU, IT, IT WOULD PROBABLY BE NEXT FALL UNTIL WE WOULD START A PROJECT ANYWAY.
AND SO ALL THIS WOULD WORK AND IT GIVES US TIME TO FIND A PROJECT, BRING IT FORWARD TO Y'ALL AND SEE, SEE IF IT'S THE RIGHT THING TO DO.
SO I JUST WANNA POINT OUT ALONG THE, THE IDEAS OF BUDGET THAT DEPENDING ON THE PLAN THAT YOU PICK, 200,000 MAY OR MAY NOT BE THE RIGHT NUMBER.
AND SO I DON'T WANT ANYONE TO GET IN THEIR HEAD THAT THAT'S THE NUMBER.
UM, BECAUSE IF YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT SHUTTLES, DO WE HAVE ENOUGH SHUTTLES? THERE'S A WHOLE CONVERSATION THAT HAS TO HAPPEN WITH GUILLERMO BACK THERE AROUND WHETHER OR NOT WE HAVE CAPACITY OR, YOU KNOW, AND ALL THAT COSTS MONEY AND YOU HAVE TO GET THE SHUTTLES.
SO DEPENDING ON THE PROJECT THAT GETS PICKED, THIS COULD BE VERY COMPLICATED.
SO I JUST WANNA MAKE SURE THAT EVERYONE'S AWARE.
IT'S NOT LIKE YOU'RE GONNA COME IN AND SAY, WE WANT A DECISION PACKAGE FOR WHATEVER.
IT'S GONNA DEPEND ON WHAT YOU CHOOSE AND HOW MUCH WORK NEEDS TO GO.
AND THAT'S GONNA SLOW DOWN THE PROCESS OF FINDING OUT WHAT THAT NUMBER MIGHT ACTUALLY BE.
BUT WE'LL TAKE 400,000 IF YOU WANT TO GIVE IT US
SO, UM, WE THOUGHT VERY, VERY CAREFULLY ABOUT HOW TO TITLE THIS LAST SLIDE AND, AND IT IS WHY THIS WILL SUCCEED.
AND, UM, WE ARE, WE ARE, WE ARE TRULY NOT STARTING FROM SCRATCH HERE.
WE HAVE THESE THREE NONPROFITS, WE HAVE ALEX'S GROUP, WE HAVE CITIZENS WHO HAVE COUNTLESS HOURS OF VOL, VOLUNTEER TIME.
WE ALL SHARE A LOVE OF THESE TRAILS AND WE WANT THEM, WANT THEM TO SUCCEED.
AND IF YOU LOOK AT THE SEVENTH ITEM ON THE CITY OF SEDONA MISSION STATEMENT, AND IF YOU LOOK AT THE SECOND ITEM OF ALEX'S COCONINO FOREST IMPERATIVES FOR THIS YEAR, IT'S THE SAME THING.
IT'S WHAT WE ALL GET UP EVERY MORNING TO WORK ON FOR YOU.
[02:00:01]
I, I, I REALLY FROM MY HEART, I WANT TO THANK Y'ALL FOR LISTENING.I KNOW IT WAS A LONG SET OF PRESENTATIONS, BUT IT'S SOMETHING THAT, UM, THAT I HAVE TO GIVE, UH, TRACY THE CREDIT FOR REALLY GETTING US GOING ON THIS AND THE CONVERSATIONS.
BUT WE WOULD JUST REALLY LIKE THE CITY INVOLVED.
WE THINK IT'S VERY, VERY IMPORTANT.
SO DICK OR ANY OF THE THREE OF YOU, UM, THE, THE GSRC IS ALREADY A CONVENING GROUP OF A LOT OF STAKEHOLDERS.
CAN YOU TALK ABOUT HOW, YOU KNOW, THIS GROUP, UH, FORMING THAT THE CITY MIGHT PARTICIPATE IN, HOW DOES THAT OPERATE RELATIVE TO GSRC? IS THIS A MORE EFFICIENT WAY OF GETTING SOME THINGS DONE? CAN YOU JUST KIND OF PROVIDE SOME COMPARATIVE BASIS THERE SINCE I SIT ON THE GSRC REPRESENTING FRIENDS OF THE FOREST? I'LL TRY TO ANSWER THAT.
UM, GS C'S FOCUS RIGHT NOW IS STILL OHVS AND I SEE THAT NOT CHANGING THROUGH THIS FI GOVERNMENT FISCAL YEAR, THE FOURTH SERVICES GOVERNMENT FISCAL YEAR THROUGH SEPTEMBER.
UM, I THINK THAT IN THEORY, THE IDEA OF THE GSRC IS PHENOMENAL.
IT'S GOT TOO MANY PEOPLE IN IT AND IT GETS A LITTLE BIT SCOPE CREEP I THINK HAS HAPPENED.
AND I THINK THAT WAS ONE OF OUR FEARS.
WE DID TALK ABOUT THAT IN OUR GROUP IS THE 12 OF US WE'RE MEETING OF HOW WE HANDLE THAT.
IT CERTAINLY COULD BE SOMETHING THAT COULD BE TURNED OVER TO THE GSRC WHEN THEY HAVE A FOCUS CHANGE, BUT THAT DOESN'T SEEM TO BE BE ANYWHERE IN THE NEAR FUTURE.
AND WE DON'T WANNA WAIT A YEAR AND DO ABSOLUTELY NOTHING UNTIL THAT POINT.
I ALSO THINK THAT THERE'S TOO MANY HANDS IN THAT PIE.
UM, FOR THE REASONS FOR OHV, IT'S A DIFFERENT TYPE OF COMPLICATED ISSUE THAN NECESSARILY THIS IS.
SO WHILE IT MAY NOT STAY AT A SMALL SIX TO EIGHT GROUP PEOPLE ALL THE TIME, THAT IS ACTUALLY WHY WE PICKED A SMALL NUMBER IS TO BE A LITTLE BIT MORE PRODUCTIVE.
ALEX, DO YOU WANNA, DID I MISS ANYTHING FOR GSRC? OKAY, THANK YOU.
I'M GONNA OPEN THE PUBLIC FORUM AND IT'S KURT COMER IS ANYBODY ELSE WANT WISHES TO SPEAK ON THIS SUBJECT? PLEASE FILL OUT A CARD AND YOU CAN HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO WEIGH IN.
SO, KURT'S, THREE MINUTES, YOU KNOW THE DRILL NAME AND CITY OF RESIDENCE.
UH, MY NAME'S KURT ER, I'M A LOCAL PHYSICIAN AND FOR 18 YEARS I'VE ALSO BEEN A MEMBER OF THE SEDONA WESTERNERS HIKING CLUB.
AND IT WAS THROUGH THAT CLUB THAT I'VE REALLY LEARNED ABOUT PROTECTION AND PRESERVATION OF OUR TRAIL SYSTEM.
AND IN 2013, A SMALL GROUP OF LOCALS, INCLUDING LAUREN BROWN AND I CREATED THE SEDONA RED ROCK TRAIL FUND.
AND THEN I REALLY GOT INVOLVED.
AND SO AS I'VE, AS I'VE LISTENED TO EVERYTHING HERE TONIGHT, I'M STRUCK WITH HOW OUTSTANDING OUR RED ROCK RANGER DISTRICT IS, HOW EXTRAORDINARY OUR TRAILS IS, AND HOW ABSOLUTELY EXTRAORDINARY OUR VOLUNTEER COMMUNITY HAS BEEN IN ALL OF THIS.
BUT BASED ON EVERYTHING WE HEARD TONIGHT AND ALL THE STRESSES, INCLUDING LINGERING FIRE RISKS AND DANGER AND TRAIL TRAIL DAMAGE, I'M GONNA RECOMMEND THAT WE STOP ANY FURTHER NEW TRAIL CONSTRUCTION IN AN OVERSTRESSED SYSTEM THAT WE HAVE.
I DON'T THINK IT'S CORRECT TO GO AHEAD AND BUILD NEW TRAILS.
WHEN WE STARTED THE TRAIL FUND BACK IN 2013, THE SYSTEM HAD ABOUT 230 MILES OF TRAIL.
AND AS A TRAIL USER, I CAN'T SEE THAT IT'S MADE MUCH OF A DIFFERENCE.
WE STILL HAVE OVERUSED AND OVERSTRESSED POPULAR TRAILS AND A LOT OF THE NEW TRAILS, ESPECIALLY THINGS LIKE THE WESTERN GATEWAY, WHICH WAS VERY INVOLVED AND EXPENSIVE, SEEM UNDERUSED TO ME.
I'M NOT SURE THAT BUILDING MORE NEW TRAILS AT THIS POINT IS GONNA MAKE ANY DIFFERENCE IN TERMS OF ALL THE STRESSES THAT WE'VE HEARD ABOUT TONIGHT.
I'M ALSO CONCERNED BECAUSE I THINK SOME OF THE NEW TRAILS THAT I'VE SEEN PUT IN EFFECT OVER THE LAST COUPLE OF YEARS HAVE STARTED LIFE AS ILLEGAL TRAILS BUILT BY ILLEGAL TRAIL BUILDERS AND THEN FOLDED INTO THE STANDARD SYSTEM-WIDE TRAILS.
AND I DON'T THINK THAT'S RIGHT.
I THINK IT, I THINK IT DIMINISHES OUR FOREST SERVICE ROLE AS THE RESPONSIBLE
[02:05:01]
PARTY.I THINK IT, IT ALSO DAMAGES THEIR, THEIR REPUTATION AS BEING STEWARDS OF THE TRAILS.
SO AGAIN, I THINK BECAUSE WE'VE HAD SO MANY DIFFERENT STRESSES ON THIS COMMUNITY AND ITS TRAILS AND BECAUSE EVERYTHING WE'VE HEARD TONIGHT TALKED ABOUT EVERY ONE OF THESE PARTICULAR STRESSES AND HOW WE'RE WORKING SO HARD TO REINVENT ALL OF THIS SO THAT WE CAN CREATE NEW TRAILS THAT POSSIBLY VISITORS WILL USE, BUT POSSIBLY THEY WON'T.
I THINK WE OUGHT TO JUST STEP BACK AND CONSIDER LEAVING THE SYSTEM AS IT IS RIGHT NOW.
ANYBODY ELSE WANNA SPEAK? GOING ONCE, GOING TWICE MARS.
COUNCIL MAYOR, VICE MAYOR, EVERYBODY.
GREAT PRESENTATION FOR EVERYONE HERE TODAY.
I JUST WANT TO GET UP AND SAY A COUPLE THINGS.
UM, I LIVE IN THE CHAPEL AREA OF SEDONA AND HAVE RECORD IN THIS LAND MY ENTIRE LIFE.
TRAILS ARE THE THREAD OF THE FABRIC THAT HOLDS US ALL TOGETHER.
I THINK THAT WHATEVER WALK WE COME FROM, WHETHER WE'RE CYCLISTS A HIKER, AN ARTIST, WE ALL USE THE TRAILS IN SOME MANNER.
AND THE AMOUNT OF WORK THAT WENT INTO THIS AND THE WAY THIS WILL BENEFIT THE COMMUNITY IS IMMENSE.
SO I JUST WANNA MAKE SURE EVERYBODY SEES THAT WHERE THIS IS GOING.
AND TO KIND OF TOUCH ON WHAT KURT'S COMMENTS WERE ON THIS, THE CURRENT CONVERSATION, I THINK AND PLANNING ON THE RED ROCK IS THAT WE ARE APPROACHING THAT LIMIT OF TRAILS AND, BUT THERE IS ALSO A BIG NEED TO REALLY COORDINATE AND GET THESE TRAILS FIGURED OUT TO WHERE THEY'RE VERY CALCULATED IN THE CONNECTIONS THAT ARE THERE AND VERY WELL MAINTAINED.
SO WE'RE NOT LOSING SOILS, WE'RE NOT HAVING THE SAME IMPACTS THAT ARE THERE.
SO I DON'T THINK THAT WE'RE DONE.
I THINK WE NEED TO GET TO THE REFINEMENT PIECE OF IT AND REALLY MAKE SURE THAT IT WORKS FOR EVERYONE WITH THE CONNECTIONS TO THE NEIGHBORHOODS, THE CONNECTIONS TO DIFFERENT TRAIL HEADS, SHUTTLES, GET THE RIGHT PLACES.
THIS STUFF NEEDS TO BE REALLY FIGURED OUT.
AND THE COORDINATION FROM THE CITY, THE COUNTIES, EVERYONE HAS TO BE REALLY WELL THOUGHT OUT.
SO I DON'T THINK WE NEED TO STOP.
I THINK WE NEED TO BE CALCULATED AND GET THIS GROUP THAT GETS EVERYBODY IN THE SAME ROOM AND ELIMINATES THE SILOS AND GETS US TO WHERE WE CAN MOVE FORWARD IN A VERY SUCCESSFUL WAY.
I'M CLOSING THE PUBLIC FORUM NOW.
COUNSEL, HAVE ANY COMMENTS? THIS IS FOR DIRECTION ONLY, KATHY.
I HAVE FOUR KIND OF AREAS OF QUESTIONS.
UM, THE FIRST IS REGARDING OUR MULTIMODAL COORDINATOR.
AND I GUESS ANNETTE, I'M GONNA DIRECT THIS TO YOU, IS TO KNOW WHAT CAPACITY IS THERE FOR TAKING ON SOMETHING LIKE PARTICIPATING IN ANOTHER ORGANIZATION.
UM, AND IN TERMS OF HOW THAT FITS INTO THE CURRENT SCOPE OF WORK, UH, COULD YOU JUST GIVE US SOME BACKGROUND ON THAT, PLEASE? SOME INFORMATION? WELL, AS YOU KNOW, THE TRAILS COORDINATOR POSITION WAS CREATED IN THE CURRENT BUDGET STARTING IN JULY AND WENT TO FULL TIME.
AND SO I THINK I WOULD HAVE TO DEFER TO, YOU KNOW, HIS DIRECT SUPERVISOR.
BUT IF THE COUNCIL DECIDES AS A POLICY MATTER THAT YOU WANT, UM, THE CITY AT THE TABLE FOR ANY OF THESE THINGS, THEN IT'S ON US TO LOOK AT THE STAFF ASSIGNMENTS AND WORKLOADS AND PRIORITIES AND THINGS LIKE THAT.
UM, SECOND QUESTION IS A LEGAL QUESTION.
UH, SO MONIQUE, REGARDING PERMITTING CITY INVESTMENT BEYOND CITY LIMITS IN TERMS OF THE SHUTTLES, UH, EXPANSION, THE HEADS UPKEEP, UM, SUVS OUTSIDE OF CITY LIMITS.
AND UH, CAN YOU COMMENT ON THAT IN TERMS OF WHERE OUR HANDS MIGHT BE TIED OR UNTIED? SURE.
I THINK THAT THERE'S A LITTLE BIT OF, UH, ROOM THERE CONSISTENT WITH THE LAWS AS LONG AS THE, THE FUNDS ARE FOR A PUBLIC PURPOSE THAT BENEFITS THE CITY.
UM, SO I THINK THAT, UH, THE NEXUS CAN BE MADE WITHIN A CERTAIN, UH, YOU KNOW, LIMITED, UH, AREA AROUND THE, THE CITY.
UH, BUT IT'S ON A CASE BY CASE BASIS THAT COUNCIL WOULD NEED TO EVALUATE WHEN A PROPOSAL IS BROUGHT FORWARD.
AND IF I MAY, UH, COUNCILOR KINSELLA, UM, WE DO HAVE SPECIFIC EXAMPLES WHERE WE HAVE DONE THIS WITH COUNCIL SUPPORT, THE BROKEN ARROW TRAILHEAD PROJECT THAT WE'RE PARTNERING ON WITH THE FOREST SERVICE AND WE'RE THE PROJECT MANAGER, THE GRANT RECIPIENT, THAT ACTUALLY MOST OF THAT TRAILHEAD
[02:10:01]
IS NOT IN THE CITY LIMITS.UM, WE HAVE SHUTTLE SERVICES, RIGHT, THAT GO OUT BOYNTON CANYON.
WE DO A LOT OF THINGS THAT ARE OF BENEFIT TO THE BROADER SEDONA COMMUNITY.
AND ALONG THOSE LINES, OUR STAFF DOES PARTICIPATE IN REGIONAL COLLABORATIONS ON THINGS OUTSIDE THE CITY LIMITS ALL THE TIME.
THERE IS NO RESTRICTION OR POLICY THAT SAYS THEY'RE NOT ALLOWED TO WORK ON A VERDE VALLEY REGIONAL PLAN OR ANY, YOU KNOW, ANYTHING LIKE THAT.
SO, YOU KNOW, THAT ALREADY EXISTS THAT STAFF PARTICIPATE IN REGIONAL EFFORTS ON A NUMBER OF TOPICS.
I WANTED TO JUST GET THAT CLARIFIED WITHIN THIS CONTEXT TO HELP FRAME CONVERSATION AS WE GO FORWARD.
UM, THIRD QUESTION IS FOR OUR PRESENTERS, WHICH YOU MAKE REFERENCE IN YOUR SLIDE, IT'S YOURS I THINK SLIDE 12.
UM, IF YOU GO BACK JUST A COUPLE, I THINK, UH, UNDER EXPERIENCE YOU HAVE THE ACCESS EXPANSION AND YOU HAVE AN EXAMPLE THERE OF THE BREWER TRAIL UPGRADE.
AND COULD YOU GIVE ME MORE INFORMATION ON THE BREWER TRAIL UPGRADE BECAUSE THAT'S, YEAH.
MY, MY UNDERSTANDING IS THAT THE SHARED USE PATH IS BEING PLANNED TO BE EXPANDED ALONG BREWER.
AND SO THE CONCEPT HERE WAS THE BREWER TRAIL IS ACTUALLY A VERY BELOVED MOUNTAIN BIKING TRAIL.
AND THAT THAT TRAIL IS GONNA SEE MORE HIKING TRAFFIC WITH A SHARED USE PATH COMING ALONG IT.
AND SO LET'S PROACTIVELY ADDRESS THAT AND FIGURE OUT HOW WE CAN, UM, MANAGE THAT TRAIL AND MAINTAIN THAT TRAIL.
NO, KEEPING IT SO IT CAN REMAIN A BELOVED BIKING TRAIL, BUT ALSO, UM, ACCOMMODATE ADDITIONAL HIKERS COMING ONTO IT.
SO IT WOULD BE A UBER MAINTENANCE PROJECT THAT SEEMED TO FIT WITH SOMETHING THE CITY IS SEEDING AND COULD ADDRESS A FUTURE CONFLICT SOONER.
AND YOU HAVE SPECIFIC IDEAS ALREADY, 'CAUSE YOU SAID FIGURE IT OUT BEFORE, BUT I JUST WANNA KNOW IS ARE THERE MORE SPECIFICS IN ORDER TO ACCOMPLISH THAT? YEAH, WE WOULD WORK WITH THE FOREST SERVICE, I THINK POTENTIALLY BRING IN A CONTRACTOR AS WELL.
I MEAN, I'M SAYING THINGS OUT LOUD HERE WITH KEVIN, BUT I THINK WE WERE LARGELY FOCUSING ON PROJECTS THAT WOULDN'T REQUIRE NEPA AND SO WOULD EXTEND THE, THE TIMEFRAME.
SO THIS IS JUST A SOUPED UP MAINTENANCE PROJECT, MUCH LIKE DOE MOUNTAIN WAS FOR HIKERS, THINK OF THIS AS KIND OF A HIKING, BIKING IMPROVEMENT FOR, UM, AND IT FITS NICELY WITH THE CITY, WITH WHAT THE CITY ALREADY HAS ENVISIONED.
KATHY, I, IF I COULD ADD THINK SOMETHING PLEASE.
UM, FOR DO, AND TRACY REFERENCED IT, WE ACTUALLY BROUGHT IN AN OUTSIDE CONTRACTOR SOMETHING TO SEE AND SAID, WHAT WOULD YOU DO WITH THIS? AND THAT'S HOW THAT PROJECT GOT DESIGNED AND COMPLETED.
AND THE NEXT STEP IS, STEP OF THAT IS WE'RE HOPING TO DO A SIMILAR THING ON BEAR MOUNTAIN.
AND SO WE HAVE A MODEL MM-HMM
THAT WORKS HERE, THAT THEY WORK VERY CLOSELY WITH THE FOREST SERVICE.
IN FACT, THE FOREST SERVICE APPROVES EVERYTHING AT THE END OF THE DAY, BUT, BUT THEY THINK ALIKE AND THEY KNOW WHAT HAS TO BE DONE, DONE, AND DONE.
AND SO WE HAVE THE RESOURCES THAT CAN DO THAT.
AND THE FOURTH, UH, QUESTION I HAVE, THESE ARE ALL NOT RELATED, BUT IT HAS TO DO WITH THE TAHOE TROUT SALES, WHICH I JUST ASKED OUR CITY MANAGER FOR AN UPDATE ON THAT, UH, YESTERDAY WHEN WE MET BECAUSE, UH, MY UNDERSTANDING WAS THAT THERE WAS SOME QUESTION MAYBE ABOUT LOCATION OF WHERE SOMETHING LIKE THAT AND ACTUALLY THE ABILITY STILL GOING FORWARD, THE LEGALITY OF, OF, OF, OF THAT.
SO IF YOU COULD TELL ME, TELL US WHAT YOU TOLD ME YESTERDAY, MAYBE EXPANDED.
THANK YOU FOR THE QUESTION, COUNSELOR KINSELLA.
UM, SO AS MENTIONED, THE PROGRAM IS MODELED AFTER THE TAHOE TRAIL FUND, I THINK IT'S CALLED.
AND WE RECEIVED A COPY OF THE CONTRACT BETWEEN THE COUNTY AND THAT NONPROFIT AND HOW THEY HAD STRUCTURED THAT, UM, PROGRAM.
AND WE'VE ALL SHARED IT AND REVIEWED IT.
AND REALLY WHAT IT COMES DOWN TO IS THE COUNTY, I THINK IT'S PLACER COUNTY, UM, DESIGNATED SPECIFIC AREAS WHERE THESE, UM, PLAQUES COULD BE ATTACHED AND THE MAINTENANCE RESPONSIBILITIES, LIABILITIES, ALL OF THAT ON TO THE NONPROFIT TO TAKE CARE OF THOSE ATTACHMENTS TO THEIR PUBLIC PROPERTY.
AND THEN I BELIEVE THEY HAD A, OR STILL HAVE A JOINT, UM, GROUP THAT IS THE COUNTY AND
[02:15:01]
THE NONPROFIT THAT THEY REGULARLY REVIEW THE FUNDS RECEIVED WHAT IT'S BEING SPENT ON AND THAT TYPE OF THING.SO THAT'S NOT JUST A PASSIVE, UM, TYPE OF ACTIVITY.
LIKE THEY'RE ACTIVELY INVOLVED IN THAT.
AND SO, FROM OUR PERSPECTIVE, THE KEY TO THIS PROPOSAL IS FINDING THE APPROPRIATE LOCATION.
WHAT'S GONNA BE THE SIZE OF THESE AND HOW DOES THAT FIT INTO THE CITY'S OVERALL PLANNING FOR PUBLIC ART WALKWAYS AND, UM, THAT PEDESTRIAN EXPERIENCE.
AND SO WE DON'T HAVE AN IDENTIFIED LOCATION YET TO BRING BACK TO COUNCIL FOR HOW THIS MIGHT WORK.
AND DIFFERENT FROM CALIFORNIA, THOUGH WE KNOW WE HAVE A GIFT CLAUSE, YOU KNOW, IN ARIZONA.
SO WE DO HAVE TO WORK THROUGH THE ISSUES OF LIKE, HOW WOULD WE GIVE PUBLIC PROPERTY TO A PRIVATE ENTITY TO USE FOR FUNDRAISING PURPOSES.
BECAUSE TYPICALLY IF SOMEONE COMES TO US AND SAYS, WE WANNA DO A FUNDRAISER AT YOUR, UM, RIDE SHARE PARKING LOT BY THE HIGH SCHOOL, 'CAUSE THAT DOES HAPPEN, WE DO HAVE PEOPLE COME TO US AND WANNA SET UP A BOOTH AND SELL THINGS AS FUNDRAISERS TO THE PEOPLE GETTING ON THE TRAIL.
HEDGE SHUTTLES, WE TYPICALLY SAY NO, BECAUSE THAT'S NOT APPROPRIATE, YOU KNOW, ACTIVITY, COMMERCIAL ACTIVITY ON PUBLIC PROPERTY.
SO FOR THIS, WE HAVE TO WORK THROUGH A LOT OF THOSE ISSUES AROUND HOW WOULD THIS BE STRUCTURED.
UM, SO IT'S JUST NOT READY TO BRING FORWARD TO THE COUNCIL AS A FORMAL PROPOSAL WHO AT, WELL, TWO QUESTIONS.
UM, FIRST OF ALL, I, IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING THAT SOME OF THE PROPOSED LOCATIONS HAVE CONFLICT.
'CAUSE ONE PROPOSED LOCATION WAS ON US FOREST SERVICE AT THE TRAILHEAD, AND I BELIEVE THE FOREST SERVICE DOESN'T ALLOW IT.
AND THEN I THINK THAT THERE WERE SOME ASKS FOR AREAS THAT THE CITY, UM, ALREADY HAS PROJECTED ART AND INFORMATIONAL, UM, PLAQUES.
SO THIS TIES INTO THE SECOND PART OF THIS QUESTION.
SO WHO OWES WHO INFORMATION TO MOVE TO THE NEXT STEP IN TERMS OF IDENTIFYING LOCATIONS, AT LEAST FOR THE ASK SO THAT THEY COULD BE CONSIDERED, I CAN COVER THIS.
SO I HAD A MEETING WITH ANDY AND I THINK, WHAT IS YOUR SIGNAGE GROUP? UM, FROM THAT, A LOT OF CONVER, A LOT OF QUESTIONS HAPPENED AND QUITE FRANKLY, THIS MEETING THEN CAME UP MM-HMM
UM, SO I PERSONALLY PUT LESS, UM, PUSHING ON ANDY, LIKE WHERE DID, WHERE DO I GO NEXT WITH THE, WHICH I'M SURE ANDY APPRECIATES WHERE DO I GO NEXT WITH THIS? BECAUSE I WAS LIKE, LET'S JUST PUT THIS IN THIS PRESENTATION WHERE WE'RE COMING FORWARD TO THE CITY WITH JUST KIND OF A COMPREHENSIVE COMMUNICATION ABOUT THE TRAILS AND WE CAN BRING THIS UP.
AND AND SINCE THEN DICK AND AND HER HAVE DISCUSSED MAYBE THERE CAN BE A COLLABORATION WITH THE ART.
AND COUNSELOR ALSO, I JUST WANNA MENTION THAT, YOU KNOW, THE FULL COUNCIL HASN'T HAD AN OPPORTUNITY TO DISCUSS THE POLICY ISSUE AROUND THIS, WHICH IS IF YOU'RE GOING TO ALLOW COMMERCIAL FUNDRAISING ACTIVITY FOR ONE NONPROFIT ON CITY PROPERTY, WHAT'S GONNA BE THAT CRITERIA WHEN THE NEXT ONE COMES AND ASKS TO DO THE SAME THING? SO THERE'S SOME WORK TO BE DONE TO CREATE, YOU KNOW, THE CORRECT FRAMEWORK FOR YOU TO BE ABLE TO EVALUATE.
AND THAT'S ALL BEING COMMUNICATED BACK TO YOU GUYS, RIGHT? THAT WAS PART OF THE DISCUSSION EARLY ON.
FIRST OFF, UH, TO ALL THE GREEN SHIRTS OUT THERE, THANK YOU FOR WHAT YOU DO.
THANK YOU FOR LOVING THIS LAND LIKE YOU DO AND ALL THE WORK THAT GOES INTO IT AND HAVE, AND THEN THANK YOU TO OUR NONPROFITS AND OTHER VOLUNTEERS THAT, UH, ARE, UH, SUPPORTING THESE TRAILS.
AND, UH, YOU KNOW, THANK YOU TO THE THREE OF YOU FOR COLLABORATING LIKE THIS.
I'VE PERSONALLY FOUND THIS TO BE A COMPELLING PRESENTATION TONIGHT.
THE MOST COMPREHENSIVE VIEW AND INSIGHT THAT WE'VE GOTTEN INTO, YOU KNOW, REALLY NOT JUST THE STATE OF A TRAILS, 'CAUSE THAT, THAT GETS SHARED A LITTLE BIT HERE AND THERE, BUT YOU KNOW, THE PURE COMPARISONS AND SO FORTH, JUST INCREDIBLY VALUABLE.
SO, UH, THIS HAS BEEN, YOU KNOW, REALLY SUCCESSFUL I THINK HAVING YOU ALL COME TOGETHER.
AND THANK YOU FOR GOING THROUGH THE PAIN OF HAVING TO GET ALL ON THE SAME PAGE.
'CAUSE I KNOW IT WASN'T, YOU KNOW, A SLAM DUNK, UH, FROM THE VERY FIRST MOMENT.
AND YOU KNOW, I DO THINK THAT, YOU KNOW, YOU SHOULD BE HERE LIKE THIS ON AN ANNUAL BASIS, YOU KNOW, AND IT PROBABLY MAKES SENSE TO COMBINE IT WITH ALEX'S, UH, VISIT.
AND, UH, YOU KNOW, I WOULD CERTAINLY HOPE TO SEE YOU ALL TOGETHER AGAIN LIKE THIS.
UH, FROM A QUESTION STANDPOINT,
[02:20:01]
DICK, YOU JUST ALLUDED TO IT AND I HEARD YOU MENTIONED IT ON SATURDAY.ARE YOU OKAY WITH TALKING ABOUT THE LICENSE PLATES? BECAUSE I'M THINKING THAT MAYBE THERE'S A WAY WE CAN HELP YOU.
SO, UM, LARS ROMIG, IS HE? YEAH, LARS IS STILL HERE.
UH, WE'VE BEEN WANTING TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO GET A LICENSE PLATE, A SEDONA RED ROCK LICENSE PLATE, AND IT'S A, UH, IT'S AN INTERESTING PROCESS.
IT, IT'S, IT'S ACTUALLY A BILL IN THE, UH, LEGISLATURE.
SO IT HAS TO GO IN THROUGH ALL THE, ALL THE UM, UH, POLITICAL STUFF.
AND THEN THEY ARE ALL GATHERED UP IN ONE OMNIBUS BILL OR WHATEVER THEY CALL IT, AND THEY'RE ALL SIGNED IN AT THE SAME TIME.
AND SO WE MISSED LAST YEAR'S CYCLE BY ONE WEEK.
UH, WE ARE JUST NOW STARTING THE PROCESS OF GOING, GOING THROUGH OUR STATE, UH, LEGISLATURE.
SO, UH, WE'RE HOPING THAT BY THIS TIME NEXT YEAR WE HAVE A SEDONA RED ROCK TRAIL FUND OR A SEDONA RED ROCK, UH, LICENSE PLATE.
SO, AND I'M ASKING BECAUSE, YOU KNOW, OBVIOUSLY THE CITY CAN ALSO ADVOCATE AND YOU KNOW, THAT'S SOMETHING THAT WE CAN, YOU KNOW, CHOOSE TO PROVIDE DIRECTION THROUGH OUR LOBBYIST AND WE COULD ALSO INDIVIDUALLY REACH OUT TO OUR REPRESENTATIVES TO, UH, PUT IN A, A WORD OF SUPPORT FOR THAT.
SO IF YOU WANT TO CIRCLE BACK WITH US AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME, THEN, YOU KNOW, I KNOW AT LEAST FOR MYSELF, I'D LIKE TO BE ABLE TO HELP.
WE WOULD VERY MUCH APPRECIATE THAT.
AND I'LL BOLT YOUR LICENSE PLATES ON WHEN YOU GET 'EM TOO, IF WE GET
UM, SO ONE OF THE VERY FIRST THINGS YOU TALKED ABOUT, UH, THIS EVENING ON IN YOUR PRESENTATION WAS, YOU KNOW, GEE, WE NEED TO THINK ABOUT HOW USERS USE THE TRAILS WHEN IT COMES TO ACCESS AND CONNECTIVITY.
NOT JUST WHAT FEELS CONVENIENT FROM A TRANSIT STANDPOINT.
AND I LIKE THAT THINKING, RIGHT? IT'S, YOU KNOW, IT'S REALLY HOW, HOW CAN WE BE MORE CREATIVE TO MEET MORE NEEDS? WHAT I'D LIKE TO ASK YOU TO THINK ABOUT AS YOU PROCEED FURTHER DOWN THIS PATH IS, YOU KNOW, HOW DO YOU RESIDENTS, YOU KNOW, FIT INTO THIS? BECAUSE IT'S EASY TO SEE WHERE, UM, YOUR, YOUR POINT ABOUT, YOU KNOW, HOW TO USERS USE THE TRAILS FROM A TRANSIT STANDPOINT.
VISITORS BECOME THE OBVIOUS FIRST, YOU KNOW, POTENTIAL USER.
BUT HOW, WHAT ABOUT OUR RESIDENTS? YOU KNOW, WHAT CAN WE DO TO MAKE IT MORE COMPELLING FOR OUR RESIDENTS TO CHOOSE TO WANT TO USE A SHUTTLE TO, UH, YOU KNOW, DO A END-TO-END HIKE OR WHATEVER IT MIGHT BE THAT, THAT THEY REALLY CAN'T RIGHT NOW OR CHOOSE NOT TO? SO, UH, YOU KNOW, I'D LIKE TO ENCOURAGE YOU TO MAKE SURE THAT THE RESIDENT'S VOICE, UH, IS INCORPORATED, YOU KNOW, AS YOU MOVE FORWARD.
UM, UH, FOR ME PERSONALLY, I'D LIKE TO, WELL, YOUR, YOUR FIRST ASK YOUR, YOUR ONE SINGULAR ASK, REALLY FOR TONIGHT IS, IS CAN WE HAVE CITY REPRESENTATION IN THIS GROUP THAT YOU'RE FORMING? RIGHT? AND TO ME, I WOULD SAY TO MY COLLEAGUES, THIS IS WHY WE CREATED THE POSITION OF A FULL-TIME TRAILS COORDINATOR FOR JUST SUCH A MOMENT AS THIS.
SO I CERTAINLY WOULD LIKE TO ENCOURAGE MY COLLEAGUES TO, UH, PROVIDE DIRECTION TO STAFF TONIGHT THAT WE WOULD SUPPORT PARTICIPATION IN THIS GROUP.
WELL, I JUST GOT A NOTE THAT WE CAN'T PROVIDE DIRECTION 'CAUSE IT'S NOT AGENDAS FOR DIRECTION, JUST DISCUSSION.
BUT EVERYONE CAN HEAR WHAT WE HAVE TO SAY AND WE CAN AGENDIZE IT FOR A SUBSEQUENT MEETING IF WE NEED TO DO SO.
UM, I THINK THAT TAKES CARE OF MY COMMENTS AND QUESTIONS.
SO, YOU KNOW, BRAVO, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR PUTTING THIS COORDINATED PRESENTATION TOGETHER AND REALLY LOOK FORWARD TO WHERE YOU GO WITH IT FROM HERE.
FOR ALL THE PEOPLE WHO ARE LEAVING WHO ARE HERE FOR THIS, UM, ISSUE, THANK YOU FOR COMING.
AND FOR THOSE OF YOU WHO HAVE STUCK IT OUT, THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE.
THANK YOU FOR SWITCHING US ON THE AGENDA TOO.
I CAN GO HOME AND GO TO SLEEP.
SO,
AND I REALLY ENCOURAGE YOU TO KEEP LEVERAGING YOUR MUTUAL SUPPORT AND REACHING OUT TO THE CITY TO FURTHER MAKE AN IMPACT.
AND THEN I JUST HAD ONE LITTLE QUESTION BECAUSE I WAS THINKING THAT THE TAHOE TROUT WAS, WELL YOU REFERENCE IN HERE IN GRAVE ROCK.
AND I THOUGHT, WELL, MAYBE THAT'S THE SEDONA VERSION OF THE TAHOE CROWD.
[02:25:01]
THANKS.WE DIDN'T HAVE ANY TROUT
THAT'S RIGHT THERE WE HAVE GARTERS.
UH, I WANT TO SAY THANK YOU AND CONGRATULATIONS ON A REALLY GREAT JOB, BRIAN.
WELL, I KNOW THAT FOUR YEARS AGO I PLAYED A LITTLE ROLE IN SORT OF MOVING, GETTING SOME MOMENTUM BEHIND THIS ORGANIZATION OF DIFFERENT GROUPS.
UH, AND I HAVEN'T PARTICIPATED WITH YOU GUYS, UH, UM, ESPECIALLY IN THESE RECENT EFFORTS.
AND IT IS JUST, I'M SO PROUD TO SEE THE WORK THAT YOU'VE DONE AND THE SORT OF THE LEVEL THAT YOU'VE COME TOGETHER WITH.
IT'S, IT'S REALLY ASTOUNDING AND I'M SO HAPPY FOR OUR COMMUNITY THAT WE'RE DOING THIS.
IT'S ABSOLUTELY THE RIGHT DIRECTION.
I'M VERY SUPPORTIVE OF, UH, OF, UH, CITY STAFF ENGAGING IN THE PROCESS THAT YOU'VE OUTLINED.
AND I JUST WANTED TO THANK, THANK YOU ALL.
AND I SUSPECT THAT, UH, AS WE MOVE FORWARD IN THIS PROCESS, YOU'RE GONNA SEE ME TRANSITION FROM THIS SIDE OF THE DAIS TO THAT SIDE OF THE DIOCESE
WE HAVE TO DEAL WITH HIM HERE.
WE CAN CONTROL HIM A LITTLE BIT, BUT THEN HE GOES TO THE, BUT YOU KNOW HOW TO DO.
I, I JUST WANNA ADD, UH, THAT CONGRATULATIONS ON A GREAT PRESENTATION.
ALL OF YOU, ALEX INCLUDED, AND THE IDEA OF BRINGING ART AND TRAILS TOGETHER REALLY RESONATES WITH ME.
I'D LIKE TO KNOW MORE ABOUT IT WHERE I CAN HELP WITH THAT TOO.
AND I JUST CONCUR WITH ALL OF MY COLLEAGUES.
KEVIN TALKS ABOUT OUR BRAND, YOU KNOW, TRAILS ARE OUR BRAND.
AND SO THOSE TRAILS HAVE TO REPRESENT THE BRAND THAT WE WANT FOR BOTH OUR RESIDENTS AND OUR VISITORS.
AND I DID NOT REALIZE HOW, AND THIS WAS SUCH A GREAT PRESENTATION, HOW FAR BEHIND WE ARE FROM CITIES, YOU KNOW, SIMILAR CITIES.
UH, TIME FOR, OH, GO AHEAD, MELISSA.
NOW THAT WE HAVE ANOTHER MELISSA, SORRY.
BUT, UM, YOU'RE A CG I'M A DIFFERENT KIND OF MELISSA.
SO, UM, I JUST WANTED TO SORT OF AGREE WITH WHAT EVERYONE ELSE HAS SAID.
WE ALWAYS TALK ABOUT THE TRAILS AS BEING IMPORTANT.
I THINK WE, WHENEVER WE GET INTO THE POINT OF DIRECTION THAT, YOU KNOW, WE SHOULD HAVE THAT CONVERSATION AROUND.
HOW DOES THE CITY ENGAGE? UM, I, I'M JUST GONNA BE THE DEBBIE DOWNER HERE AND SAY, WANTING AND HAVING ARE TWO DIFFERENT THINGS.
UM, AND IT'S COMPLICATED WHEN WE'RE WORKING WITH THE CITY AND THE PROJECTS THAT YOU WANNA DO, THEY'RE COMPLICATED.
AND WHEN WE TALK ABOUT EVEN SHARED USE PATHS, QUITE HONESTLY, WE HAVE A BUNCH OF THEM WE WANNA DO IN THE CITY.
SO HOW THESE ALL GET ASSORTED, HOW THEY'RE GONNA GET LABELED IN PRIORITY, ALL OF THAT HAS TO NOW FIT IN, IN A MUCH BROADER SET, UM, EXPRESSION OF WHATEVER WE'RE GONNA BE DOING.
AND THAT'S SOMETHING THAT WE'RE GOING TO RELY ON CITY TO TELL US HOW IT'S GONNA HAPPEN.
SO IT MAY NOT HAPPEN AS, YOU KNOW, GOVERNMENT MOVES REALLY SLOWLY.
OUR GOVERNMENT MIGHT MOVE FASTER THAN ALEX'S GOVERNMENT.
SO I, I JUST WANNA SET THE EXPECTATION THAT EVEN THOUGH WE, WE ALL MIGHT AGREE, WE LIKE THE IDEA A LOT.
THERE'S A LOT INVOLVED WHEN, WHEN YOU INVOLVE THE CITY.
I WAS GONNA SAY SAME THING HOLLY SAID, WHERE'S THE COUNTIES? UM, BECAUSE A LOT OF THIS STUFF IS IN THE COUNTIES AND THAT IT'S AS IMPORTANT FOR THE COUNTIES AS IT IS FOR THE CITY FOR US TO BE ABLE TO DO OUR TRAILS PROUD.
SO THANK YOU FOR ALL THE HARD WORK YOU DID.
WHO'S IN COLUMBUS? OKAY, WE'RE BACK.
UH, SIR, I DID NOT REALIZE YOU WERE IN THE, ON THE EAST COAST TIME AND I APOLOGIZE TO YOU KEEPING YOU SO LATE.
[02:30:02]
NO, NO WORRIES.[9.b. AB 3398 Report from the City Council Performance Audit Committee, and direction from City Council regarding performance auditing.]
BARBARA.UH, MAYOR, UH, VICE MAYOR, MEMBERS OF COUNCIL, UH, BARBARA WHITEHORN, UH, DEPUTY CITY MANAGER.
AND I'M, I WILL GIVE A BRIEF UPDATE ON THE PERFORMANCE AUDIT COMMITTEE AND WHAT WE'VE BEEN DOING SINCE THE COMMITTEE WAS FORMED IN JANUARY OF THIS YEAR.
AND THEN I WILL TURN IT OVER TO PETE AND, UH, KEVIN, NOT KEVIN PHELPS, THIS KEVIN.
AND HE'LL GIVE A, A PRESENTATION ON AUDITING.
A LOT OF THE FOCUS HAS BEEN ON KEY PERFORMANCE INDICATORS FOR DEPARTMENTS, BECAUSE AS I'M SURE YOU'RE ALL AWARE FROM OUR BUDGET, WE TRACK HUNDREDS OF WORKFORCE MEASURES AND PERFORMANCE MEASURES.
AND THE MEASURES THAT REALLY HAVE IMPACT HAVE A TENDENCY TO GET LOST IN A LIST OF 700 DIFFERENT METRICS.
SO WE TALKED A LOT ABOUT BRINGING THOSE DOWN TO SOMETHING THAT WOULD REALLY MAKE SENSE TO THE COMMUNITY AND COMING UP WITH SOME KIND OF DASHBOARD THAT WOULD, UH, PRESENT THOSE METRICS BASICALLY BY DEPARTMENT AND AND FUNCTION.
UM, OTHER THINGS THAT WE TALKED ABOUT WAS THE OPEN FINANCE MODULE FROM TYLER TECHNOLOGY.
AS YOU ALL KNOW, WE'RE DOING THE ENTERPRISE RESOURCE PLANNING, UM, BIG PROJECT THAT GOES LIVE FOR FINANCE IN JANUARY.
AND WE ADDED TO THAT, UM, IT WAS ONLY $3,200 FOR THE ADD-ON FOR THE IMPLEMENTATION AND $10,000 ABOUT A YEAR FOR THE SUBSCRIPTION, WHAT'S CALLED OPEN FINANCE.
AND IT'S, UH, IT'S A LINK ON OUR WEBSITE.
IT WILL BE THAT TAKES YOU TO A TYLER CLOUD THING THAT PULLS OUR FINANCIALS EVERY NIGHT AND PARSES THEM INTO REALLY EASY TO UNDERSTAND, UM, INFORMATION FOR THE COMMUNITY.
AND IF YOU'RE INTERESTED IN LOOKING AT WHAT OPEN FINANCE LOOKS LIKE, THERE'S A LINK IN THE AGENDA TO THE CITY OF KINGMAN.
AND IF FOR SOME REASON THAT LINK DOESN'T WORK OR ANYBODY WANTS TO SEE IT, YOU CAN JUST GO TO KINGMAN'S WEBSITE AND IT'S JUST RIGHT THERE.
IT SAYS KINGMAN OPEN FINANCE, AND IT'S A REALLY PRETTY ROBUST FINANCIAL TRANSPARENCY TOOL.
UM, AND THEN WE TALKED ABOUT PERFORMANCE AUDITING.
AND WITH THAT, I AM GOING TO TURN IT OVER TO PETE TO INTRODUCE OUR PRESENTER, AND THEN I WILL MOVE THE SLIDES FORWARD AS HE NEEDS THEM.
UH, I DID WANNA ADD THE, TO THE COUNCIL, THE KPI WORK THAT WE'RE DOING IS, HAS BEEN INTERESTING AND VALUABLE.
UH, AND I THINK IT'S VALUABLE IN A, IN MANY DIFFERENT LEVELS.
ONE FROM A STAFF PERSPECTIVE, BUT THEN ALSO FOR A COUNCIL PERSPECTIVE BECAUSE WE DO SEE KPIS IN OUR BUDGET BOOKS, BUT WE REALLY DON'T GET A LOT OF TIME TO FOCUS ON 'EM.
AND SO MAYBE THERE'S A DIFFERENT AND A BETTER WAY FOR COUNCIL AND THE PUBLIC TO SEE THAT.
AND THEN KIND OF COUPLED WITH THAT IS THIS FUTURE IDEA HERE OF, OF, UH, DASHBOARDING PER, UH, OF CREATING SOME KIND OF DASHBOARD THAT WOULD BE PUBLICLY VISIBLE AS WELL.
UH, TO, AGAIN, FROM TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY TO SHOW, UH, KPIS IN A VERY DIGESTIBLE FORM FOR US AND THE, THE PUBLIC.
SO THAT'S BEEN REALLY GREAT AND I WANNA APPRECIATE THE STAFF THAT, UH, WORK AND THAT WE HAVE HAD IN THE DEPARTMENTS THAT WE REVIEWED SO FAR.
IT'S ALL BEEN REALLY A GREAT CONVERSATION MOVING FORWARD.
SO NOW, UH, I WOULD LIKE TO, UM, TALK ABOUT THE, UH, INTRODUCE OUR, OUR SPEAKER TONIGHT AND TALK ABOUT HOW WE GOT HERE.
AS YOU KNOW, THIS HAS BEEN A TOPIC THAT I'VE BEEN A FAN OF FOR ALL THE FOUR YEARS, UH, THAT I'VE BEEN HERE.
AND I APPRECIATE BEING ABLE TO GET TO THIS SPOT TONIGHT.
UM, UH, SORRY, I DON'T UNDERSTAND
UH, WHEN, UH, I FIRST STARTED THIS, I DEFINITELY REACHED OUT DIRECTLY TO THE ASSOCIATION OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT AUDITORS.
I KNEW THAT THEY HAD AN ADVOCACY COMMITTEE, AND THEY'VE BEEN HELPFUL FOR FOUR YEARS OF TALKING TO ME ABOUT HOW TO MOVE THINGS LIKE THIS FORWARD IN CITIES.
AND I'M VERY PLEASED TO GET HERE.
KEVIN, I THINK I GOT CLOSER EVEN THIS TIME.
I TEND TO PUT ANOTHER, UH, SYLLABLE IN THERE.
KOWSKI IS, UM, KEVIN IS THE DIRECTOR, UH, THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF SPECIALTY AUDITS IN THE CITY OF, UH, THE COLUMBUS CITY SCHOOLS.
[02:35:01]
IMPORTANTLY FOR TONIGHT'S ACTIVITY, THE VICE CHAIR OF THE ADV ADVOCACY COMMITTEE FOR ALGA.AND SO, UH, HE'S HERE, THIS PRESENTATION THAT HE'S PUT, THAT WE'LL SEE TOGETHER THAT HE PUT TOGETHER IS REALLY THE ALGA POINT OF VIEW OF AUDITING.
THIS ISN'T BEEN CRAFTED BY THE COMMITTEE OR MYSELF REALLY.
THIS IS KEVIN'S, UH, WORK AND I THINK REPRESENTS THE POSITION OF ALGA, UM, QUITE FAIRLY.
UM, THERE IS A SMALL PART WHEN WE KIND OF TALK ABOUT, UH, HOW WE MIGHT USE IT, WHERE WE MIGHT USE IT IN THE CITY THAT I HELPED HIM, UM, UH, COME UP WITH IDEAS.
SO I'LL PROBABLY RUN THAT PART.
BUT KEVIN, I WANNA APPRECIATE THE FACT THAT IT'S NOW 10 30 YOUR TIME IN COLUMBUS.
UM, BUT I'M SURE AS A, A GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEE AND, AND GOING TO COUNCIL MEETINGS OR, UM, WHATEVER YOUR EXPERIENCE, OTHER EXPERIENCE HAS BEEN IN THE PAST THAT YOU'VE, UH, EXPERIENCED LONG RUNNING MEETINGS.
AND SO I APPRECIATE YOU HANGING IN THERE WITH US.
AND I'M GONNA TURN IT OVER TO YOU.
THANK YOU, UH, COUNSELOR FIRM.
I APPRECIATE THAT INTRODUCTION.
UM, NO WORRIES ABOUT THE TIME, REALLY.
UM, I, I CAN ASSURE YOU, AND I WILL IN NO WAY TRY TO CONVINCE YOU THAT TONIGHT'S TOPIC IS GOING TO BE AS, UH, EXCITING AND AS, UM, PROBABLY INTIMATE AS, UH, THE, THE PREVIOUS ONE ABOUT TRAIL MAINTENANCE AND, AND IT BEING THE BRAND OF SEDONA.
AND, UM, EVEN THOUGH IT MIGHT NOT BE NEARLY AS INTERESTING, I DO BELIEVE IT TO BE EQUALLY IMPORTANT.
'CAUSE WE'RE GONNA BE TALKING ABOUT, YOU KNOW, HOW YOU CAN BEST SERVE YOUR CONSTITUENTS AND THE CITIZENS OF SEDONA.
AND ONE WAY TO GO ABOUT DOING THAT AND PROVIDING TO THE GOVERNMENT, TO THOSE FOLKS THAT YOU'VE BEEN ENTRUSTED TO GOVERN IS THROUGH THE ESTABLISHMENT OF AN INDEPENDENT AUDIT FUNCTION.
AND SO I COMMEND YOU FOR GETTING, UM, THIS FAR IN THE PROCESS AND, AND HOPEFULLY THAT YOU WILL CONTINUE DOWN THIS ROAD AND ACTUALLY GET IT ESTABLISHED.
AND I'M HERE TONIGHT TO TRY TO HELP YOU, UH, WITH SOME INFORMATION, PROVIDE YOU SOME INFORMATION, UM, THAT HOPEFULLY HELPS YOU IN THAT DECISION MAKING.
UM, AS, AS COUNCILOR FURMAN MENTIONED TONIGHT, I DO REPRESENT ALDA.
UM, I AM THE VICE CHAIR OF THE ADVOCACY COMMITTEE.
AND IF YOU GO TO THE NEXT SLIDE, YOU'LL SEE A LITTLE BIT ABOUT ALDA AND THE ASSOCIATION, LOCAL GOVERNMENT AUDITORS.
AND REALLY WHAT IT IS, IT'S A PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATION THAT REPRESENTS LOCAL GOVERNMENT AUDITORS AS WELL AS AUDITORS AT OTHER LEVELS, WHETHER IT'S STATE AUDITORS, COUNTY LEVEL AUDITORS, WE EVEN HAVE FEDERAL LEVEL AUDITORS THAT ARE MEMBERS.
SO EVEN THOUGH THE NAME IS LOCAL GOVERNMENT AUDITORS, IT'S A LITTLE BIT OF A MISNOMER IN THAT WE HAVE MEMBERS AND WE ASSIST, UM, ALL LEVELS OF GOVERNMENT AUDITORS AS PART OF ELGAS MISSION.
AND, AND ONE OF ITS SPECIFIC STRATEGIC OBJECTIVES IS THE CHAMPION OF INDEPENDENT AUDIT FUNCTIONS AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT AUDITING FUNCTIONS.
THAT'S A, A VERY SPECIFIC, UM, STRATEGIC OBJECTIVE THAT THEY HAVE.
AND AS WELL AS BEING BUILT INTO THEIR MISSION, ONE OF THE WAYS THEY EXECUTE THAT OR CARRY OUT AND TRY TO TRY TO EXECUTE ON THAT MISSION AND OBJECTIVE IS THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THEIR ADVOCACY COMMITTEE.
UM, CURRENTLY WE HAVE, I THINK IT'S, UH, AROUND 16 OR 17 MEMBERS REPRESENTING VARIOUS LEVELS OF GOVERNMENT, UM, FROM ACROSS THE COUNTRY, UM, THAT THEN MEETS AND, AND TRIES TO CARRY OUT AGA'S MISSION AND STRATEGIC OBJECTIVES REGARDING GLOBAL GOVERNMENT AUDITING.
YOU'LL SEE ON THE SLIDE THERE WHERE WE'LL TALK ABOUT THREE SPECIFIC THINGS THAT WE REALLY TRY TO DO THROUGH ADVOCACY AND THROUGH OUR ADVOCACY COMMITTEE.
AND THAT IS CHAMPIONING NEW AUDIT FUNCTIONS SUCH AS THE CITY OF SEDONA AND ANYBODY ELSE THAT WANTS TO START A FUNCTION.
WE TRY TO CHAMPION THAT AND ADVOCATE FOR THAT.
UM, WE TRY TO DEFEND FUNCTIONS THAT ARE UNDER THREAT, THAT A THREAT TO THEIR INDEPENDENCE.
UM, SO AN OTHER FORM OF THREAT TO, UM, PERHAPS BUDGETING RESTRICTIONS OR SCOPE RESTRICTIONS.
SO WE TRY TO HELP THEM IN, IN DEFENDING ESTABLISHED FUNCTIONS AS WELL AS WE TRY TO HELP IMPROVE EXISTING FUNCTIONS.
SO WE MIGHT, UM, OFFER SOME ASSISTANCE OR OFFER, UM, GUIDANCE ON BEST PRACTICE OR THINGS THAT HAVE WORKED IN OTHER PLACES IF WE'RE CONTACTED BY LOCAL GOVERNMENT, UH, AUDITS.
UM, SO THE BIGGEST ONE, OBVIOUSLY TONIGHT IS CHAMPIONING A NEW AUDIT FUNCTION.
WHY, WHY IS INDEPENDENT AUDITING, OR WHY DOES INDEPENDENT AUDITING MATTER? UM, AS A CITY COUNCIL, YOU'RE ELECTED AND ENTRUSTED TO MAKE GOOD DECISIONS ON BEHALF OF YOUR CITIZENS.
AND THE FOLKS THAT ELECTED THE, THE REASON THAT AN INDEPENDENT AUDITING IS SO
[02:40:01]
IMPORTANT BECAUSE GOOD DECISIONS AND GOOD GOVERNING IS BASED ON GOOD, STRONG, SOLID, OBJECTIVE INFORMATION.AND MY GUESS IS THAT THE COUNCIL GETS INFORMATION IN ITS NORMAL OPERATIONS FROM CITY LEADERSHIP, CITY STAFF, YOUR OWN COUNCIL STAFF, UH, RESIDENTS, UH, OTHER STAKEHOLDERS, YOUR PARTNERS, FOLKS THAT MIGHT HAVE EVEN BEEN SPEAKING TONIGHT.
THE THE CHALLENGE THAT YOU HAVE WITH THE INFORMATION THAT COMES FROM THOSE FOLKS IS THAT IT IS INHERENTLY BIASED AND THERE IS INHERENT BIAS BUILT INTO THE PRESENTATION AND INTO THE INFORMATION THAT THEY TELL YOU.
IDEALLY, WITH AN INDEPENDENT AUDIT FUNCTION, WHAT YOU'RE GOING TO GET IS OBJECTIVE INFORMATION, THE WHOLE IDEA OF THE FUNCTION, THAT IT IS AN INDEPENDENT OBJECTIVE RESOURCE TO PROVIDE COUNSEL AS WELL AS OTHER PARTS OF THE ORGANIZATION, IDEALLY AS A TRUSTED ADVISOR FOR OTHER PARTS OF, UM, THE ORGANIZATION, WHETHER THAT'S, UM,
BUT THE, THE TRUE FUNCTION OF IT IS TO PROVIDE CITY COUNCIL OBJECTIVE ASSURANCE THAT YOUR RESOURCES, YOUR PROGRAMS, YOUR OPERATIONS ARE MANAGED EFFECTIVELY, EFFICIENTLY, UM, AND IN ACCORDANCE WITH OTHER LAWS OR POLICIES THAT MIGHT BE IN PLACE, AS WELL AS CARRYING OUT THE CITY COUNCIL'S INTENTIONS.
UM, YOU HAVE VERY SPECIFIC THINGS THAT YOU WANT TO ACCOMPLISH, AND INDEPENDENT AUDIT FUNCTION CAN GIVE YOU FEEDBACK AND ASSURANCE ON WHETHER OR NOT THOSE THINGS ARE BEING CARRIED ON.
KEVIN, IF I COULD INTERRUPT JUST WITH ONE POINT HERE THAT I THINK MIGHT MATTER WHEN YOU USE THE WORD AUDIT.
IN THIS PRESENTATION TODAY, YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT PERFORMANCE AUDITING AS OPPOSED TO FINANCE AUDITS.
AND WE DID PUT IN THE PACKET SOME INFORMATION FOR COUNCIL ABOUT THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN, UH, FINANCE AUDITS AND PERFORMANCE AUDITS.
IS THERE ANYTHING THAT YOU WANNA ADD JUST TO HELP US FOCUS ON THE CONTENT OF YOUR PRESENTATION? NO, THAT IS A A VERY GOOD POINT FOR, UH, CONTEXT.
I AM SPEAKING ABOUT PERFORMANCE AUDITING.
I UNDERSTAND YOU LIKELY HAVE A REQUIREMENT THAT YOU HAVE A FINANCIAL AUDIT WHERE YOU PREPARE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND THERE'S AN AUDIT OPINION ASSOCIATED WITH THOSE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS.
UM, I'M GUESSING ON A, ON AN ANNUAL BASIS THAT THERE'S THAT REQUIREMENT.
I'M TALKING ABOUT AUDITING FROM THE, UH, IN THE CONTEXT OF PROGRAM OPERATIONS, COMPLIANCE, UM, INTERNAL CONTROL, ANYTHING IN WHICH, UM, THERE IS AN ASSERTION OF WHAT IS GOING ON AS FAR AS, UM, THESE INTERNAL CONTROLS ARE IN PLACE, OR THIS COMPLIANCE, WE AREN'T BEING IN COMPLIANCE WITH THIS REQUIREMENT.
SO THERE'S AN ASSERTION THAT IS MADE.
AND THEN THE PURPOSE OF THE AUDIT IS TO GIVE YOU FEEDBACK ON IS THERE SUPPORT TO SUBSTANTIATE THAT ASSERTION.
AND SO THAT CONTEXT IS IMPORTANT IN THAT WE ARE TALKING ABOUT PERFORMANCE AUDITING VERSUS STRAIGHT FINANCIAL AUDIT, FINANCIAL STATEMENT AUDITING.
I'D LIKE TO ASK BARBARA A QUESTION.
DO WE DO AUDITING OF CONTROLS? YES.
INTERNAL CONTROLS ARE A CRITICAL, I THOUGHT CRITICAL PART OF THE FINANCIAL AUDIT.
SO, WELL, I'M SORRY, GO AHEAD.
YOU'RE SAYING THAT BECAUSE A DEPARTMENT DOES IT ITSELF, IT'S GONNA BE BIASED AND WE CAN'T RELY ON IT.
WELL, AS FAR AS INTERNAL CONTROLS IN YOUR FINANCIAL AUDIT, JUST TO BE CLEAR, THE INTERNAL CONTROLS THAT ARE REVIEWED DURING YOUR FINANCIAL AUDIT ARE THE INTERNAL CONTROLS THAT ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE PREPARATION OF THOSE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS.
WHAT I'M SPEAKING ABOUT, THERE'S MORE, UH, GRANULAR INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER ENSURING THAT CERTAIN THINGS GET DONE.
UM, FOR INSTANCE, UH, TAKE, TAKE YOUR PURCHASING CYCLE.
YOU WANT TO ENSURE THAT THERE ARE CONTROLS AND CERTAIN THINGS GET DONE AND THAT CERTAIN REVIEWS TAKE PLACE AND CERTAIN APPROVALS TAKE PLACE.
WELL, THOSE ARE INTERNAL CONTROLS WITHIN THAT PROCESS, BUT THEY MAY NOT BE AN INTERNAL CONTROL IN THE PREPARATION OF YOUR FINANCIAL STATEMENTS, AND SO THEY WON'T BE ADDRESSED IN YOUR FINANCIAL AUDIT.
SO WE'RE TALKING ABOUT INTERNAL CONTROLS AT A MUCH GRANULAR AND OPERATIONAL LEVEL.
I'M, I'M SORRY, KEVIN TO INTERRUPT.
OUR FINANCIAL AUDIT ANNUALLY EVALUATES THOSE INTERNAL CONTROLS FOR ALL OF THOSE SEPARATIONS OF DUTIES, APPROVALS, APPROVALS THAT ARE FUNCTIONALLY, UH, REASONABLE.
HAVE WE APPROVED PAYROLL CORRECTLY? HAVE WE APPROVED OUR PURCHASING CORRECTLY? THEY GO THROUGH ALL OF THOSE DIFFERENT THINGS, INCLUDING ALL THE IT SEPARATIONS OF DUTIES IN OUR, IN OUR SHAREPOINT AND IN HOW WE HAVE PERMISSIONS SET UP IN ALL
[02:45:01]
THOSE PROCESSES.SO IT ISN'T JUST THE INTERNAL CONTROL AROUND THOSE THINGS THAT WOULD LEAD TO A FINANCIAL STATEMENT.
UM, AND I'M NOT SUGGESTING THAT THAT MEANS THEY DO EVERYTHING, BUT THEY ARE MUCH MORE ROBUST THAN JUST THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS.
AND, AND, AND REMEMBER THAT THE, THE PURPOSE OF THAT AUDIT IS TO ISSUE THE FINANCIAL STATEMENT OPINION.
IT'S NOT TO REALLY GIVE YOU ANY ASSURANCE ON THE EFFECTIVENESS OF YOUR INTERNAL CONTROLS WHEN IT COMES TO THAT GRANULAR LEVEL THAT I'M TALKING ABOUT, THE, THE FINANCIAL STATEMENT THAT THE, THE AUDITOR THAT DOES YOUR FINANCIAL AUDIT IS RESPONSIBLE FOR ISSUING AN AUDIT OPINION ON THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS.
AND SO ALL OF THE WORK THAT THEY DO IS, IS DIRECTED TOWARDS THEM BEING ABLE TO ISSUE THAT OPINION.
SO THERE IS, I MEAN, THERE IS, THERE IS A, THERE IS A DIFFERENCE IN THE LEVEL AT WHICH THEY LOOK AT YOUR INTERNAL CONTROLS AND THE PURPOSE FOR WHICH THEY, YOUR INTERNAL CONTROLS IN A FINANCIAL AUDIT VERSUS WHAT YOU WOULD LOOK AT IT AND THE REASON YOU WOULD LOOK AT IT IN A PERFORMANCE AUDIT.
BARBARA CAN, DO YOU RESPOND TO THAT PLEASE? I, I FEEL LIKE WE'RE ACTUALLY SAYING THE SAME THING.
UM, OUR AUDITORS DO GIVE US A REPORT ON INTERNAL CONTROLS.
IT'S NOT PART OF THE ASSERTION THAT THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS ARE CORRECT, BUT IT IS PART OF WHAT THEY PROVIDE TO MANAGEMENT AS A, YOU KNOW, HERE'S ISSUES THAT WE FOUND THAT YOU SHOULD FIX OR YOUR INTERNAL CONTROLS LOOK GOOD.
AND ANNUALLY, THEY USUALLY PICK A FEW AREAS IN THE CITY TO REALLY DO LIKE MORE OF A DEEP DIVE.
LIKE THEY MAY LOOK MORE INTENSELY AT PAYROLL ONE YEAR AND SET UPS AND PERMISSIONS WITHIN PAYROLL, AND ANOTHER YEAR THEY MIGHT DO PROCUREMENT AND PCARD USE.
UM, BUT THEY DO GO REALLY DEEP INTO THOSE AND THEY DO REPORT ON THOSE TO US.
AND I DO NOT KNOW THE SPECIFIC SITUATION OR THE ARRANGEMENT THAT YOU HAVE WITH YOUR FINANCIAL AUDITOR.
I AM SPEAKING IN JUST FINANCIAL AUDIT, MY OWN FINANCIAL AUDIT KNOWLEDGE AND EXPERIENCE IN THAT, UNLESS YOU, UNLESS YOU ENGAGE THEM FOR THAT LEVEL OF SERVICE, THAT IS NOT TYPICALLY THE LEVEL OF SERVICE YOU WOULD GET.
SO I DON'T, I I DON'T MEAN TO SAY THAT YOUR AUDITORS DON'T PROVIDE EXACTLY WHAT IT IS YOU'RE SAYING.
I AM SIMPLY SAYING THAT IT, IT, IT IS NOT TYPICALLY PART OF A FINANCIAL AUDIT, BUT IT MAY BE A SERVICE THAT THEY PROVIDE TO YOU IN ADDITION TO THAT LEVEL OF FINANCIAL AUDIT, UH, CONTROL WORK THAT THEY DO.
SIR, MAY I ASK, DID YOU REVIEW OUR FINANCIAL AUDITS THROUGH THOSE, THE DOCUMENTS THAT WE HAVE FROM OUR AUDITORS? DID YOU ACTUALLY LOOK AT THOSE TO SEE WHAT THEY ARE REPORTING? I DID NOT REVIEW.
I DID NOT REVIEW YOUR FINANCIAL AUDIT REPORTS, SO THANK YOU.
ALRIGHT, SO IF WE MOVE ON TO THE SLIDE OF AUDIT FUNCTION PURPOSE, THE PURPOSE OF YOUR AUDIT FUNCTION IS TO TALK ABOUT, OR, OR IS TO, TO SAFEGUARD YOUR PUBLIC RESOURCES.
YOU WANNA BE GOOD STEWARDS OF YOUR PUBLIC RESOURCES.
UH, ESTABLISHING AN AUDIT FUNCTION HELPS TO PROVIDE THAT STEWARDSHIP.
IT ALSO STRENGTHENS ACCOUNTABILITY AND OVERSIGHT, IMPROVES EFFICIENCY AND EFFECTIVENESS, IDENTIFIES AND MITIGATES RISKS.
UM, I'M NOT SURE THE, THE, THE MATURITY OF YOUR RISK MANAGEMENT PROCESS, IF YOU'VE IDENTIFIED CERTAIN OPERATIONAL OR FINANCIAL RELATED RISKS MM-HMM
UM, BUT, UH, AN INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION CAN HELP IDENTIFY THOSE AS WELL AS HELP DESIGN PROCEDURES OR CONTROLS TO HELP MITIGATE THOSE RISKS.
AND AUDIT FUNCTION ALSO ENHANCES THE TRANSPARENCY AND PUBLIC TRUST THROUGH PUBLIC REPORT.
UM, TRANSPARENCY IS, UH, I THINK I'VE HEARD IT A COUPLE OF TIMES EVEN THAT TONIGHT'S MEETING SEEMS TO BE AN IMPORTANT THING, NOT JUST FOR YOUR FOLKS', UH, RESIDENTS, BUT ALSO, YOU KNOW, FOR THE, THE, THE RESIDENTS.
UH, MOST CITIES, YOU KNOW, TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY AND PUBLIC TRUST IS A BIG DEAL.
AND AUDIT FUNCTION CAN HELP IN THOSE AREAS.
MAY I ASK ANOTHER QUESTION? I'M SORRY.
DO YOU WANT QUESTIONS AS YOU GO ALONG OR DO YOU WANNA GET THROUGH EVERYTHING AND THEN HAVE QUESTIONS? NO, UM, I WOULD ACTUALLY PREFER IF, IF IT'S ABOUT THE INFORMATION THAT WAS JUST PRESENTED.
THAT WAY IT HELPS KEEP MY MIND FRESH.
SO YOU JUST SAID IN, UM, THAT PART OF WHAT WOULD BE PRODUCED WOULD BE PUBLIC REPORTS.
WHAT, WHAT DO THOSE LOOK LIKE? BECAUSE THAT'S ONE OF MY AREAS OF CONCERN IS THAT SOME OF THE INFORMATION THAT I THINK WE MAY ALREADY HAVE INTERNALLY AND WE MAY NEED MORE, BUT, UM, THAT IT BE
[02:50:01]
COMMUNICATED TO THE PUBLIC TO GIVE THE PUBLIC FAITH IN OUR PROCESS.SO HOW DO YOU DO THAT? WHAT PUBLIC REPORTS ARE YOU REFERRING TO? WHAT DO THEY LOOK LIKE? WHAT WOULD THEY CONVEY AND HOW WOULD THEY BE DISSEMINATED? TYPICALLY, UH, TYPICALLY THE AUDIT PROCESS RESULTS IN SOME FORMAL REPORT CRAFTED AS TO WHAT THE OBJECTIVES OF THE PROJECT WERE, WHAT THE SCOPE OF IT WAS, THE, UH, A DESCRIPTION OF THE REASON WHY THE AUDIT WAS UNDERTAKEN, AND THEN WHATEVER THE RESULTS ARE.
AND THAT CHANGES AND VARIES FROM ORGANIZATION TO ORGANIZATION.
SO THAT'S ESSENTIALLY WHAT THE CONTENT IS.
PUBLIC REPORTING TYPICALLY TAKES PLACE IN THE FORM OF, UH, WHETHER IT'S DIRECTLY TO COUNCIL, A SUBCOMMITTEE COUNCIL, OR, UH, IDEALLY AN AUDIT COMMITTEE THAT IS CREATED.
UM, A PUBLIC MEETING IS HELD WITH WHICH THOSE THINGS ARE DISCUSSED.
UH, THE REPORT IS PRESENTED, THE INFORMATION IS PRESENTED, AND THEN ALSO GENERALLY ORGANIZATIONS WILL POST THOSE AUDIT REPORTS TO THEIR WEBSITES.
SO THAT'S THE, THAT'S THE LEVEL OF PUBLIC REPORTING AND TRANSPARENCY I'M REFERRING TO.
SO AN INDEPENDENT AUDIT WOULD GIVE US INFORMATION THAT WE WOULD THEN STILL NEED TO, UH, TRANSLATE INTO PUBLIC INFORMATION.
IS THAT CORRECT? UM, I'M NOT SURE I UNDERSTAND YOUR, YOUR QUESTION.
YOU TAKE THE AUDIT REPORT THAT TO TRANSLATE IT? YEAH, PRETTY MUCH.
LIKE, DO YOU UNDERSTAND WHAT I'M ASKING, BARBARA? I DO, IDEALLY, NO, I MEAN, IDEALLY THE, THE WORD SPEAKS FOR ITSELF AND THEN, YOU KNOW, THEN CERTAINLY THE COUNCIL AND OR MANAGEMENT WOULD'VE TO RESPOND TO TAKE WHATEVER ACTION THAT DEAL IS NECESSARY IN RESPONSE TO THE ITEMS THAT ARE INCLUDED IN THE REPORT.
AND, AND GENERALLY IF, IF YOU GO TO ANY OF THESE SITES AND, UH, ANY OF THESE DEPARTMENTS THAT DO INDEPENDENT, UH, PERFORMANCE AUDITS, THE, THE, THE, THE REPORT WILL COME OUT AND IT, IT STARTS AT THE BEGINNING WHAT THE SCOPE OF THE AUDIT WAS, WHAT THE ANALYSIS, YOU KNOW, WHAT, WHAT THE REASON FOR TAKING IT.
IT'S UP THE FINDINGS THAT THE AUDITOR HAS FOUND A RESPONSE, USUALLY FROM MANAGEMENT ABOUT ITS ASSESSMENT TO THOSE FINDINGS.
UM, AND THEN IT COMES TO COUNCIL, BUT IT'S ALL, IT'S ALWAYS A VERY READABLE DOCUMENT.
AND, AND, AND MY EXPERIENCE IN THE PAST IS THAT, YOU KNOW, THE, THE PUBLIC AND THE PRESS ACTUALLY DIG IN AND ENGAGE DIRECTLY WITH THAT DOCUMENT.
AND, UH, AND IT'S UP TO THEN THE COUNCIL TO, WHEN IT COMES TO MATTERS OF POLICY, TO, YOU KNOW, DECIDE WHICH OF THOSE FINDINGS, UH, ARE IMPORTANT.
AND IF IT'S A MANAGEMENT ISSUE, IT'S, IT'S A DIALOGUE BETWEEN THE COUNCIL AND THE MANAGER ABOUT WHAT TO DO ON EACH OF THOSE FINDINGS.
YOU ANSWERED THE QUESTION THAT I COULDN'T FULLY ARTICULATE.
UH, CORE RESPONSIBILITIES AND ACTIVITIES, THINGS YOU COULD EXPECT YOUR INDEPENDENT, UH, PERFORMANCE AUDIT FUNCTION TO BE DOING AS SERVICE TO THE CITY.
UM, FINANCIAL AND OPERATIONAL AUDITS.
NOW, I'VE USED THE WORD FINANCIAL HERE, BUT BASED ON OUR PREVIOUS CONVERSATION TO MAKE SURE WE UNDERSTAND CONTEXT, I AM NOT TALKING ABOUT FINANCIAL STATEMENT AUDITS.
UM, THEY MIGHT BE FINANCIAL IN NATURE IN THAT THEY ARE RELU REVIEWING.
AND THE, THE CORE OBJECTIVE OF THE AUDIT IS TO REVIEW FINANCIAL ACTIVITY WITHIN THE CITY SOMEWHERE, WHETHER THAT'S, UH, A PARTICULAR REVENUE SOURCE OR AN EXPENSE SOURCE, UM, OR EXPENSE, UH, EXPENSE STREAM.
SO I'M TALKING ABOUT FINANCIAL ACTIVITY, BUT NOT FINANCIAL STATEMENT AUDITS.
AND THEN WE ALSO HAVE OPERATIONAL AUDITS WHERE YOU MIGHT BE IN CONTROL.
IT MIGHT BE PROCESS EFFICIENCY OR EFFECTIVENESS, UM, WHETHER OR NOT, UM, AN ORGANIZATION OR WHETHER OR NOT, UM, A PART OF YOUR ORGANIZATION HAS CARRIED OUT OR MET GOALS THAT THEY HAD.
UM, THOSE ARE EXAMPLES OF OPERATIONAL AUDITS, COMPLIANCE REVIEWS.
THERE'S A PARTICULAR LAW OR RULE OR, OR GUIDELINE OR POLICY THAT COUNCIL WANTS TO MAKE SURE WAS, UH, COMPLIED WITH YOUR AUDITOR CAN CARRY OUT COMPLIANCE REVIEWS, INTERNAL CONTROL ASSESSMENTS.
WE SPOKE A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THOSE.
IN ADDITION TO REGULAR OPERATIONAL AND FINANCIAL RISKS, MOST ORGANIZATIONS HAVE FRAUD RISK, SO FRAUD RISK AS WELL RELATED TO THEIR OPERATIONS.
YOUR AUDITOR CAN HELP MANAGE THE FRAUD RISK MANAGEMENT AND THEN FOLLOW UP ON CORRECTIVE ACTION.
ANY WHAT THE WORK THAT THEY DO AND ANY OF THE ISSUES THAT WERE IDENTIFIED THAT REQUIRE FOLLOW UP.
YOUR INDEPENDENT AUDIT FUNCTION COULD THEN ALSO
[02:55:01]
SERVE AS THAT TOOL TO FOLLOW UP TO ENSURE THAT THE CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKES PLACE.RECOMMENDED STRUCTURE, RECOMMENDED STRUCTURE FOR YOUR FUNCTION IS THAT IT FUNCTIONALLY REPORTS TO THE CITY COUNCIL, A COUNCIL COMMITTEE, OR IDEALLY IF YOU CAN SET IT UP AS AN AUDIT COMMITTEE.
AND AN AUDIT COMMITTEE DIFFERS FROM THE OTHERS IN THAT YOU HAVE MEMBERS OF COUNCIL AS WELL AS MEMBERS OF YOUR COMMUNITY THAT SIT ON YOUR AUDIT COMMITTEE, HEAR THE RESULTS, CHIME IN ON RESULTS OFFER GUIDANCE, OFFER ASSISTANCE.
THEY HAVE SOME MAYBE THEIR FINANCIAL KNOWLEDGE OR AUDIT KNOWLEDGE, OR THEY HAVE SOME KNOWLEDGE OF GOVERNMENT FUNCTION TO BE ABLE TO PROVIDE A COMMUNITY VIEWPOINT ON, UM, THE AUDIT RESULTS.
SO FUNCTIONALLY, THE REPORT TO THE COUNCIL, COUNCIL COMMITTEE OR AUDIT COMMITTEE, FUNCTIONALLY, THAT MEANS THAT FOR THE PURPOSE OF AUDIT SCOPE, FOR THE PURPOSE OF THE WORK THAT IS DONE, THEY REPORT TO THE COMMITTEE.
THEY'RE SUPPORTED ADMINISTRATIVELY BY THE CITY CHIEF EXECUTIVE.
AND SO YOUR AUDIT EMPLOYEES, WHETHER IT'S JUST CHIEF AUDIT EXECUTIVE AND OR ANY STAFF THAT MIGHT BE, UM, HIRED, THEY'RE SUPPORTED ADMINISTRATIVELY BY THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE.
AND FOR EXAMPLE, THEY FOLLOW ALL THE CITY'S HR FUNCTIONS OR PAYROLL FUNCTIONS.
'CAUSE YOU DON'T WANT TO HAVE TO HAVE 'EM CREATE THEIR OWN ADMINISTRATIVE PROCESSES, WHETHER THERE'S ALREADY PROCESSES BUILT IN.
SO ADMINISTRATIVELY, THEY REPORT WAS REPORTED BY THE EXECUTIVE OFFICE.
UM, NEXT BULLET POINT IS THEY'LL PROVIDE AN UNRESTRICTED ACCESS TO RECORDS AND STAFF.
NOW, THERE'S LIKELY A CONCERN THAT, UM, YOU KNOW, CONFIDENTIALLY CONFIDENTIALITY AND PRIVACY ISSUES THAT GO ALONG WITH ACCESS TO CERTAIN RECORDS, YOUR INTERNAL AUDITOR WILL UNDERSTAND, OR YOUR PERFORMANCE AUDITOR WILL UNDERSTAND THAT THAT UNRESTRICTED ACCESS TO RECORDS AND STAFF COMES WITH THOSE RESPONSIBILITIES.
THEY ARE TO PROTECT THOSE AND THEY HAVE TO FOLLOW THOSE SAME RULES, BUT IT'S IMPORTANT THAT THEY HAVE THAT UNRESTRICTED ACCESS TO RECORDS AND STAFF SO THAT YOU DON'T RUN INTO SCOPE LIMITATIONS, AND YOU HAVE THE ABILITY TO GET A FULL PICTURE OF WHATEVER THE ISSUE MIGHT BE THAT THEY'RE AUDITING.
AND FINALLY, THE, THE LAST BULLET POINT THERE IS THAT THE WORK IS DRIVEN BY A RISK-BASED AUTO PLAN.
UNFORTUNATELY, AS GOVERNMENT ENTITIES AND MOST ENTITIES, WE DON'T HAVE RESOURCES THAT ALLOW US TO GO AND AUDIT EVERY SINGLE THING THAT WE THINK IS IMPORTANT.
AND THAT NEEDS TO BE, HAVE TO HAVE SOME ATTENTION AND AUDIT ALL OF THE ACTIVITY THAT THE ORGANIZATION DOES EVERY YEAR.
AND SO IT'S IMPORTANT TO USE A RISK BASED AUDIT PLAN IN WHICH YOU EVALUATE WHERE IS THE GREATEST RISK TO THE ORGANIZATION SO THAT I THEN KNOW WHERE TO GO SPEND MY GREATEST AUDIT RESOURCES TO GIVE THAT ASSURANCE OR TO GIVE THAT FEEDBACK ON THE, UM, ISSUES OR SUCCESS OF WHATEVER THAT FUNCTION IS.
SO THE STRUCTURE USES A RISK BASED AUDIT PLAN SIMPLY BECAUSE THEY CAME TO EVERYTHING THAT THEY NEED TO.
I HAVE, UM, EXCUSE ME, A QUICK QUESTION ON THAT ONE.
WHO TYPICALLY WOULD BE, UM, DETERMINING THE RISK BASE? UH, THAT'S USUALLY THE PRODUCT OF THE CHIEF AUDIT EXECUTIVE OR OF, OF THE FUNCTION.
THEY WILL DO A RISK ASSESSMENT THROUGH DISCUSSIONS WITH YOU, DISCUSSIONS WITH MANAGEMENT, UM, OTHER INFORMATION THAT THEY GATHER IN RESEARCH OF WHAT MIGHT BE TYPICAL RISKS ASSOCIATED WITH THE TYPES OF OPERATIONS THAT THE CITY OF SANTA DONOR WOULD HAVE.
AND SO THEY WOULD DO A RISK ASSESSMENT.
UM, SOME PLACES GO TO THE EXTENT OF ASSIGNING NUMERIC VALUES.
I MEAN, THERE'S DIFFERENT KNOWLEDGE METHODOLOGIES TO DO THAT RISK ASSESSMENT, BUT THEY WOULD IDENTIFY THE AREAS THAT ARE THE HIGHEST RISK AND BELIEVE TO WARRANT AUDIT RESOURCES.
THEY WOULD THEN PRESENT THAT TO COUNCIL, THE COUNCIL COMMITTEE OR AUDIT COMMITTEE.
HOWEVER, THE STRUCTURE ENDS UP BEING DESIGNED.
AND THEN THE COUNCIL FOR THAT COMMITTEE THEN ENDS OFF ON THE PLAN AND APPROVES THE WORK PLAN FOR THE AUDIT, UH, FUNCTION TO THEN GO CARRY OUT THE WORK.
I'D LIKE TO ASK IF YOU COULD, UH, PROVIDE A LITTLE BIT MORE.
I WANTED TO JUST CLARIFY IN, IN MY VIEW, AS I HEAR YOUR PRESENTATION AND READ YOUR WORDS REPORT FUNCTIONALLY TO THE CITY COUNCIL AND THEN SKIP INTO THE SECOND BULLET AS WELL, SUPPORTED ADMINISTRATIVELY BY THE CITY CHIEF EXECUTIVE.
SOUNDS A LOT LIKE THE COUNCIL APPOINTEES THAT WE CURRENTLY HAVE THAT FUNCTIONALLY THE CITY COUNCIL MEANS
[03:00:01]
IN ONE SENSE, THAT THE HIGHER FIRE DECISION MIGHT BE THE CITY COUNCIL ADMINISTRATIVELY BY THE CITY CHIEF, IS THAT THEY USE THE HR FUNCTIONS AND THE, YOU KNOW, WHATEVER ELSE, UH, ADMINISTRATIVELY IN, IN THE FUNCTION.SO I THINK IF I UNDERSTAND YOU CORRECTLY, THAT'S A MODEL OF OPERATION THAT WE'RE CURRENTLY, UM, UH, USED TO, UH, IF YOU HAVE ANY FURTHER COMMENT ON THAT, I'D APPRECIATE IT.
BUT THEN I ALSO WANT TO ASK ABOUT IDEALLY, THE AUDIT COMMITTEE.
AND SO I'M CURIOUS ABOUT THAT VERSUS, UH, REPORTING FUNCTIONALLY TO THE CITY COUNCIL.
WHY WOULD A CITY COUNCIL, UH, BE MAYBE LESS IDEAL THAN A, AN AUDIT COMMITTEE? UM, WELL, THE ANSWER TO, TO THE YOUR FIRST QUESTION IS, IS YES, AS I UNDERSTAND HOW THE, THE CITY OF SEDONA IS CURRENTLY ORGANIZED, IT WOULD BE THE CITY COUNCIL'S RESPONSIBILITY FOR FIRE, FIRE OF THE, UM, CHIEF AUDIT EXECUTIVE FOR THIS FUNCTION.
UM, RATHER THAN IT BEING IN MANAGEMENT OR AN EXECUTIVE, UH, ACTION OR TASK, IT SHOULD BE CITY COUNCIL'S TASK TO HIRE OR, AND MC FIRE AND EMPLOY THE CHIEF AUDIT EXECUTIVE.
AS FAR AS AUDIT COMMITTEE VERSUS COUNCIL, UM, THE, THE ADVANTAGE, THE ADVANTAGE IS THAT YOU DO GET A WIDER AND DIVERSE, UH, REPRESENTATION.
UM, CERTAINLY COUNCIL, CITY COUNCILS, AND THERE ARE CITY COUNCIL ACROSS THE COUNTRY THAT IT'S THE CITY COUNCIL'S RESPONSIBILITY TO DO IT.
THEY, THEY ACT IN THAT CAPACITY.
THE, THE IDEAL SITUATION OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE ADDS THAT EXTERNAL VIEWPOINT AND THAT EXTERNAL EXPERTISE, UM, WHETHER IT'S A FINANCE FUNCTION OR WHETHER IT'S AN AUDIT FUNCTION OR A GOVERNMENT FUNCTION, YOU KNOW, THOSE PEOPLE ADD THAT ADDITIONAL VIEWPOINT TO THE PROCESS.
SO THAT'S WHAT WE BELIEVE THE ADVANTAGE TO BE TO AN AUDIT COMMITTEE STRUCTURED THAT WAY VERSUS JUST A, UH, JUST THE MEMBERS OF COUNCIL.
AND WHAT WOULD A MEMBERSHIP OF AN AUDIT COMMITTEE TYPICALLY ENTAIL? UM, TYPICALLY WHAT I'VE SEEN IS THAT IT USUALLY INCLUDES, UM, YOU KNOW, TWO TO THREE MEMBERS OF THE GOVERNING BOARD, DEPENDING ON HOW BIG IT IS.
AND THEN ANYWHERE FROM TWO TO THREE TO FOUR EXTERNAL MEMBERS.
UM, AND ALL THAT KIND OF DEPENDS TOO ON, ON WHAT YOUR LEGAL SITUATION IS LIKE HERE IN OHIO.
IF YOU HAVE, I THINK IF YOU PUT, UH, I THINK IF IT'S FOUR, IF YOU HAVE FOUR MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF EDUCATION IN A PLACE, IT CONSTITUTES A MEETING.
SO THEN IT'S A PUBLIC MEETING THAT THEN REQUIRES PUBLIC DISCLOSURE, PUBLIC ANNOUNCEMENT, ALL THE THINGS THAT GO ALONG WITH THAT, WHICH IS SUPPOSED TO TAKE PLACE.
SO ONE, ONE WAY TO, UM, I DON'T WANT TO GET AROUND IT, BUT ONE WAY TO TO MANAGE THAT IS, IS THAT THERE'S ONLY, UH, WHEN WE HAD, WHEN WE HAD AN AUDIT COMMITTEE, I THINK WE ONLY HAD THREE MEMBERS OF OUR BOARD THAT WERE ASSIGNED TO IT.
AND SO THAT'S A WAY FOR YOU TO BE ABLE TO HAVE THOSE MEETINGS WITHOUT NECESSARILY CONSTRUCTING A COUNCIL, WITHOUT, WITHOUT RIGHT.
IMPLEMENTING OR WITHOUT EXECUTING A PUBLIC, UH, CONS.
HERE IN ARIZONA, IF THIS IS A COUNCIL SPONSORED THING, THEN IT JUST AUTOMATICALLY BECOMES A MEMBER, UH, AN OPEN MEETING.
SO SUBJECT TO THAT, WE, WE HAVE TO WOULD DEAL WITH THAT.
BUT WHEN YOU TALKED ABOUT EXTERNAL MEMBERS, YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT NON-CITY PUBLIC MEMBERS, NOT CITY STAFF MEMBERS ON THE AUDIT COMMITTEE? CORRECT.
YOU'RE, YOU'RE LOOKING FOR COMMUNITY REPRESENTATION ON THAT.
UM, I'D LIKE TO ASK OUR CITY ATTORNEY, IF YOU COULD CLARIFY FOR US WHAT THE AUTHORITY OR SCOPE, UM, CITY COUNCIL WOULD HAVE TO DIRECTLY EMPLOY, UM, AN AUDIT AUDITOR, PERFORMANCE AUDITOR.
SO OUR, UH, CITY CODE, UM, CONSISTENT WITH THE STATE STATUTE HAS SOME, UM, CITY OFFICERS.
WE HAVE SEVEN OFFICERS, UH, AND THREE OF THOSE SEVEN REPORT DIRECTLY TO THE CITY COUNCIL.
AND EACH OF THOSE OFFICES HAS THEIR OWN SEPARATE CITY CODE PROVISION.
SO THOSE BEING CITY CLERK, ATTORNEY, MAGISTRATE, CHIEF OF POLICE, CITY ENGINEER, UM, AND THE COM DEV DIRECTOR, THERE IS A, A CARVE OUT IN THE CITY CODE THAT, UH, FOR ADDITIONAL OFFICERS.
SO, UH, THE COUNCIL MAY APPOINT AND REMOVE, UM, OTHER SUCH OFFICERS AS IT MAY DEEM NECESSARY, AND THAT ARE NOT PROVIDED FOR IN THIS CODE OR A STATE
[03:05:01]
STATUTE.SO SHOULD THE COUNCIL WANNA HAVE A FOURTH, UM, CITY OFFICER REPORTING DIRECTLY TO THE, THE CITY COUNCIL, WE WOULD SIMPLY, UH, NEED TO DO IT BY, UH, ORDINANCE.
UH, AND I WOULD RECOMMEND, UH, CONSISTENT WITH THE OTHER OFFICERS, THEY WOULD HAVE THEIR OWN PROVISION IN THE CITY CODE, THEIR OWN SECTION THAT SPECIFIED WHAT THEIR DUTIES ARE.
BUT ON THE OTHER, UH, YOU KNOW, SIDE OF THE COIN, THE CITY MANAGER HAS AUTHORITY TO, TO, UH, YOU KNOW, APPOINT AND HIRE ALL OTHER CITY, UM, EMPLOYEES, OFFICERS, OR NON OFFICERS.
AND SO FOUR OF THE SEVEN REPORT TO THE CITY MANAGER.
SO IN, IN OUR SITUATION, UM, YOU KNOW, THE MAJORITY OF THE, THE CITY OFFICERS ACTUALLY REPORT TO THE CITY MANAGER WHO HAS THE AUTHORITY OF HIRING.
I ALSO WANTED TO BE CLEAR THAT THAT LANGUAGE WE HAVE IN OUR CODE, WHICH IS 2 3 0 20, IS CONSISTENT WITH A RS 9 2 37, WHICH ALSO GIVES AUTHORIZATION TO CITY COUNCILS TO FORM OTHER OFFICES.
CHARACTERISTICS OF AN EFFECTIVE FUNCTION, ONE CHARACTERISTIC THAT'S CLEARLY, OH MY GOD, THIS IS FOR AMBER.
IF, IF THE WORK IS GONNA BE QUALITY AND THE WORK IS GONNA BE RELIED ON, AND YOU WANT THE WORK TO STAND UP ON ITS OWN, SO THE, THE AUDITOR CLEARLY HAS TO BE INDEPENDENT.
YOU DON'T WANT TO HAVE ANY, UM, YOU DON'T WANT TO HAVE ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT THE INDEPENDENCE OF YOUR AUDITOR BECAUSE THEN IT JUST MINIMIZES AND, AND DEFLECTS FROM THE EFFECTIVENESS OF THE WORK EFFECTIVE FUNCTIONS,
AND THOSE AUDIT STANDARDS ARE TYPICALLY DERIVED.
UM, MOST GOVERNMENT AUDITORS FOLLOW AUDIT STANDARDS TO PREPARE OR PUT OUT BY THE GOVERNMENT, GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTING OFFICE, THE GAO, UM, SOMETIMES REFERRED TO AS THE YELLOW BOOK.
AND NO SURPRISE, REALLY, IT'S BECAUSE THEY PRODUCE A DOCUMENT THAT'S PRODUCED IN A LITTLE YELLOW BOOK.
UM, SIMILARLY, THE INSTITUTE OF INTERNAL AUDITORS IS ALSO ANOTHER SET OF PROFESSIONAL STANDARDS THAT, UM, ARE FOLLOWED BY LOCAL GOVERNMENT AUDITORS.
UH, THEIRS ARE CONTAINED IN A RED BOOK BECAUSE THEY PUBLISH IT IN A RED BOOK, BUT THOSE ARE VERY SPECIFIC PROFESSIONAL AUDITING STANDARDS.
SO EFFECTIVE FUNCTIONS WILL FOLLOW THOSE ONE, TYPICALLY ONE OF THOSE, THERE ARE OTHER ONES, BUT THE, THE POINT IS, IS THAT THERE IS SOME LEVEL OF PROFESSIONAL AUDIT STANDARD THAT IS ADHERED TO WHEN THEY DO THE WORK.
UH, THE WORK'S CARRIED OUT BY PROFESSIONAL CERTIFIED STAFF.
YOU'RE LOOKING FOR SOMEONE WHO IS EITHER A CERTIFIED INTERNAL AUDITOR, A CERTIFIED PUBLIC ACCOUNTANT, UM, SOME LEVEL OF PROFESSIONAL CERTIFICATION.
COULD BE A CERTIFIED RISK MANAGER, COULD BE A CERTIFIED, UM, GOVERNMENT AUDIT PROFESSIONAL.
UM, THERE ARE A NUMBER OF CERTIFICATIONS, BUT IN THE IDEA IS THAT YOU HAVE, YOU HAVE CERTIFIED STAFF THAT, THAT INDICATE AND DEMONSTRATE A LEVEL OF COMPETENCY AS WELL AS, UH, ARE SUBJECT TO ONGOING TRAINING SO THAT THEY'RE ABLE TO MAINTAIN THAT LEVEL OF COMPETENCY AND PROVIDE HIGH QUALITY WORK.
EFFECTIVE FUNCTIONS ARE ADEQUATELY BUDGETED AND HAVE ADEQUATE RESOURCES.
YOU KNOW, SO WHETHER THAT'S THE FINANCIAL BUDGET THAT'S PROVIDED TO THE OFFICE SO THAT IT CAN CARRY OUT FUNCTION AS WELL AS RESOURCES EITHER IN THE NUMBER OF BODIES OR ACCESS TO ADDITIONAL FINANCIAL RESOURCES TO CARRY OUT THE WORK PLAN.
UM, KEVIN, CAN I ASK YOU A QUESTION? WHAT IS ADEQUATE BUDGET AND RESOURCES? WHAT IS A TYPICAL SIZE OF A FUNCTION LIKE THIS FOR, UH, THE SIZE OF, OF WHAT? THE SIZE OF THE CITY OF SEDONA.
NOW I, I THINK FOR CLARIFICATION, SHE'S ASKING LIKE, WHAT WOULD ADEQUATE BUDGET LOOK LIKE FOR THIS FUNCTION? NORMALLY, UM, AN ADEQUATE BUDGET IS REALLY DEPENDENT ON HOW BIG YOU WISH TO MAKE THE FUNCTION.
I MEAN, IF YOU'RE, IF YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT A CHIEF AUDIT EXECUTIVE, UM, I THINK YOU WOULD DO COMPARISONS OF LIKE, CITIES AND OR CITIES IN YOUR REGION.
UM, AND I CAN'T REALLY SPEAK TO THE NUMBER BECAUSE COST OF LIVING ACROSS THE COUNTRY.
UM, IF YOU'RE TALKING, UH, WELL, THERE ARE, LET ME, LET ME JUST CLARIFY.
THERE ARE NO OTHER CITIES IN OUR REGION THAT HAVE THIS FUNCTION.
SO WHAT, WHAT WOULD IT, HOW MUCH STAFF WOULD YOU REQUIRE TO DO THE, WE, WE DON'T HAVE ANYBODY TO LOOK TO, TO IN OUR REGION.
'CAUSE THEY DON'T HAVE SUCH A FUNCTION.
LET ME HELP YOUR MAYOR IN THAT.
WHAT HE'S, HE'S GONNA GET TO MODELS.
[03:10:01]
ONE OF THOSE MODELS IS A HYBRID MODEL, WHICH IS A SINGLE PERSON THAT COULD DO SOME WORK.AND IF MORE WORK WAS NEEDED, COULD HAVE SOME CONTRACTING AUTHORITY TO DO SOME WORK.
SO IT COULD BE AS LITTLE AS ONE SENIOR MANAGER A, YOU KNOW, AT A, A, A, A COUNCIL APPOINTEE WHO RUNS THE OPERATION AND COULD DO ALL OF THE WORK IF THAT PERSON COULD DO THE WORKLOAD THAT COUNCIL WISHES THEM TO DO.
OR IT MIGHT BE MORE THAN THAT IF COUNCIL WISHES THEM TO DO MORE THAN THAT AMOUNT OF WORK, IF THAT HELPS.
IS THAT YOUR ANSWER, KEVIN? WELL, I MEAN, IT REALLY IS DEPENDENT ON, ON HOW MUCH WORK YOU WANT TO GET DONE AND HOW MANY BODIES YOU WANT TO APPLY TO THE WORK.
UM, A LOT OF THAT IS ALSO BASED ON WHAT YOUR RISK ASSESSMENT MIGHT LOOK LIKE.
IF YOUR RISK ASSESSMENT IDENTIFIES, UM, A SIGNIFICANT NUMBER OF AREAS THAT ARE COMPLICATED AREAS, WELL THEN YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT MORE RESOURCES THAN IF YOU WERE, IF YOU WERE A, A SMALL TOWNSHIP AND ALL THEY DID WAS, YOU KNOW, PAVE ROADS AND, UM, COLLECT, YOU KNOW, SOME LEVEL OF PROPERTY TAX THAT'S NOT NEARLY AS SOPHISTICATED OR COMPLICATED AS, AS SAY, THE CITY OF SEDONA THAT HAS, YOU KNOW, I UNDERSTAND YOU GUYS HAVE A PARKING GARAGE.
YOU HAVE MAYBE SOME SENIOR SERVICES AND SOME OTHER SERVICES THAT YOU DO THAT ARE GONNA BE MORE COMPLICATED.
SO THE MORE COMPLICATED YOU GET, THE MORE AUDIT RESOURCES YOU'RE LIKELY LOOKING AT BECAUSE YOU'RE PROBABLY FACING HIGHER RISKS OR GREATER RISKS, MORE SIGNIFICANT RISKS.
SO, I I, I'M NOT TRYING TO REALLY DODGE YOUR QUESTION, IT'S JUST THAT IT IS, IT IS VERY DEPENDENT ON WHAT IT IS YOU WANT TO ACCOMPLISH.
I DO RECOMMEND, YOU KNOW, SINCE YOU'RE, YOU'RE STARTING, I DO RECOMMEND STARTING SMALL.
THERE'S NO NEED TO, THERE'S NO NEED TO COMMIT TO SOMETHING EXTRAORDINARILY LARGE AT THIS POINT.
THE IMPORTANT THING IS, IS THAT YOU'RE CONSIDERING THE FUNCTION AND YOU WANT TO PUT SOME LEVEL OF FUNCTION IN PLACE, AND THEN YOU CAN GROW THE FUNCTION AS NECESSARY.
BUT, BUT STARTING THE FUNCTION WILL THEN START TO HELP YOU ANSWER THOSE QUESTIONS OF DO WE NEED MORE THAN WHAT IT IS WE'VE GOT HERE? AND WHAT DOES MORE LOOK LIKE? WHAT CAN WE AFFORD? WHAT CAN WE NOT AFFORD RIGHT NOW? WHAT MIGHT BE THE PLAN FOR, YOU KNOW, THE NEXT THREE TO FIVE YEARS? AND EXPANDING IT IF WE THINK WE WANT TO EXPAND IT.
BUT STARTING THE FUNCTION AND HAVING SOMEONE AVAILABLE TO YOU TO GATHER THE INFORMATION THAT YOU'RE ASKING OF ME AND GATHER IT FOR THE SPECIFIC NEEDS OF THE CITY OF SEDONA WOULD BE EXTRAORDINARILY HELPFUL TO HELP YOU MAKE THOSE DECISIONS OF DO YOU WANT AND NEEDS TO EXPAND.
IF I COULD ASK ANOTHER QUESTION RELATIVE TO THIS SLIDE, EFFECTIVE FUNCTION.
CAN YOU DESCRIBE HOW AUDITORS AND CITY STAFF WORK TOGETHER? WHETHER THERE'S COLLABORATION OR NOT? IS IT COMPLETELY INDEPENDENT? WHAT'S THE DEPENDENCY HERE IN THE RELATIONSHIPS IN A WELL-FUNCTIONING OFFICE BETWEEN THE HEAD AUDITOR AND THE CITY MANAGER MANAGER? UM, I'LL TELL YOU FROM MY EXPERIENCE, IT REALLY DEPENDS ON WHAT YOUR ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE IS LIKE.
UM, I HAVE SEEN INSTANCES WHERE THE AUDITOR AND CITY MANAGEMENT, UM, HAVE A VERY ADVERSARIAL RELATIONSHIP BECAUSE THEY BOTH, ONE MIGHT SEE ONE AS BEING IMPINGING UPON THE OTHER, OR ONE MIGHT THINK THAT THE OTHER'S PLAYING A GOTCHA GAME.
UM, I'VE ALSO SEEN IT WHERE IT CAN BE A VERY HEALTHY RELATIONSHIP AND THAT BOTH SIDES RECOGNIZE THE PROFESSIONALISM AND THE DESIRE TO ADVANCE THE ORGANIZATION AND HOW THEY CAN LEVERAGE EACH OTHER BY DOING THAT.
UM, I'VE SEEN MANAGEMENT VERY MUCH EMBRACE AUDIT JOBS IN CERTAIN PLACES BECAUSE THEY RECOGNIZE THAT NOT JUST DOESN'T PROVIDE FEEDBACK TO COUNCIL.
IT CAN PROVIDE FEEDBACK ON THEIR OWN OPERATIONS.
AND IF THEY'RE VERY MUCH INTERESTED IN IDENTIFYING WHAT THEIR OWN GAPS MIGHT BE AND HOW TO IMPROVE THOSE GAPS, RECOGNIZING THAT ALL OF US, YOU KNOW, AS GOOD AS WE MIGHT THINK WE ARE, IT DOESN'T HURT TO HAVE ANOTHER SET OF EYES LOOK AT WHAT IT IS WE DO AND OFFER US FEEDBACK ON THAT.
SO I'VE SEEN, I'VE SEEN THE GAMUT AND IT REALLY DEPENDS.
UM, IT REALLY DEPENDS ON YOUR ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE AND, AND, AND THE BUY-IN THAT PEOPLE INVOLVED IN THE PROCESS HAVE TOWARDS ADVANCING THE ORGANIZATION.
THERE'S NOTHING, UH, TERRIBLY COMPLICATED ABOUT ANY OF THEM AS THEIR NAMES MIGHT SUGGEST.
[03:15:01]
THAT IS FULLY IN-HOUSE, ONE THAT'S FULLY OUTSOURCED, AND ONE THAT IS AN IN-HOUSE FUNCTION THAT HAS AVAILABILITY OF BOTH OUTSOURCING AND CO-SOURCING.UM, I'M GONNA TALK ON THE NEXT COUPLE OF SLIDES ABOUT SOME OF THE ADVANTAGES OF